5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This is an Amazing Book!, December 17, 2007
This review is from: Songwriting Success: How to Write Songs for Fun and (Maybe) Profit (Paperback)
I am surprised this book has not gotten any reviews yet, but, I guess there are a lot of songwriting books out there. This is an amazing book. The author goes through various aspects of the craft of songwriting, not assuming you're going to know any of them. I have mostly been skipping the music sections, because I already know a lot about that.
But the lyric writing sections are great. He talks about creating a persona, an "I" that you use in performance, and how the "I" you create in your song must be at the same time genuine, but also a specific character that might not even look like you; how the feelings in the song need to reach out to the listener, so they can identify with what you are saying; how every song needs to revolve around a core idea, whether that is contained in the title, or not.
I don't believe I know how to do this book justice in this review, but it is a wonderful book. His advice about songwriting is so well distilled, so clear, and makes so much sense! I love this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent book, terrible Kindle edition, September 7, 2010
This is a most excellent book on songwriting but the Kindle edition is a ripoff.
The book is comprehensive, well written, it manages to explain complex notions in simple words. Also it filled with common sense (just read the introduction on the risks of songwriting...).
I am a self-learner (keyboard) and I have acquired some experience in music theory (I can read music, I know the scales and chords, etc.) but this book offers a fresh perspective on this material and one that is very pleasant. I enjoyed reading this book and I learned a lot.
Unfortunately the Kindle edition is a ripoff: the book includes a CD. No rather the book relies on the included CD. Unlike many similar books, the CD is not just a MIDI rendering of a few tunes but it is an integral part of the teaching experience with voice-over and additional explanation and demonstration by the author. BTW this is *great* pedagogy as you can read a chapter one day and listen to complementary explanation the next day, which re-enforces what you have learned. The author has done an excellent job at combining the two medias (print and audio), they never repeat each other but truly complement each other.
And now the ripoff: the Kindle edition does not include the CD, nor does it include a link to download the tracks. Nada. If you buy the Kindle edition, you're getting less than half of the teaching efficiency.
Having realized that the book had potential, I had to buy the print edition as well, since it is the only one that include the mandatory CD. Of course the print edition is less convenient to read so I only open it once: to remove the CD. And since the Kindle edition is only very slightly discounted from the paper edition, I ended up paying twice to access the material.
I'm afraid that I find that this attitude from the publisher is very dishonest.
So if you like reading on paper, you would do well to buy this book. But if, like me, you prefer the convenience of the Kindle, this publisher does not deserve your trust.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No