My first Sony eReader, the PRS-500 is still plugging away, albeit with a much fuzzier/blurrier screen around the left edge, but I decided after 6 or so years to upgrade to a new Sony Touch PRS-650, after MUCH research between it, and Amazon's Kindle. I did, at one point, buy and then cancel my purchase of the latest Kindle *because of* the wireless capabilities, and it's limited support of content formats.
Primarily, what niggled in the back of my mind after I had initially went the Kindle, was that this Kindle I had purchased would be "calling home" if I were to leave the wireless capabilities enabled, and whoever is at the other end at Amazon would, essentially, be able to see, or have access to whatever was on it. I like my privacy a great deal, and this did not sit well with me. (Scroogle "Kindle and Privacy") I would be willing to bet that even with wireless off, there would be some "limited" talking back and forth regardless, and there would be no way I could tell otherwise. That was when I decided to go with Sony. This said, I'm not sure this review will even be posted here at Amazon, but such is life.
Granted, each reader has it's own limitations, but I also felt much more secure in the knowledge that were I to, down the road, decide to take my extensive library of e-books to another reader, I would be in much better shape with the Sony (especially since I already have an extensive library that works with my previous Sony reader) than Kindle, with it's DRM restrictions. Here's the list of media formats supported from Sony's website (sonystyle.com):
* DRM Text : ePub (Adobe DRM protected), PDF (Adobe DRM protected), BBeB Book (PRS DRM protected), Text, RTF
* Image : JPEG, PNG, GIF, BMP
* Unsecured Audio : Unsecured Adudio: MP3 (Non encrypted), AAC (Non encrypted)
* Unsecured Text : ePub, BBeB Book, PDF, TXT, RTF, Micrsoft® Word, (Conversion to the Reader requires Word installed on your PC)
In addition, my old Sony eReader as well as the PRS-650 both have expandable storage, where the Kindle does not. The Touch has 2 GB of internal space with slots for SD cards up to 32 GB.
I'd also like to note that the reviewer that said that there was NO glare/reflection issues from the screen in any light is mistaken. Yes, the screen surface is somewhat matte, but there are still times when the reader needs to be tilted this way or that when the light is behind you, but this is a very minor inconvenience. I love my Sony Touch for all the reasons he mentioned as well, and more!
If you cannot find a good deal on this item through ebay (because you'll be hard pressed to find an affordable one on Amazon), do go to the Sonystyle.com site and pick one up. I got mine on sale at Sony in Nov '10 for $199, and even now they're $230 (Dec '10), and if you turn in your old Sony eReader for recycling, I guess, it's an additional $75 or so off the new one.
I want to end this by saying that it was a VERY close race between the Kindle and the Touch for me, and if the Touch was not around, I would be leaping on the Kindle in a moment's notice. With the wireless off, or preferably, broken.