** Modified 05-08-09 by adding nitpick #5 :) ***
I had been a digital point-and-shoot camera person for about 12 years, since the Canon Powershot 100. Over that time, I've upgraded to various Powershot models until 2 years ago, got a Sony A100 DSLR. I love that camera and have lots of fun taking pictures with it.
For work, we had been using my A100 to take product photos. It was nice having a remote, and all of the great DSLR features that come along with that camera. But, I have been without my A100 for a while, and was missing it dearly, so I decided to get another camera for work, and was having trouble deciding between the DSC-HX1 and the A200 DSLR.
I've been playing with both, and have decided to return the A200 and keep the DSC-HX1. Here's why:
1. The other people helping me take these product photos don't have any DSLR experience, and don't share my enthusiasm for photography. They prefer point-and-shoot. So from an ease of use standpoint, the DSC-HX1 is a better choice, especially with the live view. The A200 doesn't have that, and although the A350 does, it does cost $100 more.
2. The HX1 has enough features on it to allow us to play with settings to get a great shot. You can control aperture, shutter speed, etc, just like on a DSLR. Manual focusing is available, but using the selective focusing is much more accurate for our non-moving subject. We just move the cursor to highlight the area that should be in focus, and the camera does the rest. Otherwise, there are lots of DSLR-like features.
3. The picture quality is pretty good. The JPG only shooting mode may put off more serious photographers who want RAW, but is fine for those moving up from lesser cameras. The large lens and CMOS
4. Live histogram view is nice to make sure you get a good exposure.
5. The optical zoom is great. I turn off digital zoom, since I don't really like it.
6. It's very light, much lighter than the A200 and even more so than my A100 setup.
7. The panorama feature is nice, but we won't be using it at the office.
8. The noise reduction modes are nice, but we won't be using it, since we have a lightbox and tripod setup for our needs. However, at a birthday party, I could see how this would be a nice feature.
There are some drawbacks that I would like to see addressed in future models:
1. I wish I could manually focus with a dial. The manual and semi-manual focusing on this thing has you move a scroll wheel to select a distance, and doesn't give the fine focusing of an actual lense dial on a DSLR. The selective focus is a nice feature that allows us to compensate for it, but this won't work well with moving subjects, but the semi-manual mode is a decent compromise.
2. There is a slight lag with the live view that I'm not used to coming from a DSLR. However, the tilting ability of the screen helps is nice, and makes up for this minor drawback.
3. With a tripod mount fitted, it's impossible to access the memory card slot. The DSLRs had this on the side of the camera.
4. Even with a tripod, it's possible to get blurry pictures when you press the shutter button. I thought that I read a review of the camera somewhere that said it had a remote. I didn't see mention of one in the manual, and of course there wasn't one in the box. However, it would be a great feature. The 2 second timer is ok, but not as convenient.
*** ADDED 05-08-09 ***
5. Although this camera has a great zoom lens for a non-DSLR, I found that it had difficulty focusing on close objects with a high zoom. Taking close-ups from about 2.5 feet away, I found it difficult to go beyond 3x zoom. Just another difference between this and a DSLR with a huge telephoto lens. Of course, moving the product closer, and reducing the zoom did the trick. Most people probably wouldn't be using the zoom lens this way, and probably won't have an issue with this limitation.
***
Overall, I would choose this camera over the A200 for many applications, but mainly for ease of use. The quality is great, and it has lots of features. Unless you need to change lenses or need precise manual focusing, it's hard to go wrong with this camera. It's for someone who likes to take pictures, wants good quality photos, but doesn't want the heft nor the bulk of a DSLR.