This is a fantastic little recorder that is, I think, probably the least expensive audio recorder available capable of making professional quality recordings. I use it three ways -- either on it's own (using its' built-in microphones), with an external Sony ECM-MS957 stereo microphone, or with an external RODE NT4 stereo microphone. Also, just for reference, I edit all my recordings on a system that has very high resolution -- a Grace M902 D/A converter driving AKG K701 headphones.
I record larger groups, predominately gospel choirs, and buying this recorder made a huge improvement in the quality of my recordings. I previously used a Sony MZ-M200 Hi-MD recorder in linear PCM mode. Using the PCM-D50 with the same microphone and at the same recording quality settings, here's what I have observed:
1. A very large improvement in the frequency response of my recordings. There is much better extension on both the low and the high end. This is probably attributable to the quality of the microphone preamps in the PCM-D50, but it is NOT subtle...
2. A significant improvement in the sense of air or openness in a recording. This ties into the extended HF response, I think, but there's something else going on as well that adds to the overall quality of a recording.
3. Better stereo imaging; again, likely due to the far better mic preamps and better channel isolation throughout the circuitry.
4. A significantly lower noise floor. I don't care if they're both digital, in something as small as the MZ-M200 there's simply not enough room to have high-quality parts with adequate isolation. The difference was, frankly, a surprise.
5. A huge improvement in potential recording time without reducing quality. I have 8GB of memory (4GB internal, 4GB on MemoryStick), compared to 1GB (per disc) on the MZ-M200. I believe there is a 2GB limit for file size, but -- as I understand it -- the PCM-D50 will seamlessly transition to a new file when you hit the 2GB wall. I have yet to record anything that large, and therefore haven't tried this in practice.
6. A massive improvement in battery life. I haven't done a scientific comparison, but using lithium cells in the PCM-D50 probably offers battery life that is easily 10 times greater than what the rechargeable battery on the MZ-M200 offers.
7. Far quicker downloads to my Mac, on the order of 6-8 times faster. They both use a mini USB connector but the PCM-D50 works far better with a computer, especially a Macintosh. When you plug it in it appears on your desktop as though it were a standard USB drive. With a MemoryStick inserted you actually get two separate drive icons, one for the internal memory and another for the MS.
8. A far more sophisticated limiter. The PCM-D50 always makes two data streams, one at the level you've set and another that's -20dB down in level. If you overdrive the thing it quickly switches to the lower level data stream, thus preserving the quality of your recording. You can adjust how quickly it switches back to your preset levels -- either 150 milliseconds, 1 second, or 1 minute. I was skeptical of this feature, but in practice it works very well in my recording venues.
Are there things I don't like? Not a lot. I'm mad that Sony didn't offer the case (CKL-PCMD50) that is sold for this recorder in Japan, but you can find them on eBay. I'm frustrated that the accessories offered for this unit -- a small tripod (VCT-PCM1), a furry windscreen (AD-PCM1), and a wired remote control (RM-PCM1) -- are not available until February (at the earliest).
The only other thing that is slightly bothersome is the fact that, when using the tripod, you are limited to recording others. That is, if you want to be part of the recording -- this happens when I join in with some of the vocal groups I record, or if you are trying to record yourself playing an instrument -- you will not be able to see the VU meters. In these cases I always resort to an external microphone, which allows me to have proper mic placement while keeping the meters in sight.
I would recommend this to anyone looking to spend under $1,000 on a pro-grade recorder. Above that price point I'd suggest going all the way and spending $1,700 to $1,800 on the Sound Devices 702...