9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
complete waste of time, May 19, 2006
This review is from: Some Like It Haute (Hardcover)
this book is a complete waste of time ... the protagonist is dumb and not very likeable, the plot is ludicrous (when ESPERANTO is a major plot point, someone's trying too hard), and the fashion "details" are about what you could pick up reading your local newspaper. How many times can the author make dumb 80s-hairspray references? You will honestly lose count. And repeatedly pointing out that the heroine has a "great education" which she's wasting by being a fashion journalist? That's fairly insulting to people who enjoy fashion and think it's important, as well as being overly-reductive about the value of education. (Not to psychoanalyze too much, but since the author went to Harvard and is now working at PEOPLE magazine, maybe someone is insecure about her own life choices?)
There are plenty of great, smart, enjoyable fashiony chick-lit reads out there. Too bad this isn't one of them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fun Escape from Reality!!, May 15, 2006
This review is from: Some Like It Haute (Hardcover)
It was a little early for "beach reads" when this book was originally released, but it should fit right in this summer. It's fun, light reading with characters who are mostly likable and a story that goes over the top just a little. Clearly not for the "fashion-illiterate", so if you don't know the difference between Chanel & Prada, or don't know who Michael Kors or Marc Jacobs are, you'll probably find this a little boring. But if you're a "fashionista" & enjoy a fashion-related "guilty pleasure" every now & then, this book is definitely for you!! Frequent name-drops of some of today's top designers & trendy celebrities can be found on nearly every page, which adds some fun (There's even a tongue in cheek reference to the "Hilton" sisters as our main character attends the same party as the "Sheraton Sisters"!). Designers from Prada to Chanel to YSL to Stella McCartney and so, so many more make such frequent appearances that it's almost like the designers & their clothes, shoes, handbags & accessories are supporting characters in the story! Definitely written with fashion-lovers in mind (what else would you expect from an editor from People mag?!) (WARNING! Do not attempt to read this book anywhere near the mall or while you have access to you computer & credit card!! Shopping is not recommended within 60 minutes of reading this book!!!)
If you need a break from deep, moving, emotional stories with characters you become emotionally invested in & attached to, you might want to give this one a try. It won't take you anytime to get through it & shouldn't give you much pause for thought!! It's a very light, fluffy, fun read that doesn't take much thought at all. Your only emotional involvement in the characters might be envy, as one might only dream of having a closet or clothing allowance like Alex's!!!
The last third of the book is definitely over the top with a pretty imaginative story that's just a little unbelievable - but if you can look past that and read it just for fun, you should find it entertaining. I appreciate the effort that Julie Dam made to write a story that's an escape from the "real world" of today. For just a little while each day, I was happy to put aside the trials & tribulatons that is my real life & enjoyed spending time with Alex & her friends in the City of Paris and the crazy, unrealistic world of fashion. Everyone needs a break and needs to have a little fun now & then - SOME LIKE IT HAUTE, if anything, will put a smile on your face, cause you to roll you eyes once or twice, and forget about being a grown up for just a little while!!! Isn't that what reading's all about after all?? Taking time out of each day just to relax & escape for a little while. This book definitely did that for me!!
I look forward to what else this author brings us & whether or not she's able to sustain the level, or whether she takes dive along the lines of Plum Sykes & Lauren Weisberger, who delivered very entertaining first-run novels, but seemed to lose themselves in their subsequent attempts! I'm crossing my fingers for future escapes from reality, into the imaginitive world of Julie Dam!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Weak story, even for chic lit., May 18, 2006
This review is from: Some Like It Haute (Hardcover)
I am all for an easy read now and again, something to take me away from the grind of the day to day, but "Some Like it Haute" was just lame. This commentary may seem harsh but I really did try to like to book and I made myself finish it. However, from Alex's whining about her mistakes in her predetermined outfit organization, to the fact that Paris is teeming with people from Texas, I overdosed in cheesiness. The plot thins more so when Alex hears of her love interests "big secret", bizarro at best.
All I can honestly say is that anyone who is interested in fashion and designers has the same amount of knowledge as Alex, who sadly has a career in writing about it. So many other good options out there for summer reads, bypass this one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No