27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The good, the bad, and the ugly, January 13, 2007
This review is from: Sony VAIO VGX-XL2 Digital Living System (Intel Pentium D Processor 920, 1 GB RAM, 320 GB Hard Drive, Optical Drive) (Personal Computers)
I had been looking at the XL1 for a while, then heard about the XL2, so waited and bought the XL2 almost as soon as it came out, so probably overpaid for it, but it has earned its keep by taming our collection of DVDs and CDs. We have 2 small children, and no one seems to want to put the DVDs back in their cases, so they would sit in piles around the DVD player, getting scratched and knocked in the floor. I also wanted to get our CDs out of the house and reclaim the space they were taking up for other purposes, plus get them all ripped so that I could put them on my iPod and also play them anywhere in the house. Finally, we had bought a 50" plasma, and I really wanted to have a living room computer to connect to it to view family photos, listen to music, watch videos of the kids, and browse the web.
Overall, I love the unit, as it did all the things that I bought it for, but it has not been without its share of problems. My CDs are all ripped and out of the house, our DVDs are under control, and we have a screen-saver that kicks in and displays family photos at random, which is very nice. I am typing this right now via the unit using the plasma as a monitor.
I'll try to touch on some of the features and issues we've had here.
CPU
You would think that dual Pentium D 920 2.8GHz processors would make this unit pretty fast, but there are many times when I find it to be pretty sluggish. Web-response is pretty zippy, but it's really slow just after booting, which I believe is due to a myriad of background programs that run at boot time. I haven't had time to dig into what might be causing this, though I do know there is a Media Center Connect program which takes up a lot of CPU time at boot time. The other thing that bothers me is that I bought a Sanyo VPC-HD1A camera which generates MP4 hi-def videos. QuickTime, which is the only player of which I'm aware that can play this format, cannot seem to decode these videos on the XL2. In fact, the only PC in my house that is able to decode these smoothly is an HP Pavilion Media Center Edition desktop PC I have which contains a dual core AMD Athlon X2 4200+. I'm very disappointed that the XL2 can't play the HD MP4s, as I'd really like to watch them on the plasma.
DVD changer:
It's a little loud and clunky, but we put it inside the entertainment cabinet, and we don't mind it. The basic usage model for the unit is that you rip all your CDs to the hard drive just after you buy it, and then you can fill it up with your DVDs and leave them there. I'll address ripping CDs and playing DVDs separately. One other problem I've had with the DVD Changer is that sometimes the XL2 PC unit does not detect it, particularly after the main unit has crashed. To recover, I've had to power down the CPU, and then turn off the changer, wait about 15 seconds, then turn on the changer, wait until it stops whirring, then power on the CPU again. The changer seems to just go "out to lunch" if the main unit crashes. Given that it runs Windows, you can expect it to crash now and then. To be fair, this is a pretty complex device, with lots of drivers from lots of different vendors, and any one of them could be the culprit. Still, since my old CD changers and DVD players have never crashed, it shows that PC-based AV equipment has a ways to go to match the historic reliability of non-PC-based equipment. (Interestingly, my DVR/cable box is Linux based, and even it crashes and/or reboots now and then.)
Ripping CDs:
Ripping CDs is a little tedious, as it requires several steps, but overall it still beats the heck out of ripping them 1 by 1. First you have to load the CDs. Luckily, the changer does have a "speed load" feature, which can be enabled by double clicking (not too fast; hit the button for about half second, wait a second, then hit for another half second) the LOAD button. It will then take a CD, and spin to the next empty slot to accept the next CD. It will repeat this process until you wait about 10 seconds without inserting a CD, and then it will timeout. It's still tedious, but sure better than doing them 1 by 1. After the CDs are put in, the software has to first load each one, identify it, and download artwork, album name, and song titles from the internet. This takes about 20 seconds per CD. So, for example, if you put in 100 CDs, you have to wait 30 minutes before starting the ripping. Once that is complete, then you can begin ripping the CDs. Finally, once that's done, you have to eject the copied CDs. There is an "Eject Copied CDs" feature in the software, which makes this fairly easy, assuming you remember to do it right after ripping. I have forgotten to do it right away once or twice, and then I have to go back and manually eject, which is a pain. If you want to eject ALL disks, there is a "speed eject" feature similar to the "speed load". It's also good to note that Media Center will generally rip the CDs into the format that is chosen under the Media Player. So, you have to exit the Media Center, and start Media Player to choose these options before ripping, and then re-start Media Center. I personally ripped all my CDs (about 400) into "WMA lossless" format, which took up 150GB of space. That's probably overkill for most people, but I wanted to be able to import my files into iTunes to play on my iPod, and wanted to get the best possible quality. By using "lossless" format, I can be fairly sure that iTunes is making the same quality of files that it would make if it ripped the CDs itself. (I read about this trick on a forum somewhere.)
Playing DVDs:
DVDs can be loaded in the same way that CDs are loaded, so the "speed load" and "speed eject" features are just as useful. The same "20 second per disk" applies for DVDs as well. One really annoying thing about the XL2 is that it will not play a copyrighted DVD to the component outputs unless the screen resolution is set to a fairly low level (800x600, I think). This forces you to leave the XL2 in a lower resolution mode, which then affects the appearance of the Windows desktop. This is supposedly to thwart hi-quality DVD copies from being made. This can be remedied by using HDMI to connect the XL2 to the TV. If you must use the component outputs, then you can get software such as "DVD Region+CSS Free" which can allow DVD playback at the higher resolutions even on the component outputs. However, I had problems with this interfering with the automatic recognition of CDs and DVDs in the changer. I eventually found that I had to disable RegionFree before inserting the disks, and then re-enable it after the automatic detection and catlogging completed, which was a bit of a pain. RegionFree does have other nice features like skipping the FBI warnings and previews, and disabling any navigation limitations that the DVD may have. Since I switched to HDMI, I disabled RegionFree for the time being until I have more time to figure out why it messes up the recognition functions. I might also try a different brand of software to see if it improves things, since I'd still like to be able to skip the warnings and trailers.
Recording to DVD:
Ironically, though we thought this was a pretty cool feature when we were contemplating the purchase of the unit, we've never used it. You cannot copy DVD with this feature, but you can put in blank DVDs and back-up recorded TV to the DVDs if you want. Again, we've never actually used this feature, as we just don't record enough TV on the unit, and the TV that is recorded seems a bit noisy ("staticky"). For the few series that we would like to actually watch over and over, we would rather just buy them at retail, as many shows come in widescreen format and with extras, and in much higher quality.
Video outputs:
I also noticed that the XL2 seemed to have some noise on the component video outputs. With my cable box, and using the same cables, I noticed no difference in quality between component and HDMI, so I have the cable box connected via component to make room for the XL2 on the HDMI port of the TV. Still, it's disconcerting that the component ports on the XL2 are so noisy. It looks clearly like some digital noise, as I see diagonal lines across the screen, especially when using Media Center where the background is mostly blue. I should also note that, when I first hooked up HDMI to the TV, the XL2 was already powered up, and nothing came out on the TV screen. I had to power down and restart (not just reboot) the machine before the XL2 seemed to recognize that there was an HDMI cable connected. It may be best to connect the HDMI cable while the XL2 is powered down, then boot it up (that's probably what the instructions say, but who reads those? :-). Also, I would NOT recommend trying to change the video drivers to newer ones from Nvidia. I tried it, but had lots of problems, and then restored the original drivers. I think the HDMI port is an XL2-specific feature that is not present on most of other GeForce 6600 graphics cards, so it may not even be supported properly by the generic drivers that Nvidia provides.
Using the XL2 for computing on the TV:
I currently use a 1240x692 mode with my 1080i plasma (1366x768 native resolution, I believe). With the icons set to large, it's fairly readable at about 10 to 12 feet. Sony provides a tool called Liquid Surf which allows web-pages to be magnified. Optionally, you can uninstall Liquid Surf, and upgrade to Internet Explorer 7, which has a similar feature. I find I can read most things at 100%, but some sites use small print that requires 125% or 150% to read easily.
Keyboard:
I hate the keyboard. It's usable, but it barely has enough range to make it 10 to 12 feet across my living room. It also has things like Home, End, PageUp, PageDown doubled up with other keys so that you have to use the Fn...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Media PC, August 9, 2006
This review is from: Sony VAIO VGX-XL2 Digital Living System (Intel Pentium D Processor 920, 1 GB RAM, 320 GB Hard Drive, Optical Drive) (Personal Computers)
I did a lot of research before I purchased this unit. I wanted a Media PC that would fit in my stereo rack that would actually look like my other components. My final two choices were this sony and the HP. I chose the Sony because it has HDMI (I like having the sound transfered over Digital) output, which none of the other Media PCs have out there and the processor was a dual core, which means it's more up to date than other units I looked at.
The setup was real easy, although when I connected it to my TV it didn't like it. I had to update the video driver before it worked correctly, I started by using the component cable. My TV supports 1080P natively, so the picture looks great. The 200 Disk changer works flawlessly and pretty easily. The keyboard that comes with it is allright, I wish it were a bluetooth keyboard, but I guess we can't have it all. The Remote is okay as well, It's not very ergonomic, it's a standard Media PC remote with some minor Sony Tweaks, it's not a sony remote by any means. Since I don't have an ethernet port near my TV, I have to use the wireless G that's built into the unit; This sony has one of the strongest receivers I've seen in a wireless network card.
The only think I don't like about this unit is that it doesn't really have room for expantion. It seems that all the PCI slots are being used by the two tunner cars that are in the unit. I haven't dared to open it to see if maybe one of them can be removed. Also it's kind of pricy, but my experience with the new VAIO PCs has been that they are very reliable. I also think that they could have used a higher end graphics card like a 7600 series or above nVidia.
Overall, I'd recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No