Customer Reviews

Solid State Physics: Problems and Solutions

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

One rarely comes across a book, about which one can say without any qualifying adjective, that it is simply great. The book of Mihaly and Martin however does belong in this rarefied category.

As anyone teaching solid state physics knows from experience, it is always demanding to find quality examples. The problems in the previous standard books are unfortunately dated, often decades back. In contrast, Mihaly and Martin bring examples from the very latest developments in solid state physics. At the same time they find room for covering the actual workings of such must-know experimental apparatii, as the triple axis spectrometer and the Fourier transform infrared spectrometer. It is hard to find books, which adress the theoretical and experimental sides of our discipline with such balance.

When the authors cover more conventional topics, like symmetries and band structures, they make them exciting for the student by chosing fascinating applications, for instance lattices of fullerenes instead of sodium. When they cover modern areas, they devote space extensively, very much unlike similar treatises. These include optical properties, correlation effects in infinite and low dimensional models, and phase transitions in electronic systems.

The best recommendation goes beyond words; it is reflected in actions: I already adopted the book in my course, and the students cannot get enough of these inventive problems. They actually like solving the homework problems, a true satisfaction for any teacher.

One rarely comes across a book, about which one can say without any qualifying adjective, that it is simply great. The book of Mihaly and Martin however does belong in this rarefied category.

As anyone teaching solid state physics knows from experience, it is always demanding to find quality examples. The problems in the previous standard books are unfortunately dated, often decades back. In contrast, Mihaly and Martin bring examples from the very latest developments in solid state physics. At the same time they find room for covering the actual workings of such must-know experimental apparatii, as the triple axis spectrometer and the Fourier transform infrared spectrometer. It is hard to find books, which adress the theoretical and experimental sides of our discipline with such balance.

When the authors cover more conventional topics, like symmetries and band structures, they make them exciting for the student by chosing fascinating applications, for instance lattices of fullerenes instead of sodium. When they cover modern areas, they devote space extensively, very much unlike similar treatises. These include optical properties, correlation effects in infinite and low dimensional models, and phase transitions in electronic systems.

The best recommendation goes beyond words; it is reflected in actions: I already adopted the book in my course, and the students cannot get enough of these inventive problems. They actually like solving the homework problems, a true satisfaction for any teacher.

This problems and solutions in solid state physics book leaves much freedom and autonomy to the reader. The expositions of the many problems this book contains are generally short and cover a wide range of solid state physics notions. Much more instructive than Kittel's or Ashcroft and Mermin's exercises set.

a very good book. The problems are smart. The order in which the problems are given is smart.

Problems and Solutions is a must have if you're struggling with your Solid State Physics problems. The subject list covers pretty much all the elementary (and more) and the style and methodology is crisp and fresh. In my opinion Mr. Mihaly and Mr. Martin should be handsomely rewarded for their work. If you're an undergraduate student this book is a must have together with Kittel, Myers and Hook & Hall.

This book isn't helpful to a beginning grad student trying to get a better grasp on solid state. Maybe someone a little more advanced, like a postdoc or very advanced grad student, would benefit from this book.

The questions in each topic area start with a very basic question (for which there is a limited solution) and then skip right to much more difficult questions (for which there are still limited worked-out solutions). I have not found the book helpful, and I'm a 2nd year grad student w/a strong math background. I think it tries to cover too much in too little space, rather than (what I need) focusing on the basics (at a graduate level) and expanding a little on the main topics.

Basically, it's going to end up being a waste of my money.

This book offers a nice set of pretty standard undergraduate to first year graduate problems in solid state physics. The answers, unfortunately, are sloppy and remarkably lack the detail you would expect from a question and answer book. Each chapter has a superficial and not too insightful introduction to the topic before asking the questions. Probably, most disappointing are the problems for which there are no answers. Isn't this supposed to be a problem and answer book? If you are looking for an insightful solution guide or a general overview as a companion for an introductory solid state course, you don't want this book. If you just want to see a result and have some stuff to jot down on homework assignments, then perhaps this book is just what you need.

This book compiles a large number of problems in SSP (included solutions to the problems as well). It could certainly be used as a supplement for a first course in SSP very effectively.