Customer Reviews

Socionomics: The Science of History and Social Prediction

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

It's been painfully obvious for over three years that the standard approach of economic forecasters, who examine every newly released government statistic to divine the next lurch of the stock market, has been less than stellar. Almost none of those who today talk about the "technology bubble" actually called for a top in 2000, the recession of 2001 wasn't recognized until it was half a year old, and in spite of a chorus of calls for an incipient recovery it seems plenty of skepticism remains about economic prospects. The reason for this forecasting disconnect is obvious, according to Robert Prechter, Jr.

Prechter's newest title, Socionomics: The Science of History and Social Prediction is a two-book set that offers voluminous support for a revolutionary concept. It reverses the direction of causality that underpins the entirety of orthodox market forecasting with a radical thesis: Instead of the economic statistics leading the market, the market (or more properly the aggregate social mood it measures) determines economic behavior that leads to the statistics.

Though a simple statement, this is heady stuff when its full ramifications are considered. This is exactly what this set does, addressing both theory (Wave Principle of Human Social Behavior, 2nd ed.) and its application (Pioneering Studies in Socionomics, a new work). Its illustrations of this reversal of causality cannot be casually dismissed, nor should they be ignored by anyone who believes timing matters in business, politics, investing, or every other aspect of life.

Socionomics is Prechter's term for the application of Ralph Nelson Elliott's Wave Principle market model to a wider array of social phenomena (see reviews of Elliott Wave Principle). Prechter has taken this principle and, along with colleagues both within and without his Elliott Wave International market forecasting firm, developed it into an early stage science in its own right. Pioneering Studies in Socionomics is a compilation that represents their work, a series of related studies which run from the 1980s and forward to 2002. Most were published as part of Prechter's Elliott Wave Theorist newsletter. Sequential dating of some studies offers a particularly detailed timeline for their conclusions, allowing readers to assess the validity of the observations in retrospect. The result borders on amazing.

Pioneering Studies is quite a departure from Prechter's other recent work, Conquer the Crash. While the latter deals almost exclusively with the financial arena, this latest book leaves the world of finance and ventures out into the wider arena of human endeavor.

Noting that certain social outcomes occur against a backdrop of specific market behaviors, socionomics attempts to make objective forecasts for the kinds of events that should occur as the market and its social mood "Pied Piper" follow their tortuous path through time.

That "torturous path" is where the greater controversy rages. Adherents of Elliott Wave methodology believe that markets follow a fractal pattern and that the market's current position in the wave pattern can often be estimated with a significant level of confidence. Knowing "where you most probably are" gives tremendous guidance in discerning the likeliest path for future market action. Detractors observe that there are always multiple, correct interpretations of where in the pattern the current market resides, so they claim application of the process to forecasting is simply too subjective to be useful.

Prechter's socionomics hypothesis starts with the Wave Principle and so raises two separate questions. Does the stock market reflect aggregate social mood, which precedes and drives social outcomes as varied as fashion, war and peace, economic activity, and even sex, according to socionomics, or are all these social factors dependent upon outside influences like unemployment rates and durable goods orders that can be discerned and used for forecasting in the orthodox method? And even if social mood is the driver of social outcomes, is the social mood patterned and therefore subject to forecast by analyzing the stock indexes, or is the path a "random walk" that precludes accurate forecasting at all?

The answer to the first question, as far as economic forecasting is concerned, can be determined by simply turning to the article titled, "Socionomics in a Nutshell." If a picture is worth a thousand words, the graph found in figure 1 is a picture equal to the sum of all the words uttered each year by economists on TV and in print. It bears a graph of the Dow Jones Industrial Average from the late 1920s to 2000 with shaded bars depicting periods of recession. With one exception (1946, which supports neither case), every recession during the period coincides with or follows a significant decline in the Dow. With this single graph, Prechter shows that asking an economist to forecast the direction of the market using economic statistics is about as silly as asking a passenger to predict how hard the driver will press the accelerator pedal ten seconds in the future by watching the speedometer now. All that is needed is to watch the stock market. If it's rallying, economic expansion will follow, while persistent, larger-scale declines presage economic contraction.

Pioneering Studies addresses topics both light and serious, tracing the connections between the social mood as demonstrated by the stock market with the fortunes of horror films, professional sports, terrorism and war. Events such as 9/11 are addressed in a way that brings coherence to what otherwise looks like chaos.

Anyone who recognizes the value of timing in their endeavors would be wise to consider the message delivered by this latest from Elliott Wave's most articulate exponent. Our times appear to be getting more "interesting," in the sense of the age-old curse (May you live in interesting times) and Prechter's method, thoroughly addressed in this set, offers a unique and useful perspective. This two-volume set should also be the starting point for a broader investigation of socionomics, with an eye toward its establishment as a new field of study in its own right.

This is a two book set, a bit pricy, but I read it for months. It's a detailed, interesting book. The author could have cut it way down and made it just a quick overview, but I'm glad it was a more detailed version, like it is. I read the interview on First Voice (www.7to7.net) and thought Prechter sounded interesting. He's obviously very smart. He makes his living doing stock market analysis, and has written other books about the market, which doesn't interest me.
This book covers a lot of ground about how people interact. I've always wondered about the madness of crowds. This book gave me a completely different outlook on why people act the way they do and why I need to be aware of it.
Very good book. You'll keep this one for a long time.

This is a 2 volume set, and it is long. The first book is in my opinion the better of the two. It goes into great detail about Socionomics and makes a very convincing augment. This book has shown the light on many things, and it is not simply geared to the stock market. I do believe in Elliot Wave, but do not trade by it as I have found it impractical. It has been most useful in my dealings with groups or organizations, how people think and will act based on their perceptions, even if they are wrong. Mr. Prechter does an excellent job driving home the human herding concept. It makes reading about the political actions in the newspaper make so much more sense now, and should provide future insight for years to come.

The best way to really describe the first book is an academic text book one would read in college, and at times the reading gets to be a bit heavy. And I would be remiss in this review not to mention Phi, and how he has tied it into nearly every aspect of nature. Completely fascinating!!! It has been a year since I read these and I can still recall the lessons in this book.

The second book I never made it through, I got about half way and finally gave up. It is all short essays/articles backed with newspaper clippings trying to show how the first book knew what it was talking about. If you understood the first book, there is little point in re-reading the same material presented in a different manner. However, I guess if you did not get the first book, the second may appeal to you instead.

Overall, this is a good purchase, if solely for its ability to point out what people around you will do based on actions and events surrounding them, right or wrong.

The previous reviewer really says it all, but I felt I would add to the commentary by posting my own 5 star, because this new boxed set truly deserves it.
As a fellow "Elliottician" for a number of years now I can say with great confidence that (especially for the new reader) Prechter's new boxed set is simply the best study and most complete explanation to "how things really work" that is currently out there. (Until, of course, I publish *my* studies, ha ha, just kidding Bob)
As I've often noted in previous reviews on Elliott Wave, the biggest problem is...most people just don't "get it"... Elliott Wave and is SO MUCH MORE than the financial markets. The fundamental discoveries that govern the Wave Principle and thus the behavior of the financial markets are the very same fundamental forces at work throughout the entire universe! Who cares about making a few bucks in the stupid stock market when, if you have a deep understanding of the Wave Principle, Socionomics, and science in general, you can begin to see how everything around us all ties together to form this awesome grand scheme of life and existance. A deep understanding of Elliott Wave and Fibonacci is the key to opening a whole new world of knowledge, application, and the birth of a new science!
With the publishing of this boxed set, I hope more people can come to realize that the universe is indeed a truly beautiful place and man has a deep intimate connection with it.
This boxed set is only the beginning of the wealth of knowledge that can be mined in this area. You just have to know what to look for, and these books give you an excellent foundation.

Today, thanks to the genius of Robert Prechter, we have a chance of understanding the R.N. Elliott's own genius which was at root the discovery of the amazing Wave Principle almost 70 years ago when pencils and rulers were used instead of today's advanced computers. I am convinced that years and decades from now, when awareness and acceptance of the Elliott Wave Principle will increase to more appropriate levels, Robert Prechter's contribution in taking "the word out" and laying the foundation for one of the most revolutionary sciences ever, will be self-evidently immense.

"The Science of History and Social Prediction" is the most monumental piece of work you will have probably read in your entire life. It certainly fits this bill as far as I am concerned because it challenged everything I thought I knew in respect of understanding the social realm and because it helped refine and redefine my knowledge about financial markets and the importance of understanding societal impact of financial trends. It is absolutely obvious that the set is the result of an elaborated work that lasted many years for which I can only congratulate the author and his crew.

Bob Prechter's sustained effort to do justice to the theory he adores finally morphed into one outstandingly coherent explanation of how human social behavior is patterned and why is it important to be aware of where we stay in the overall social cycle at any one point in time.The lecture will be nothing but enjoyable thanks to Bob's fascinating style to put ideas on paper and to the brilliantly logic manner in which arguments are exposed along the way. It is a must read if you ever want to gain a competitive advantage in a surrounding social setting in which impulsive herding can occasionally be utterly destructive to your own self.

A big thanks to Bob for having shared with us his outstanding work!

Prechter uses Elliott Wave principle to demonstrate the ebb and flow of social mood and the cultural consequences in movies, music, literature, clothing styles and other phenomenon observed over the decades. His analysis is useful in predicting what cultural trends will be occurring in the future as well as explaining current trends. I found the book fascinating in its depth and simplicity. Socionomics should be the center of cultural studies. Only Prechter could bring what could otherwise be very dry subject matter to life in this book. A must read for politicians, business owners, designers, music industry execs, movie studio execs and anyone who wants to see what is going on with "the herd."

If you are tired of looking at every problem / situation "as a nail", because your only tool is a hammer, this work offers some exciting possibilities.

The author has given a mathematical as well as a psychological explanation of the stock markets and many areas of human behaviour. This work will give you great insight into yourself, your own motivations and behaviours. Of course, introspection is not something everybody has the mental or emotional stamina to undertake.

Bold ideas and alternative explanations of human events, as well as human behaviour are explained with both infallible logic as well as a fair amount of scientific evidence.

It is clear that Prechter is a firm believer in the Wave Principle, but the book is far from the product of a man with an agenda of a secret mission. The overall impression is that the author has discovered something important that he wishes to share with the rest of the world.

If you enjoy learning what motivates people and how society works - it will be a good read.

Today, thanks to the genius of Robert Prechter, we have a chance of understanding the R.N. Elliott's own genius which was at root the discovery of the amazing Wave Principle almost 70 years ago when pencils and rulers were used instead of today's advanced computers. I am convinced that years and decades from now, when awareness and acceptance of the Elliott Wave Principle will increase to more appropriate levels, Robert Prechter's contribution in taking "the word out" and laying the foundation for one of the most revolutionary sciences ever, will be self-evidently immense.

"The Science of History and Social Prediction" is the most monumental piece of work you will have probably read in your entire life. It certainly fits this bill as far as I am concerned because it challenged everything I thought I knew in respect of understanding the social realm and because it helped refine and redefine my knowledge about financial markets and the importance of understanding societal impact of financial trends. It is absolutely obvious that the set is the result of an elaborated work that lasted many years for which I can only congratulate the author and his crew.

Bob Prechter's sustained effort to do justice to the theory he adores finally morphed into one outstandingly coherent explanation of how human social behavior is patterned and why is it important to be aware of where we stay in the overall social cycle at any one point in time.The lecture will be nothing but enjoyable thanks to Bob's fascinating style to put ideas on paper and to the brilliantly logic manner in which arguments are exposed along the way. It is a must read if you want to ever gain a competitive advantage in a surrounding social setting in which impulsive herding can occasionally be utterly destructive to your own self.

A big thanks to Bob for having shared with us his outstanding work!

Prechters view is markets peaked in wave 5 in year 2000.
Never called the bottom in 2002, and stated the
high of year 2000 would not be surpassed.
Well 7 years later the DOW has indeed surpassed the year 2000 high!
High of 2000 was ~12000, today it is nearly ~14000 !