Amazon.com Review
Somewhere In France, John Rolfe Gardiner's novel about a family torn apart by the trials of World War I, recalls Leo Tolstoy's celebrated aphorism, "All happy families are alike, but an unhappy family is unhappy after its own fashion." At the height of the war, William Lloyd, a doctor from a notable New York family, is writing from a military hospital "somewhere in France" to his wife, Emma, back home. In order to escape the great outbreak of influenza in the U.S., the family has fled the city for Moriches, their Long Island estate. Here, his three children have discovered a trove of candid letters that their father wrote while he was in boarding school. In an author's note, Gardiner tells us that his own grandfather's letters about his service in France during the Great War were the seed of this novel. But Gardiner has turned these stories into a tableau for greater metaphysical musings on God and nature, as in this missive from William to his wife:
Thanks to you, Emma, I have the Emerson at my bedside. I hope you've bought another copy so that you and the children will not be without his advice.... The boys especially should have another go at these essays. I believe they went right over Willie's head on his first try. And Louis may have been too cocky to listen to anyone's counsel. Keep reminding them that Nature manifests the rules for their conduct. That's the key to it all. They've just got to open their eyes to Nature, God's first Bible.
Soon, however, his letters reveal his growing obsession with a mysterious, and scientifically gifted, French nurse: "At the Bagnoles de l'Orne, Lloyd was forced to see Jeanne as the daring other half of himself. Informal and spontaneous to a fault, the side of himself he had been trained against." Not surprisingly, the family buckles under the strain of his prolonged absence. Even once he returns, his wife finds him hard to reach: "If his mind was in France, she could wait for its reunion with his body here in America." Gardiner writes superb dialogue and expertly sets his characters in their place in time. His fourth novel is suffused with melancholy for a lost era of chivalry and class privilege, buried forever by the Great War.
--Ted Leventhal
From Publishers Weekly
Perhaps better known as a short story writer than a novelist (In the Heart of the Whole World), Gardiner uses a disarmingly plain style with which to tell a strange and complex story. Major William Lloyd is an Army doctor in WWI, doing his best to cope with the flood of injured at his base hospital in France, many of them also affected by the mysterious new viruses carried by battlefield lice. Jeanne Prie is his invaluable French-born, German-speaking assistant, who in her earlier work with leading medical scientists of the day has come to understand better than he the way fevers work in the blood, and how to create serums to combat them. (She is also not averse to being thought of as a kind of Jeanne d'Arc.) Together they forge a relationship that Lloyd's mother, Helen, and his wife, Emma, reading his letters back home in Long Island, see as obsessive. The family also has its own obsessions: volatile Emma is struggling with dictatorial Helen; they must cope with a devious chauffeur, and decide whether or not to light an oddly symbolic annual Fourth of July bonfire. Lloyd's pacifist son is drafted, arrested in France for his antiwar sentiments and nearly dies, only to be saved by Jeanne's ministrations. Lloyd can never again settle down at home after the war, when his family begins to quarrel over the estate. Heading back to France, he begins a long and sometimes dangerous pilgrimage that eventually returns him to Jeanne's side; but in an epilogue she appears as mysterious and difficult to characterize as ever. It is a bizarre tale of seemingly plain people driven by extraordinary passions, but the artless style seems at odds with the drama of the events, so that, despite some occasionally vivid scenes, they never quite come into focus. (Sept.)
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.