15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A page-turner ..., May 28, 2001
This review is from: A Soldier's Duty: A Novel (Hardcover)
It's a page-turner, especially for military types that give a heck about this man's Army.
I suppose there should be a law on the books somewhere that requires authors who write about the U.S. military to have either been in the U.S. military -- or to be journalists who deploy into war zones more often than the average Joe deploys in a career.
This is a good book. He got the language right by being the first civilian in history to master acronymic milspeak (plus accurate expletive usage). He arrived at the correct assumptions with gender issues (or he talked to a lot of female soldiers that have put up with the rather ubiquitous sexual-harassment drivel that exists in today's military). He even got the right take on the "no psychos allowed" syndrome in the military that goes like this: Seek mental-health assistance and you can say "Bye" to your military career.
And he made it sound as though he may have actually attended one of those dismounted patrols that should have never happened (as in, yep, there are a few patrols -- training, combat, whatever -- that make absolutely no sense).
Although it was hard to get used to at first, some of the best reading would be the total-insubordination events, one of which I would have given at least one body part to have observed (to have observed actually happening with a past, real-world president). Or, maybe it did happen and nobody told me ... big sigh. The exceptional thing he captured while "reporting" on the U.S. military with this novel -- with the keen Somalia-through-Kosovo analogies -- is that some of the unruliness has probably actually occurred (although I would like to think that, in reality, a good sergeant major would lock a few heels, officer or otherwise).
The book hit a personal nerve when he managed to put into words a difficulty I have always had with the whole "charge the old machine-gun nest" thing (time hack: circa the end of the Cold War).
The largest commentary I saw was on the mission creep that has been going in our military for the past fifty or so years with the clowns that think their careers are more important than taking care of subordinates.
Anyway.
Ricks even dings on the media, albeit from a military perspective. :-)
With his first novel, Ricks has displayed an uncanny knack for delving deeply into the U.S. military mind at all levels. His breadth of knowledge about our military "es-tab-lish-ment," our history (which he manages to relate better than some military historians), the District of Columbia, and a number of U.S. military installations -- verges on the incredible.
Finally. A book about the U.S. military that actually says something.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb, tough-minded and authentic!, May 16, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: A Soldier's Duty: A Novel (Hardcover)
Tom Ricks, who just might be the nation's finest military journalist, has written a remarkably-good first novel. Based upon the tensions within today's military and the very real challenges posed by a changing world, Ricks takes lead characters who have just the right feel as examples of today's Army officers and puts them through a kick-butt, hold-on-tight story that takes the reader from commando raids and foreign firefights to the even more vicious combat inside the Pentagon and the government. From oblivious politicians to conniving generals, Ricks gets the Washington scene dead-on, while his details-perfect view of the military, in the field or in office suites, is one of the best I've ever encountered (as a recently-retired officer, I know that world pretty well). So, high praise to Ricks for a tightly-written, faster-than-a-speeding-bullet and very convincing thriller. Highly-recommended for soldiers and civilians. And, by the way, this novel would make a great movie.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Rightest Stuff, May 27, 2001
This review is from: A Soldier's Duty: A Novel (Hardcover)
Let me add to the praise already lavished on Thomas E. Ricks' A Soldier's Duty. In many ways, it is the quintessential moral tale of the post-Soviet, post-modern age.
Mr. Ricks accomplishes a number of extraordinary things with this book. He summarizes a universe of complex contemporary issues in a volume that can be read in a single rainy day. He establishes dramatic tension from the start and maintains it throughout the piece. He creates complex, three dimensional characters with the brushstrokes of a minimalist. And as he does in his journalistic writing, he presents all sides of the issue in an even, dispassionate manner.
With A Soldier's Duty, Mr. Ricks has revived a genre that was teetering on the brink of destructive self-imitation. If you read one military related novel this year, A Soldier's Duty is the one to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No