Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
I'm taking it on faith., May 7, 2001
This review is from: Sound on Sound (Hardcover)
I was totally involved in NYC scene pre-1980 (after that I was in Japan for a while) so judging from what I know about what went on there after what was if I do say so myself the golden age of NYC rock (ca. 1974-79), this book seems pretty accurate in its depiction of a crummy third rate band going through the motions. That's just the story part. The book is told in this fantastic, difficult to describe way. Very parsed, if that's the right word. Each section corresponds to a track on a multi-track tape, "Basic Rhythm," "Vocals," "Solo," etc. Cool, if a little confusing. You're never sure what happened. Very unlinear and kind of cool and abundant in footnotes and self-referential asides way way before Wallace or Eggers or those guys. Definitely a must-read--even if you hate its guts, which about two people I've told about it ended up doing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
What a sad and lonely little book., April 14, 2005
This review is from: Sound on Sound (Hardcover)
"Only one left in stock!" Each time I visit this lonely, windswept page I notice that superfluous legend, and I think to myself, "My! No one's bought that last copy yet." It must be a year or two since it first appeared here, like a sign advising of the maximum legal occupancy of a room in some Last Man on Earth movie. How ironic!, you're supposed to think. But Amazon adds insult to injury by advising, "Order soon (more on the way)." Oh, Amazon! Must you rub it in? We all know that nobody wants Christopher Sorrentino's little book, except maybe his mother. Only one left in stock! Why not just say, "We're almost out of this bomb! It's so insignificant it's not even worth paying the parcel post rate to return it to the publisher! We just keep it around, put hot things on it when we're sitting around the break room table having lunch, me, Terry, Glenn, Little Chris, Mike--the whole shipping room gang knows which books you can and cannot use as a trivet. Can't: Jonathan Safran Foer. Can: Curtis White. Can't: Dave Eggers. Can: Alex Shakar. Can't: Rick Moody. Well, OK, maybe it's OK to serve piping hot Chef Boy-Ar-Dee Ravioli off a copy of PURPLE AMERICA." Poor SOUND ON SOUND. I think it must be the loneliest book at Amazon. Here's ESTUARINE AND MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSK CULTURE, by Winston Menzel. That's ranked around 1,300,000th--about 700,000 ahead of SOUND ON SOUND. Is SOUND ON SOUND really more boring than a book that retails for $359 and begins, "The soft-shell clam Mya arenaria (Linnaeus) (family Myidae; common names: soft-shell clam, long-necked clam, nannynose, sand gaper, steamer clam) has an elongate, elliptical shell (Figure 1), with a large siphonal gape at the elongate posterior end and a small gape anteriorly." And how about XYLEM STRUCTURE AND THE ASCENT OF SAP, by Melvin T. Tyree. Sounds like a Vollmann title, almost. It begins, "The development of upright land plants depended on the development of a water conducting system." Everyone knows that. Rank? About 800,000th--1.2 million ahead of SOUND ON SOUND. How about intubation? Here's COMMUNICATION AND SWALLOWING MANAGEMENT OF TRACHEOSTOMIZED AND VENTILATOR DEPENDENT ADULTS. No quote, but the front matter promises to avoid a "cook book" approach, thank goodness. Also ranked around 800,000th. Is there nothing poor, poor SOUND ON SOUND can outsell? I don't understand it. Let me look.....................................................................................Ah! Jerome Charyn's DEATH OF A TANGO KING (#2,337.737). Of course, Jerome Charyn has written about forty-five books, so even his most avid readers might be forgiven for overlooking a title here and there. Sorry, lonely SOUND ON SOUND. You're still the champ.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Talented writer, but bad book, January 28, 2008
This review is from: Sound on Sound (Hardcover)
This book is about a band that could never make it in the rock scene in NY (or did they?), and the author tirelessly rips them appart. I had many problems with this book. Number one, isn't it a little easy to rip on a band that never made it. It's a little like picking on the smallest kid in school. It's easy, but why bother. Second, Sorrentino writes the book in a strange and creative structure. But, a cool structure doesn't make up for a dull story. Most of the book is about one night when the band just plays at a club. Pulp Fiction wasn't a good movie just because it had an interesting structure, it was an interesting story to begin with. The worst chapter is Dub 3 (Vocals) where every character is asked the same three questions. Again, these are not interesting questions, or answers. It's just people rambling. I know some people liked it, and I thought I would like it too, but in the end it just sounds like a talented writer with no direction or motivation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|