Customer Reviews

The Snow Day

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

You know when a picture book is successful? When it can conjure up a feeling or a memory you didn't even know you had. I remember playing in the snow at night as a small child. The contrast of bright white snow lit by the streetlights, and the jet-black sky above. In my experience, picture books that deal with simple subjects generally have a hard road to hoe. They either are accused of glutting the market with more of the same, or they are so unique that they're told that they won't find their readership. I find it hard to believe that "The Snow Day" by Komako Sakai will share either of these fates, though. A Japanese import from the creator of the equally compelling and mesmerizing "Emily's Balloon", Sakai's title turns gray to gold. Any child who has ever watched flakes fall in rapid succession is going to get a kick out of this book. A title capable of finding the dreamlike beauty in stark reality.

When a little rabbit wakes up early one morning its mother assures it that there's no reason to get up. "Kindergarten's closed. It's been snowing all night, and the school bus got stuck." A snow day! But rather than be allowed to run outside, the rabbit's mother informs it that it will have to wait until the snowflakes stop falling. So together they play cards and watch the flakes fall from the balcony. At night the little rabbit is just about to go to bed when it realizes that the snow has stopped falling. So together, in the well-lit dark, the two of them go outside to play in the snow. They'll play again tomorrow, and tomorrow daddy (stuck in an airport) will be home, "because it stopped snowing."

Since we are dealing with a child wearing a snowsuit playing in a mass of white fluffiness there are bound to be people who equate it with "The Snowy Day" by Ezra Jack Keats. That's an unfair comparison on so many levels, though. I mean, both books have that slow, methodical feeling you get when you walk outside and the sounds of the world are hushed by the fall of the flakes. When the little rabbit in the book says, "Mommy, we are all alone in the world," that could sound twee or quaint, but instead it feels exactly right. Snow reinforces the loneliness that comes with silence. And while Keats chose to beautify the ugliness of a city with his white canvass, Sakai seems far more interested in beautifying the seeming ugliness of an apartment complex. It's a different world and it inspires a wholly different feel. Keats' book was all about experiencing the snow. Sakai's book is all about waiting to experience it.

My edition of this book did not say how the art was made, but we can infer a little. Some paint looks like it came into play. The clusters of snowflakes falling as light masses of white are definitely painted. Crayon also looks like it was a medium. The moment when the little rabbit changes into a snowsuit (ears on his hoodie and all), a single red crayon line curls and pools on the ground, becoming the red stretch of yarn that connects one red mitten to another. And is that a thick smear of some kind of oil-based crayon or paint I see as well? It's hard to say. Whatever its make-up might be, the book's illustrations bring to life that cool gray light that comes on overcast days. The kind of light that seeps into every corner of your home, no matter how many lamps you turn on to banish it. I am always impressed by an artist's skill with figures and landscapes, but lighting is the hardest of these. And the most impressive.

Sakai has cleverly avoided giving the little rabbit a gender. Lest you doubt me, this is not an easy thing to do. It takes a very very particular art style to make a convincing any-old-gender-will-do child in a book, regardless of what animal they might be. The downside to this is that because the artist has made the bunnies here look pretty much like real bunnies, however, they initially appear to be a touch expressionless. As the story continues, however, their faces melt a little, as when the little rabbit jumps out of bed for joy, or when the two go outside and make snow dumplings and monsters. Particularly in the latter scene there's a great image of the mother rabbit watching over her little one, an identical smile on both their faces.

Children understand waiting. They don't like it, but they understand it. They may not all know what snow days are like, or even what snow itself is, but the feeling of having to wait to do something fun is universal. This book is universal. A class unto itself, if you want to get lofty about it. If these are the picture books the Japanese are putting out these days, I think we should demand to have more of them translated and put on our bookstore and library shelves. A book that will please both grown-up and child and happens to be a little beautiful, just for kicks.

The little bunny peeked up over the covers as his mother looked in on him. She told him that he could sleep in because Kindergarten had been closed due to snow. "It's been snowing all night, and the school bus got stuck." He jumped out of bed anxious to rush out and play in the snow, but his mother thought he might catch a cold and wanted him to wait. He snuck outside on the balcony to watch the snow and made a "little snow dumpling." The snow continued to come down and it looked like one of those inside days.

They played cards and there was so much snow that "Daddy's flight got canceled, and he couldn't get home." Mommy turned away from him and held a tissue to her lips in worry. The snow continued to swirl and activity in the city seemed to come to a standstill. "Mommy, we are all alone in the world." Night time came and it was time to get ready for bed. He realized that he had not been outside to play in the snow. Would Mommy agree to let him go outside and play even if it was dark out?

I loved the tone of this book. Both the text and the beautiful art work catch the gloominess and the worry of a snow day when school is closed and a parent cannot come home because a flight has been cancelled. Children are often forgotten when things are rushed or tense in the home as in the case of this absent Daddy, but this little bunny's Mommy understood and let her child do something to comfort him that normally would have been out of the question. Children often see snow days as fun days, but sometimes they are just the opposite. This book can be one of joy to a child or can be used as a cuddle up comfort one just as easily.

This is a great book for kids. My daughter loves to pull this book off the shelf when it's snowing out! Great illustrations and wonderful story!

Kiwi Magazine Review:
Gorgeous illustrations are the hallmark of this book about the timeless excitement of snow appearing and closing school. Unlike the Snowy Day by Ezra Jack Keats, this mama makes her child wait until the snow stops falling to go outside and play just before bedtime.

[...]

This is one of the best children's books ever, and the illustrations are absolutely exquisite. Reading this book with my 3 year old daughter is like stepping into a memory, a feeling; you can literally feel the snow, the moment, the silence, the closeness between mother and child. There are reviews on here that say it wasn't written for a child, but I can vouch that my daughter actually wants to meet these bunnies. When I told her that I might not be able to arrange that, she started to cry. She wants to "jump" into the book with them; she wants to look at the pictures and hear me read it over an over again. It's simple, magical, an universal. I highly recommend it.

Upon the first reading of this book, I absolutely loved the illustrations. They capture the essence of being trapped in a snow storm - the dark, dreary snow that seems like it will never end. But the young rabbit wants to play. He is disappointed that daddy's flight is delayed. But when the snow finally stops falling, mommy and bunny have great fun outside. Great illustrations and an excellent story. Even in translations this is a great book for young readers.

This may be my favorite book to read to my son......the message is simple and sweet and the artwork is by FAR my favorite of any children's book I've read. (and I've read a ton!) We live in Florida and my son has never seen snow, but I grew up in Virginia and remember "snow days." It's a neat book to get the point across to my son of what it feels like to be stuck inside all day and not be able to leave. (and my dad would be stuck away by the snow, too.) It's a great way to begin a conversation with a child about feelings, fears and the fun of playing in the snow!

Amazing that a book about such a cold snow could be so warm. And, as I said, the artwork is phenomenal!!

The feelings of a small child are here. But,it is not geared towards children in practice rather than in theory.

Perhaps using a small child instead of a blobby bunny might have given this the universal feel the author is aiming for with the bunny. But instead the juxtaposition of an animal on a very real world somehow clashes.

Sorry, no one has ever done it better than Ezra Jack Keats did it in The Snowy Day. You can read that to a bunch of 2009 high tech, overstimulated preschoolers and they will still thrill to the emotion it evokes.

This one is an exquisite work of art--you could hang some of the illustrations in an art gallery. But it just doesn't have the heart and soul of a children's picture book.