Songs for the Broken Hearted

Windy & Carl | Format: Audio CD

Product Details

• Audio CD (October 14, 2008)
• Original Release Date: 2008
• Number of Discs: 1
• Label: Kranky
• ASIN: B001CQP48O
• In-Print Editions: Vinyl  |  MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 4.8 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (4 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #194,318 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)

Editorial Reviews

Most everyone has experienced love as well as heartbreak. The 10 songs that form the new Windy & Carl album are interpretations of those emotions that run the gamut from pain, anger and longing, to warmth, admiration and joy. Started in early 2007 and finished in the spring of 2008 in the midst of some sudden inspiration, these songs are some of the best Windy & Carl have to offer, and a new mark in their always developing sound.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Songs for the Broken Hearted, November 8, 2008

By 

Mike Newmark (Tarzana, CA United States) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)   

This review is from: Songs for the Broken Hearted (Audio CD)

Over a 15-year career that has outlived nearly all their space-rock peers, Dearborn, Michigan-based ambient duo Windy & Carl have built their music around three constants: universality, honesty, and beauty. Their albums go for big, overarching concepts that reflect some part of the world and the way in which we experience it. Depths, for instance, is about submitting oneself to the forces of nature, as depicted vividly on its cover, and Consciousness is a serene ode to the pleasures of being sentient. But rather than simply work in grand gestures, Windy & Carl make the universal personal and the personal universal, gazing outward for inspiration and recording how it makes them feel in a way that makes sense to us. Their 2005 EP Dedications to Flea may revolve singularly around the passing of the married couple's beloved pet dog, but the mournful guitar drones and field recordings of Flea go straight to the heart of anyone who has ever lost someone close.

The duo's honesty, however underappreciated, elevates the music even higher, resulting in a catalogue that sounds as though it doesn't contain an insincere bone in its body. Recent albums have arrived with poignant and elaborate statements about their reasons for creation; the liner notes to Dedications to Flea, for example, touchingly recalled the life and times of their dog in a staggering amount of detail. Now we have Songs for the Broken Hearted, and it's seemingly no less purposeful. On the band's official website, Windy begins her explanation of the new release with, "This is an album about love." And then she lays it bare: how she went through a "dark time" during recording (which started on the same weekend she began her murky solo album, I Hate People) and left the tapes off the reels to rot until Carl rescued them, how the songs consistently made her cry before she could even write the lyrics, how the album shifted from straight-up sadness to an aural documentation of the way love works, in its high peaks and low, low valleys. As the duo's discography has taken on an increasingly elegiac tone, the idea of an album with heartbreak as a central motif fits snugly into their trajectory.

And it is about heartbreak--far more so, I think, than it is about love in the simplistic Valentine's Day sense. Windy & Carl understand that to make an album personal is to make it real, and the instances of love in Songs for the Broken Hearted are beset by the unmistakable tension of knowing that everything could fall apart in an instant. Leadoff track "Btwn You + Me" reflects this state of being. Multiple lines of guitar ambience--some becalmed, some ominous--blend into an emotionally ambiguous cloud as Windy whispers something into our ear that's below our level of comprehension. Before we can figure out whether the words she just told us were good or bad, "La Douleur" ("The Pain") does the job for her: It's over ten minutes of dolorous catharsis, with a high-pitched guitar wailing into the void. "My Love", the track following, is the calm after the storm. It has the feel of black satin, of love enshrouded by an almost gothic mysteriousness, and though it was released as a single earlier in 2008 it works incredibly well in this context.

Just about any of these tracks could have been singles, really, in that they're superlative examples of the form, but what makes Songs for the Broken Hearted stand out in Windy & Carl's discography is its impeccable pacing. There are thickly layered ambient suites ("When We Were"), Flying Saucer Attack-style space-rock ballads ("Forever"), and happy mediums between the two ("Snow Covers Everything"), clocking in at runtimes from two-and-a-half minutes to almost 13. The path they follow has been clearly plotted out, the way Tim Hecker might have done it, for maximum impact. When the album's only joyous moment arrives ("Snow Covers Everything") eight tracks in, it seems to serve as a reward for enduring the rest of the album's emotional upheaval. The song's peaceful guitars wrap around the ears like a warm blanket, while wind chimes and glockenspiel emulate falling snowflakes and Windy sings in a voice that's uncommonly clear and--possibly for the first time in the duo's history--free. Yet its title and strange placement within the sequence suggest an impermanent coating; when the ice melts we're left with, quite literally, "The Same Moon and Stars", a track that contains the same conflicted emotional mixture as the one on the record's other end.

I don't have to tell you that the third constant, beauty, is here on Songs for the Broken Hearted full stop. What's remarkable about this, of course, is that Windy & Carl haven't changed their cloud-drift instrumental approach since they first picked up their equipment. (The final track on their 1994 debut, "Through the Portal", doesn't sound particularly out of touch in 2008.) But as beautiful as the album is, it's not easy to listen to casually. Upon finding out that Songs for the Broken Hearted references Windy & Carl's own broken hearts, their personal struggle with the way in which love waxes and wanes between them, everything clicks. We hear, once again, the sound of the musicians' external world becoming internalized as emotion, then beamed outward for droves of listeners to appreciate. Writing a love song is easy; millions have done it, and love is by some margin the most frequently referenced subject in popular music. But few artists are so perceptive that they can capture love's terrifying complexity, so honest that they can give us a glimpse inside themselves to understand it, and so brave that nowhere on an album about love can they offer us a resolution.

(This appeared in PopMatters on 11/7/2008)

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Headphone Commute Review, May 3, 2009

By 

Headphone Commute - See all my reviews

This review is from: Songs for the Broken Hearted (Audio CD)

Windy Weber & Carl Hultgren have been releasing minimal ambient and experimental post-rock music since the late 90's. The catalog of this Michigan based husband-and-wife duo spans an eclectic selection of notable labels such as Icon, Ochre, Darla, Brainwashed, and of course, Chicago-based Kranky Records. Songs For The Broken Hearted is Windy & Carl's fourth release on Kranky (being signed to the label for over a decade now), where it perfectly fits among the works by their fellow label-mates, Stars of the Lid, Pan*American, Tim Hecker, and Brian McBride. The tracks on Songs For The Broken Hearted continue to build on the duo's style of beatless shoegaze layers of Carl & Windy's guitar work, using EBow and a variety of time-based delays, with the occasional soft vocals by Windy. Both play equal amounts of guitar on the record, and Windy tells me that "each track (with the exception of Rhodes) was created spontaneously with us both playing guitar, and then carl added a few extra layers after and i added the vocals". The sound of this album is still drony, but a lot more harmonic, as if a heavy pillow was left on the Rhodes, pressing on all the right keys. The cover art of the album pictures a forest with breaking light. A parallel could be drawn between this image and the dense stratum of sonic frequencies evoked by the guitar, with an occasional breakthrough of clearly EQed voice, which almost whispers the songs that lullaby the sad, and indeed the brokenhearted. To understand the depth of feelings behind this work, it helps to bypass my interpretations, and instead quote Windy talking about the album on the band's web site: "this is an album about love. everyone has known love, and everyone has known loss. love is not just about warm fuzzy feelings, although that would be the part people say they like the best. and in any span of time, love changes and means different things to different people. [...] songs for the broken hearted is an album full of honesty, both musically and lyrically. it is for anyone who has felt love - you can hear it in the sounds and the words, both spoken and unspoken. the album i never thought would be is finished." For an extensive selection of Windy & Carl's tracks, check out their triple disk release, Introspection (Blue Flea, 2002). A few other great recommendations from the duo include Depths (Kranky, 1998), Consiousness (Kranky, 2001), and a compilation of two EPs, The Dreamhouse / Dedications to Flea (Kranky, 2005) - the latter being a sad elegy dedicated to their departed dog, Flea. Recommended for the above mentioned Kranky roster. Windy & Carl are currently preparing for their spring tour along with Benoît Pioulard with some special treats from Lambs Laughter (Windy and Thomas Meluch). For tour tour dates and details check their website or myspazz.

4.0 out of 5 stars A Heart Pumping Heavily, August 31, 2011

By 

kabalabonga - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: Songs for the Broken Hearted (Audio CD)

Sounding in places as if the roar of the universe were being channeled through a deep aquatic current, "Songs For The Brokenhearted" is reminiscent of Windy and Carl's fourth release, "Depths", with a murkiness that invokes feelings of languor. "Depths" harnessed this in the service of a motif that thematically connected to the nautical aspects of its title; "Songs For The Brokenhearted" uses this sense of submergence to evoke how those who love can be trapped within their own current of disappointment and painful emotion.

And be forewarned that this recording is not easy listening. Carl Hultgren typically channels a multiplicity of effects through his pedals rack: to me, it often sounds as if he is levitating tiny fragments of resonating crystal within a miniature whirlwind, creating a warm, shimmering effect around massive, elongated drones that seem as limitless and expansive as the dimensions of the universe. Here things get a little weightier, and the building blocks of the drones on many of these tracks are sculpted from waves of heavy feedback or distortion.

But not every track is mired in gloom. "My Love", driven by gentle reverb and Windy's low, breathy, spoken-sung vocals, hearkens back to "The Silent Ocean" from "Depths", a patiently constructed song that reaffirms commitment in the face of potential future uncertainty. "Rhodes" is a track that loops guitar and keyboard through levels of endless, cyclically driven ascension, and would not have been out of place on a release by Seefeel. And finally, "Snow Covers Everything", containing a mantric, chanted vocalization from Windy, chimes with beautiful insistence and suggests a level of purification or willingness to cover over previously scarred ground.

"Songs For The Brokenhearted" is probably the most demanding CD that Windy and Carl have ever released, and is definitely not the entry point for someone who's just developed an interest in the band's material. While not brutal in presentation, it's very dense in construction, and with much heavier layers of nearly-claustrophobic drone to anchor it in place. I would recommend grabbing this after listening to every other release first, but it is definitely worth getting.