Most Helpful Customer Reviews
67 of 71 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beautiful, practical and accurate, August 30, 2005
This review is from: Soehnle Rio Fat, Muscle, Water Analysis Scale (Health and Beauty)
I had been looking for one of these body fat analysis scales, but couldn't find anything that looked good enough to replace my nice glass tray scale, until the Soehnle Rio showed up in my Gold Box (thanks Amazon!).
I have been using it for a few weeks and couldn't be more pleased.
You will probably need to refer to the clear, multiple language manual the first time you use it so you can configure it for multiple people. The scale can remember up to 4 different users, and tells them apart automagically.
Unlike other electronic scales, which require you to power them up and wait for a beep before you step on them, the Rio works like you would expect: just step on it and wait for your weight to appear on the dial. Analysis then follows automatically if the scale "recognizes" you. It turns itself off automatically when you step off.
Don't let the low price fool you: this is a well made, very accurate scale with advanced features that looks gorgeous and couldn't be any easier to use. Nice work Soehnle.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
34 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
looks nice, questionable accuracy of measurements; significant quality control issues, November 14, 2005
This review is from: Soehnle Rio Fat, Muscle, Water Analysis Scale (Health and Beauty)
As a nice looking scale, I'd rate this 5 stars. The weight measurement seems accurate -- very close to the scales at my doctor's office and gym as well as weight measurements that seem to accurately reflect my recent eating habits and exercise habits (ie, when I have eaten a lot and expect to weigh more, I do). I do question how accurate the other measurements are, though. The muscle, fat, and water measurements are highly interdependent which, to some extent, makes sense: If you're well hydrated then you should have a lower body fat percentage. I'm not sure why higher or lower hydration should have such an impact on the muscle measurements, however, and all three measurements can vary enough from weigh-in to weigh-in (even if done in close succession) that I simply think these measurements are more "ball park" guestimates (like the calories burned counters on various cardio equipment) rather than real measurements.
I bought this scale to replace a previous weight and fat measurement device made by Tanita, hoping that this would offer more accurate fat percentage measurements. After using it for the past several weeks, I doubt that it's any more accurate than my previous, considerably less expensive scale.
So my advice to prospective purchasers is that if you want a pretty looking scale that will give you a rough guide as to the other parameters this scale measures beyond body weight, this isn't a bad purchase. If you really only need a body weight scale, however, you can get something that looks as nice for a lot less money and then use something like a tape measurer to get an idea as to how your body measures. (Of course then you need to be honest with yourself as to whether that 18" bicep is mostly fat or muscle!)
Edit on 1/26/09:
I would downgrade this scale's rating considerably now. I had to have my scale replaced about one year after purchase because it stopped doing anything other than basic weight measurement. The first replacement scale sent to me from the manufacturer did not work at all. The second one has just died in the same way as my first scale, just over two years post-replacement. The good news is that the scale comes with a 10-year warranty and the manufacturer has, so far, been good about replacing defective units. The bad news, however, is that the postage to return the defective merchandise comes out of the consumer's pocket. Given that this item isn't light and given that this is the second scale I'm having to return to the manufacturer (they didn't even want back the totally dead one they sent to me), at this rate I figure that I'll end up spending over $20 over the life of the warranty to keep getting scales that work. Factor in the hassle involved in packing the item and taking it to USPS or UPS, I just don't think this scale is worth the hassle. The scale it replaced (I'm glad I still have it) still works fine. I should add that (a) I'm the only person using this Soehlne scale and (b) I have not done anything that could have damaged either scale that broke on me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Great while it lasted!, September 19, 2006
This review is from: Soehnle Rio Fat, Muscle, Water Analysis Scale (Health and Beauty)
The scale is everything the manufacturer claims. However, with minimal use by one average sized adult, our scale lasted only about nine months. The balance part of the scale is very sound, but the battery clip that powers the electronics is poorly designed and built of very cheap components. I suspect that poor Q&A will result in a fairly high percentage of these units failing and recommend that you go elsewhere. Today, my scale will not function unless I hold the batteries by hand (not too practical when someone is standing on it...).
Conclusions:
* Scale design is nice--looks good.
* Construction of balance components is solid, glass is very strong. Design and construction of the power unit (battery) is rather poor.
* Scale functions as advertised for a normal sized (80kg/175lb) adult ... until the battery power clip dies.
* Buyers should avoid this scale in favor of something with more solid battery compartment and connections.
Hope this helps!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|