11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
great documentation but take the history with a grain or two of salt, December 27, 2008
This review is from: Sound Art: Beyond Music, Between Categories (Book & CD) (Hardcover)
as with most rizzoli books, this one seems to have had a budget and a research team for images. it has photo documentation of pieces i've only seen in rare gallery exhibition catalogs or in some case, only heard stories of. licht has included many works sorely missed in other sound art specific books (kahn, labelle, de la motte haber etc) and for that reason the book is well worth the cost when it comes out in soft cover. the writing however, as has been mentioned in other postings, is informal compared to most histories of the sort and in places, value judgements are made which make the text read as too personal to be trusted as a history as such and should have been caught by an editor. the history also has gaps, and suffers from the same problem of most sound art history writing: too much time spent on deciding what is included and excluded from the genre by definitions and not enough space devoted to close readings of individual works as exemplars of practice. this book paired with Brandon LaBelle's 'Background Noise: Perspectives on Sound Art' (low on documentation, but very theoretical) and perhaps the new 'Autumn Leaves: Sound and the Environment in Artistic Practice' produced by CRISAP and edited by Angus Carlyle (not available on amazon yet), would make a balanced sound art history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Oh, it's not so bad, January 21, 2011
This review is from: Sound Art: Beyond Music, Between Categories (Book & CD) (Hardcover)
I produce an occational podcast; I'm familiar with compiling and creating sounds for fun.
There's a lot that is touched on here in "Sound Art": sound playgrounds, DJ experience, Laurie Anderson, 1950s tape recordings, artist crossovers, Walter Murch, Maryanne Amacher, Stephen Vitiello, Max Neuhaus, Christian Marclay, LaMonte Young and especially John Cage. Eleven pages of footnotes. Four Hundred index entries.
Despite what others have written here "Sound Art" is not the worst book ever of all time. The pictures are crisp and there are lots of pictures. Quotations are set apart in blue ink. It has heavy paper. The dust cover flap says that "... Alan Licht lays bear the origins of sound art...". Those funny flap writers, afraid of yogi bare.
"Sound Art" sets itself up as authoritative but it is limited to thoughts about installation pieces, about conjured electrical mechanical inventions, about sound reflecting physical space, about the marriage of audio with photos or paint or rope or wood. "Sound Art" is a narrow look at the intersection of visual art and noise. The subtitle after all is "Beyond Music Between Categories."
This is disappointing to me as I want to learn more about artists who creatively use found sounds, clips of voice, clips of music. But that's not this book.
So while there's a nod to The Beatles for the white album cover, and several nods to Yoko Ono, there's not a word here about the most listened-to sound-art piece in the history of humanity, Revolution #9.
Where are the scripted audio collages of Joan Schuman? Where are the field recordings of Michael Oster? Where are artists moving occasionally into sound, like Lorna Simpson? Where's spoken word poetry art?
Jim O'Rourke, 6-year bassist/guitarist for Sonic Youth and prolific record producer, provides a useless 250 word introduction. His name appears on the cover, though.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Think of it this way: for 30 quid you can buy original digitized-duplicate sound art and get the 300 page liner notes for free.
The compilation CD, about 50 minutes, is slipped into a blue paper envelope attached to the inside back cover. There are six pieces, of mediocre audio quality (as originally made) but robustly presented:
Harmonic Bridge (Bill Fontana) [11 minutes of sound of the Millenium Bridge, as broadcast into London's Tate Modern].
Rust (Steve Roden)[3+ minute sounds emanating from a steel chair].
Terre Foisonnante (Jean Dubuffet) [The famous artist's 6+ minute 1960 furious instrument scream across the sky. They were recorded using two tape recorders and here are the only creative use of stereo on this compilation.]
Jam Smear (Destroy All Monsters) [6 minute, 1970's band from Detroit playing anti-music on anti-instruments]
Still And Moving Lines of Silence in Families of Hyperbolas (Alvin Lucier)[almost 17 minutes of minimalist tone, written 1974 and recorded here 2005]
57A (Bernhard Gal) [7 minute recording of place, from Germany - my favorite, and the one piece that fits most closely to my list of omitted sounds.]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Just don't call it music..., January 7, 2008
This review is from: Sound Art: Beyond Music, Between Categories (Book & CD) (Hardcover)
Years ago, a critic remarked that so-called Performance Art might have been called either Theater or Dance if those media were less uptight. That's how I feel about sound art - if Music were more open as a discipline, we wouldn't need to have a special category of stuff called sound art. We would simply recognize that for most of the 20th century, music and visual art blurred into each other, and the artistic use of so-called non-musical sounds became increasingly important. Today, in the age of the sample, where Foley artists and composers are often one and the same, and most undergrad art students have made at least one sound piece in their lives, it's useful to have Alan Licht's clearly written, well-illustrated, handsomely designed volume on how composers and artists have worked with sound in the 20th century. Licht hits all the significant movements (Futurism, Dada, Fluxus, etc.) that contributed to sound art, and does a good job of exploring the range of possibilities (from sound sculpture to sound installation to Christian Marclay's floor covered with vinyl records). While I might wish that some of the younger contemporary artists working with sound got more space, you can't have everything. A few years ago, the Pompidou Center in Paris did an exhibit called Son et Lumiére, and if you can find the catalog (and read French) it provides the history of the connection of music and visual art missing in Licht's book. But until that's available in an affordable English version, Licht's book is probably the best available on the topic. And the handy CD included means you can use your ears as well as your eyes to consider the topic, a welcome addition.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No