Customer Reviews

Sony HDR-XR150 120GB High Definition HDD Handycam Camcorder

5 star:		(12)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

Wanted to replace my VHS-C camcorder with a more updated camera. After research, I picked the HDR-XR150. Loaded with features, but small enough to fit in pockets, fanny-packs,etc. Worked great for first communion and graduation footage. Battery runtime is great, would recommend upgrade for extended uses. Works well in low light, 25x zoom is awesome!! Need to learn all of the features yet, but easy enough for beginners to use. I also need to get a blu-ray player so I can take advantage of the HD. Easy to burn dvd's with either computer or Sony DVDirect. Would highly recommend to those looking for a good family movie quality camcorder.

Sony XR-150 camcorder videos are mushy at the best, whatever the setting, be it in SD (640x480) or HD mode (1080/60i FX, FH)... I compared this camcorder's HD video output with my 4-year old Fuji F30 digicam's upscaled SD video (my Fuji digicam has only SD video resolution). Disappointingly, this camcorder produces mediocre HD videos that are soft and are only marginally better in resolution compared to the upscaled SD video of my Fuji digicam. The marginal improvement in resolution is offset by the oversmooth, soft, washed out appearance of this Sony XR-150 camcorder's video colors. Exposure-wise and color-wise, the Fuji F30's upscaled SD output looks sharper, and overall, much better despite the being much noisier.

Comparing Sony XR-150 camcorder's SD output with my Fuji F30's SD output, the F30 is a bit noisier but again, the color and exposure and sharpness and detail is way much better. I was expecting a really dramatic improvement considering the price of this camcorder and considering that we're talking about 640x480 resolution (Fuji) vs. 1080/60i (Sony `HD'[?!!!] camcorder)... What a disappointment... I had to return this camcorder and stick to my Fuji F30's SD video until I find a more deserving replacement. (I'm looking at the Canon Vixia HF100).

My advice: Don't buy this camcorder if you want to improve on your digicam's SD videos or the existing videos of your SD camcorders... The video quality improvement (if you'd call it that) is not worth the price of this `barely' HD and 'pretentiously' 'HD' camcorder.
---------
Update: August 8, 2010

I've just bought the Canon Vixia HF M300 and all I can say is... Wow!!! What a world of difference in sharpness and resolution! Now that is HD! This Sony has fixed auto settings with no manual controls whatsoever while the Canon is fully customizable with manual controls (aperture priority; shutter priority, gain control, etc.). While I do admit at the default point-and-shoot settings (program AE mode) the Canon output looks visibly noisier (horrible trailing noise) but more detailed compared to this Sony camcorder's program AE mode (clean, but oversmooth and mushy with little detail left not fit to be called 'HD'), the ability to customize the Canon and adjust manual settings set these two camcorders a world apart. With the correct manual/custom settings, the Canon at $110.18 cheaper ($438.82 for Canon vs. $549 for the Sony) leaves this Sony in the dust. With the Canon, you will see what HD is supposed to be (sharpness and resolution that rival blu-Ray movies and HD channels). If you don't want to learn and fiddle with manual controls however and just want to point and shoot, only then will I suggest this more expensive Sony because as much as I hate to admit it, the Sony's program AE settings does appear cleaner (but less detailed) in indoor lighting than the Canon's default program AE settings which I can describe as detailed but just too noisy for my taste. (I'm not talking about what the Canon is capable of achieving with the correct manual settings which is simply spectacular whether it be in the bright sunny outdoors or dim, low light indoors. [Check out my review for the Canon HF M300]).
-----------
Update: November 19, 2010
I would just like to add that for those wanting to use the Sony XR 150 as a backup tool to take photos in addition to videos (in case you forget to bring your digital camera), be forewarned that the 3 megapixel photos taken by this camcorder is plain noisy, mushy garbage as there's no built in flash. The 3 megapixel photo capture is actually just upscaled from a 1 megapixel capture so don't be misled into thinking this camcorder can serve as your emergency 'backup' photo capturing device in case you forget to bring a digital camera. You need at least 2.0 NATIVE megapixels (not 1 megapixel UPSCALED to 3 megapixels) for a decent 4"x6" photo print. In the same way, the 'HD' video of this camcorder is actually just an upscale of its native capture which is NOT TRULY 1080p (just upscaled to 1080p). For those who think this camcorder's 'HD' video quality is comparable to blu-ray discs or HD broadcasts, you should check your sitting distance and your screen size and resolution. Screen size should at least be 42" 1080p and sitting distance should be no more than 2x the screen size. Viewing much farther away will make even the best HD broadcasts look like ordinary DVD or SD. Also, if you have no plans buying a 42" or bigger screen in the future, or sitting at the appropriate 2x viewing distance, you shouldn't be buying an HD camcorder as you will only see MARGINAL video quality and resolution improvement at inappropriate viewing distances and small screen sizes. Do compare this camcorder's output to reference Blu-ray discs like 'Pirates of the Carribean' (Curse of the Black Pearl) first or other similar reference HD material so you can judge for yourself how good really is the `HD' video resolution and quality of this camcorder is. Do compare this camcorder first with other camcorder offerings from other brands which cost so much less and offer so much better HD video and photo quality and so much more value for the money before shelling out a `premium' price for this camcorder. Make no mistake about my negative review. I love my Sony 1080p LCD tv, my Sony blu ray player and my Sony DVD players. My HD camcorder would also have been a Sony (XR 150) if it only lived up to its price and `Full 1080p HD' tag.

For the price, I believe Sony could have done better: True 1080p HD capture, full manual controls and a hotshoe because the much cheaper offerings from other brands (like the Canon HF M300), perform so much better and have so much more to offer with built in flash, mini hotshoe and with very good TRUE 3 megapixel photo capture (not upscaled). I always liked Sony products but I wish Sony would stop exaggerating specs like claiming a 'FULL HD 1080p'camcorder in a product that actually captures lower than that (only upscales internally the video captured to 1080p), or bannering '3.2 megapixels' in its camcorder body when the actual photo capture really is only 1 megapixel and is just upscaled internally to 3 megapixels.

I'm surprised at how strong of negative reivews this camera got on Amazon. I consider myself somewhat picky about electronics and have been very happy with this camera. I rarely charge the battery and it has never come close to running out on me, the storage for video's is massive, and the video picture quality is excellent. All this in such a compact camera. I have had it almost a year and my family and friends all have been impressed with the video quality as well. I have not taken still shots with this camera so I cannot comment on still shots. I'm sure if you do your research there are probably several cameras on the market that are as good as this one, perhaps even better(cant' be by much) in this price range, but I have been very happy and very impressed with this camera and would definantly recommend this camera.
Note: Since I wrote this review I did notice that outside/bright lighting the picture is amazing. However, indoors w/moderate lighting the picture is OK, not bad, but not nealry as sharp as outdoors. I still recommend doing your research but I am very happy and impressed with this camera.

This camera is actually a Consumer Reports Best Buy, so I went to my neighborhood Fry's Electronics to take a look at it in their showroom. To my surprise, they had already mounted this camera on a tripod and hooked it up to a 40" 1080p HDTV through an HDMI port. I played with the camera focusing on people at various locations throughout the store and checked out the results on the TV. The quality was such a disappointment. Edges were fuzzy and pixelated even on faces that the camera auto-focused on. Anything with sharp lines (like the edges of tiles in the ceiling) actually wiggled while the camera was motionless on the tripod. If I hadn't read the one-star review for this model on Amazon, I would have thought there was a problem with that particular camera.

I guess if you were just going to create low-resolution videos to upload to YouTube this camera would probably be just fine. Since I wanted something I could capture good quality home videos to display on my HDTV, I passed over this camera.

25 X Zoom in 1080p! Where else you get gonna get that? 300 X digital zoom! Now those ufo pics will be indisputable! Minus 1 star because no way to attach an infrared light or flash. :(

i ordered this product off Amazon around a year ago so i know its ups and downs quiet well, i used this camera for my multi-media classes to make short movies and advertisements, it was a great experience, the bottom line is the camera is great outdoors but needs alot of lighting indoors, just a few light bulbs won't do the job of decent lighting, the camera's zoom with 1080p is amazing, the best thing about this camera is the sound quality it records without attaching any attachments like a shotgun mic to it, i was extremely impressed with how clear the sound was as oppose to other brands, even when the person is pretty far it wasn't a problem, it also have a zoom-mic option that can come in handy.

the main reason i gave it a 3/5 which is also the reason that gave me a really hard time shooting was it had no microphone jack, so i couldn't install a boom mic or a shotgun mic or any type of mic that will give me smooth crystal clear sound. What also really annoyed me is you could ONLY install sony accessories because the way accessories were installed in the camera was different from other camera's, i had alot of stuff i wanted to use with the camera that i didn't simply because it won't install on the camera.

having a camera with an HDD was a great idea, but out of every (approx) 50 video's i recorded i had one that was corrupted and wouldn't open. Not sure if its just my camera.

This is the 3rd camera I have bought from Sony. I use to work for Apple Retail as a manager when we sold different video cams and I can say that Sony leads in cameras and camcorders, Samsung leads in TV, Apple leads in phones, computers, and mp3. Sony did great on the optical zoom on this camera. You should ignore the digital zoom on any camera, look at the optical only. I gave this camera 4 stars only since it is 2010 and any camcorder should have at least at 5 or 6 megapixel still feature (this cam only has 3 which is ok). Since I strongly believe we are going away from dvd and blu-ray format toward a hard drive media hub format, I think this camera is the way to go. I personally bought the Western Digital Media Hub that comes with HDMI, network, rca, 1TB capabilities to backup my data and connect to my tv $200 plus a redundant backup of a cheap 2 TB WD Costco HD $100. It may seem like quite an investment but think of the mini DV tapes or SD cards if you choose a format different this a HD camera. You will spend well over $300 in the first year in tapes or cards and you won't have the great features that come with a media hub (no tapes or cards to mess with).

This camera shoots HD very well for a consumer camera. I use it for "Prosumer" tasks and it has given me absolutey no problems. Also, the Hard Drive size is very very convenient. And it is difficult to find this much hard disk with a lens this long. This has been one of my best purchases ever on Amazon.com.

This is a unique HD video camera and this uniqueness is why I gave it 5 stars. It is the only HD video camera that has a 25x optical zoom, a 300x digital zoom and a 120 gigabit hard drive. That and its compact form and the Sony name are four compelling reasons to buy this model. Optical zoom and not digital zoom is paramount when it comes to quality photography of any kind. It comes with a Carl Zeiss lens and Exmor CMOS sensor and image stabilization. I have recorded hours of video including a 2 ½ hr graduation without even coming close to needing to download to a computer. You can record between 30 hrs of HD HQ and 50 hrs in HD LP mode. The camera is remarkably small and therefore convenient for travel. It has quite a few features including face detection and a useful index system. The video I have recorded was clear and crisp; and while it wasn't the sharpest HD video, at this price point the trade off for a smooth auto exposure and better than average low light capability was welcomed, after all it is full HD. The only negatives so far have been the difficult to access menus from the lcd screen and the lack of an optical viewfinder. There are many menu levels and the scrolling method for finding settings etc. just doesn't work for me. Despite this however this camcorder deserves 4.5 - 5 stars because of the outstanding 25x zoom and enormous hard drive in a compact body for what is considered budget pricing at around $500 dollars.

I bought this camera to take videos my grandchildren.Camera is so tiny and to use is so easy.Auto focus is very fast.120 gb hard disc memory is wonderful.We can take long videos.summary I prefer this camera to everybody.