9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining but flawed, January 25, 2006
This review is from: Software Piracy Exposed (Paperback)
First, I ran across this book in the bookstore, went home, got a
better price, and read it cover to cover. The book was entertaining
as hell. The only part I didn't particularly care for was the
inclusion in the appendix of what was clearly an overview of
current virus, popup, firewalls and other softwares, which I
considered way off the book's subject.
The problem with the book is that it seems entirely unproofed
(unproofread). Spelling errors are rampant, and the author
appeared to lose control of the book in places, writing
"Sentinel was discovered by the FBI in late 1999, who then
called the FBI"
The various clerical errors could have been overlooked. However,
there were so many technical errors and distortions, I was left
wondering if the author was reporting on what he had witnessed
in the "scene" accurately. He reports again and again that
crackers can defeat any program in minutes or hours, then later
relates on programs that remain uncracked. Which is it ? There
are pronouncements about how certain programs cannot be cracked
when they make windows calls, leading to the conclusion that
the author is not aware that even the Windows kernel can be
debugged. The author talks about dongles being "enveloped",
as a "small deciphering machine". It appears that he wasn't
aware that a dongle can have an onboard CPU, or be a simple
ROM accessible by the main computer. The text reads like
an effort to dance around the fact that he didn't
understand the difference.
The other errors, or if you will, "affectations" of the book
are just annoying. The term "ISO" is used many times in the
book as the term for a CD-ROM image on a computer. The author
does, at one point, give the definition of ISO = International
Organization for Standardization, but never gives the full
definition of "ISO 9660" (or similar). Calling a disk image
an "ISO" is like calling an apple "A grocery" because that's
where you got the apple. ISO has hundreds, if not thousands of
standards. I do realize that such misuse of terms is common
on the internet, but I would expect better from a reporter.
The term "warez" is explained: (exaggerated plural derivative
of software). Not bad, but the author repeats this expansion
over and over again like a bad Saturday Night Live skit.
I liked the book, but would warn that there are better books
to really learn how to protect applications against piracy.
My current favorite is "reversing", but Eldad Eilam, but I have
three books on the subject so far, and I unfortunately find I
know more about it than the writers of these books (and not
because I know more than average).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Yo ho, yo ho, a pirate's life for me.., November 25, 2005
This review is from: Software Piracy Exposed (Paperback)
With all the hype currently being generated about digital piracy, I decided it might be interesting to read Software Piracy Exposed by Paul Craig and Mark Burnett. There's an interesting subculture there that's unlike anything I've ever known, and it's not quite what I expected...
Craig spent some time working himself into a position of trust with a number of significant players in the piracy scene. While not participating in the activities himself, he was able to see how cracking and distribution organizations are structured, and what drives the individuals to do what they do. Surprisingly for software piracy, it's not necessarily being able to have and use the software you crack. Mainly it's the bragging rights to say you were the first to crack and distribute the package, or that you have the largest collection and distribution network. I got the distinct impression that most of the hardcore players in this culture don't even have the time to use the software. Since these groups are competing against each other, minutes can be critical in breaking a package open and getting it out first on a network. And as soon as one is done, the next one is waiting. If you spend days cracking something complex and then get beat out by another group by a few minutes, you (and your group) don't get credit for the hack and all the work was wasted. It seems like music and movies are less intense so far as breaking encryption, but a bigger deal to get it out early. Morals and ethics aside, it's a rare look into a strange lifestyle...
While the book is pretty good, it did suffer from some bad basic editing. Acronyms were inconsistently spelled (MP3, Mp3, etc.), and I got tired of seeing the parenthetical description of "warez" showing up time after time. Explain it once at the beginning, and then move on. There were even a couple of times when the explanation of the acronym was just plain wrong. I feel if you're going to publish a technical book, you need to pay attention to these things. Otherwise, it looks shoddy, unprofessional, and rushed. While it wasn't enough to make me dislike the book, it did detract somewhat from what would have been a very good volume otherwise.
Editing aside, it's a worthy read in order to understand the mindset and reality of the piracy and cracking subculture. Software piracy does have a financial effect on copyright owners, but it's not a case of "every copy is a lost sale"...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
