Most Helpful Customer Reviews
36 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Inspector Yashim, the Turkish impotentate, returns, October 30, 2007
Jason Goodwin's second book "The Snake Stone" sees the return of the Turkish, crime-solving eunuch Yashim Togalu. I'm pleased to report that Goodwin's second book was as fun to read as his first, The Janissary Tree: A Novel".
As befits a mystery set in Istanbul the plot of "The Snake Stone" is moderately Byzantine but not so complex that the reader gets lost. Yashim is approached by a French archeologist (of the plundering sort) who tells Yashim a story about some priceless antiquities. Shortly thereafter the man is found dead and since Yashim is the last man to see him alive he finds himself faced with the prospect of being a suspect in the murder. Yashim has no choice but to try to unravel the mystery.
Two aspects of the book deserve special praise. As noted, the plot revolves around the possible discovery of priceless antiquities and this is a perfect device for a book set in a city such as Istanbul one of the world's historic cross-roads. The plot gives Goodwin a great opportunity to `explore' Istanbul's rich and diverse history both archeologically and socially. Goodwin studied Byzantine history at Cambridge and has written books on the history of the Ottoman Empire ( Lords of the Horizons: A History of the Ottoman Empire and his writing evidences that knowledge. Goodwin puts his knowledge to good use as he paints a very readable picture of Istanbul that captures (for me at least) the sights, sounds, and smells of Istanbul's streets and alleys while also conveying a sense of the political and social backdrop that drove the characters in the book. Anytime a writer gives you the sense that you can almost get a visceral feel for the sights and sounds of a city that writer has done a good job.
Second, Goodwin has done an excellent job in developing the character of Yashim. Yashim is now, in the second book, a fully formed and very endearing character. The minor recurring characters are equally engaging. Last, Yashim isn't the first detective to be a gourmet cook but I have to say the descriptions of Yashim's recipes were very enticing.
In my review of "The Janissary Tree" I mentioned that Goodwin's Yashim reminded me of Boris Akunin's Erast Fandorin novels (late 19th-century Russia such as The Winter Queen: A Novel (Erast Fandorin Mysteries)) and Arturo Perez-Reverte's Captain Alatriste stories such as Captain Alatriste (17th-century Spain). They all take the standard detective or mystery story and transport the reader to a different time and place. "The Snake Stone" confirms my original impression that Goodwin's books belong in that good company. "The Snake Stone" was an excellent story and anyone who likes a good detective story with a bit of an exotic twist should enjoy it. L. Fleisig
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Byzantine Treat, November 30, 2007
As the subtitle says, 'Investigator Yashim Returns' to solve another mystery in the Istanbul of the 1830's. Historian-turned-novelist Jason Goodwin concocts another intriguing tale based on the sound footing he established last year in The Janissary Tree: A Novel.
Yashim Togalu, the eunuch detective, is forced into the investigation of the brutal murder of a French archaeologist when suspicion turns on Yashim, the last person known to have seen the man Lefevre alive.
As he did in The Janissary Tree, Goodwin again entwines his story around the history of the era. But Goodwin's strongest suit may be his ability to surround the reader with sensory experiences of the streets of Istanbul; the sights, the sounds, the smells and tastes. The varied peoples and their styles come alive. And not only on the streets, but also under the streets - the meticulously maintained and ancient waterworks of Istanbul (and their Albanian maintainers) play a large part in this story.
Moreover, the mystery that Goodwin unravels for the reader is quite appropriately byzantine with several dead alleys and an ending that...well, I go too far. Another enjoyable and slightly offbeat treat. Highly recommended.
[Postscript: I see that Len Flesig beat me to the review here and was tempted to simply say "read Len's review" as they are always excellent. I offer my own comments out of a habit that approaches compulsion, albeit an enjoyable one.]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Eunuch Detective with the Modern Sensibility, December 1, 2007
It is the Summer of 1839 and the Ottoman Sultan lays dying in his palace. In the ten years since the Greeks have won their independence, Ottoman Turkey has become known as the "Sick Man of Europe". Its European neighbors are contemplating the Empire's dismemberment and nationalist feelings are awakening in the Balkans. It is a time of great political and economic uncertainty. Into this tense situation enters a French archaeologist searching for Byzantine treasures that hold great symbolic meaning to the Greek subjects of the Ottoman Empire. Yashim Togalu, a eunuch who conducts discreet investigations for the powerful is put on the archaeologist's trail. Thus begins Jason Goodwin's sequel to the Edgar Award wining, "Janissary Tree".
The Investigator Yashim Series has a lot going for it. Instanbul and its world of royal intrigue, harems and political uncertainty is as exotic a setting as any mystery series has ever had. It is a real pleasure to follow Yashim as he navigates the inner court yards of the Royal Palace and the mean streets of Instanbul's toughest neighborhoods. Jason Goodwin's ably opens a window into an interesting time and place.
Alas, I can only give this book four stars. One would think that a Nineteenth Century, Ottoman eunuch would be as alien as any person from the distant past could be. Yet, Goodwin has created a detective hero with a Twenty First Century sensibility. Not only is Yashim a Stendhal reading gourmand, he has great multicultural and transgender sensitivity credentials. European beauties find him irresistable and older powerful women find him to be a sensitive friend. Dare say, there is something metrosexual about Yashim Togalu. When I read a great detective series, I want to lose myself in the time and place. Unfortunately, Yashim's modern sensibilities keep me from losing myself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|