From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 1–Down on the farm, a gaggle of shiny, white geese teases a dirty, little goose. However, when the moon is full, he is the one the fox does not chase because his muddy feathers blend in with the shadows. Soon all the geese begin to bathe in the muddy pond. When winter comes, the dirty goose cleans himself up until he gleams and shines, and the fox doesn't notice him against the snow, enabling the little hero to kick the predator down a hill. The other geese praise his smarts, making him feel part of the gaggle at last. The simple, playful text is full of fun sound effects and repeated phrases. Church also conveys much emotion and feeling through the fluid, bold lines of her cartoon illustrations. Various textured papers as backgrounds help give the images depth. Young children will applaud this endearing tale with its clever and resourceful protagonist. Pair it with Richard Waring's
Hungry Hen (HarperCollins, 2001), also illustrated by Church, for a storytime featuring barnyard underdogs.–
Rachel G. Payne, Brooklyn Public Library, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
PreS-Gr. 2. The smart (but dirty) goose of the title has perfected the art of camouflage. The other bright-white geese fear the fox on moonlit nights, but the dirty goose walks unafraid. When the others learn the secret, they leap into a muddy pond. As time goes by, the weather grows cold. The little goose finds a clean pond and scrubs its feathers, but it can't convince the others to do the same. Then snow falls, the moon rises, and the fox chases the dirty geese--until the clean goose outfoxes him once and for all. The clever story will hold the attention of young children, but the illustrations are the book's most striking feature. Bold black lines define the forms of the geese, the fox, and the setting, while textured papers, bits of smudgy print, and collage elements enrich the simple compositions. Visually appealing, this provides an excellent early introduction to the concept of camouflage in nature as well as a narrative worth repeat readings.
Carolyn PhelanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved