Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome live album, October 3, 2002
This review is from: The Song Remains The Same: Soundtrack From The Led Zeppelin Film (Audio CD)
I cannot for the life of me figure out why so many Zep-heads (and Page and Plant too) dismiss this 1973 concert album as sub-standard. Granted, it is heavily edited, with the best moments of three consecutive nights spliced together for the final mix. But then, in reality aren't all official live recordings put together this way? And there is no doubt that what we are left with is definitive concert versions of these nine songs. Page delivers two of his finest ever solos in 'No Quarter' and 'Stairway to Heaven,' while his chord/lead work on the title track is simply astounding. Similarly, the violin bow solo in 'Dazed and Confused' and the rockabilly solos in 'Whole Lotta Love' are masterful. Also, Plant is in fine voice throughout, and the rhythm section of Jones and Bonham is frighteningly intense. In my view, 1973 was Zep's greatest year as a live band - it marked the peak of their early instrumental development (check out bootlegs of the Mobile and Seattle shows from this same US tour for comparable performances). And this album captures that peak-1973 period for official posterity. So forget what the 'politically correct' Zep critics say - this is one of rock's great live albums!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Moment In Time, January 16, 2000
This review is from: The Song Remains The Same: Soundtrack From The Led Zeppelin Film (Audio CD)
This film/album had actually been shelved in 1973, never intended to be released because of what was perceived by the band to be a mediocre performance. It only saw the light of day because of a decision that the band needed to fill a void of 18 months due to Robert Plant's personal problems (he suffered a badly fractured leg in an auto accident and it was feared that he would never walk again without a cane). First of all, The Song Remains the Same was out of date - the film was shot well before the release of the band's monumental Physical Graffiti album and, obviously, contained none of that album's material. Secondly, the band members themselves lament to this very day that this was their only live performance officially captured for posterity. They were at the end of an extensive American tour at the time and were understandably exhausted. Circumstances prevented Zeppelin from ever producing the definitive live recording that they so desperately desired. Such a project was slated for the band's '80-'81 tour, but was obviously scrapped by the death of John Bonham. It's best to think of The Song Remains the Same more as a historical peice than as the definitive live Led Zeppelin, which it is not. It captures a moment in time. An inside-glimpse at the larger-than-life Led Zeppelin, complete with their flaws (even Zep was not perfect). And in that way, The Song Remains the Same is actually more intriguing and has more of an enduring charm than some pristine, studio-exact live excercise. But don't be deceived into thinking that this album is slop. There are certainly moments of grandeur here that other bands would kill for on their best day. Page's guitar blitz on "Celebration Day" obliterates the studio version. That breathtaking final solo provides fresh open-mouthed astonishment every time. Of course, any time Zeppelin straps it on for "Dazed and Confused", it's an adventure - although the running time here of nearly 27 minutes is shockingly self-indulgent for a live album, especially considering the wealth of material they had to draw from (believe it or not, they were known to go even LONGER in their early days). And who could fail to mention the most famous improvised line ever in a live recording, Robert Plant's, "Does anybody remember laughter?" during "Stairway..." - so well known in fact, that many people think it's part of the studio version. Taking the good with the bad, The Song Remains the Same soundtrack is an essential momento for any Zep fan, while it should perhaps be left until later for Zep novices (at the very least, get 2 or 3 of the first 6 studio albums before you jump into this).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Note To Consider, September 4, 2003
By A Customer
First of all the 5 stars is for Zep & the great music but collectors of mini lp replicas take note: All the Zep albums(Bar BBC) have been released on mini lp paper sleeve versions BOTH from Japan AND Europe. The europe & Jap versions are sonically identical, all are taken from the Jimmy Page George Marino remasters,a fact also printed on the stickers(Europe releases)& insert sheet (Japan releases). The packaging is also identical,the europe releases actually use the Jap outer cardboard sleeves(the catalog numbers on the europe spines are identical to their Japanese counterparts but the numbers are different on the actual discs (europe) themselves. The Japan versions DO have an extra foldout lyric insert in Japanese,the discs are housed in see through thin plastic sleeves (the europe versions are enclosed in glossy card inner sleeves,much nicer). Most importantly the EAU versions are MUCH cheaper, if you must have the paper insert and the obi strip,be prepared to pay heavily. All in its great to have these available but in a nutshell the European versions are almost identical bar the paper insert at a much lower price(amazon.co.uk)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|