Customer Reviews

South Pacific: In Concert From Carnegie Hall

5 star:		(80)
4 star:		(7)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(5)

 

 

What superlatives are left to describe this concert? This is a truly exhilirating, incandescent performance filled with an all too rare quality, passion. The New York Times review described it best as "near complete rapture." For those who belittle the idea of Reba McEntire in a Broadway musical, take a look at this first before passing unjustified comments. It doesn't matter if she's a country singer, an opera singer or a rap singer, or if she is older than what Nellie Forbush should be. Anyone who can perform with this level of passion and conviction deserves unstinting praise. What a pity it was a one-night only performance. At least we have this DVD as a permanent keepsake. Brian Stokes Mitchell is in equally fine form as Emile de Becque, the French plantation owner, who deservedly brings the house down (and the concert itself to an almost minute-long standstill) with his moving rendition of "This Nearly Was Mine." It may only be a concert performance, without costumes or sets, but it puts many fully staged musicals to shame. All the supporting cast are equally commendable. My one tiny criticism is that the voice coach should have taught the children to sing "Dites Moi" with a more "neutral" accent. The children are supposed to be French Polynesian, children of "a cultured Frenchman." However, they sound more American than Nellie Forbush.

The picture quality on this DVD is absolutely gorgeous. When you consider that it was practically a last minute decision to film the concert at all, the camera crew, sound crew and all the technicians involved did a truly remarkable job. One of the finest live performance recordings I've had the pleasure to watch. The picture is presented in its original 1.78:1 widescreen (enhanced for widescreen TV) with razor sharp images, vibrant, natural colors & perfect black levels. Two soundtracks are provided, one in 2.0 Dolby Stereo and the other in 5.1 Dolby Surround. Rich, sumptuous sound throughout. This is a performace to treasure for years to come. Already I've watched it through thrice, two occasions back-to-back. It always has me singing and whistling along from start to finish. Guaranteed to raise a smile on even the dreariest day. A deliriously joyful DVD. There are no extras but I don't begrudge the lack one bit. This will be my favorite DVD for many months to come.

The score for South Pacific, by Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II, is one of the richest, biggest and most romantic Broadway has ever seen. The show opened in 1949, set records and won just about every award there was. Mary Martin and Ezio Pinza starred as Nellie Forbush, a young nurse from Little Rock, and Emile de Becque, an older French planter. In its essence, South Pacific is the story of two romances. In one, between Nellie and de Becque, Nellie must face the consequences of her prejudices. She does, and overcomes them. In the other, between Lt. Joe Cable and Liat, Cable does not.

This concert version was staged without sets or costumes, but with a full orchestra and chorus. Reba McEntire plays Nellie, Brian Stokes Mitchell plays de Becque and Jason Danieley plays Cable. Lillias White is Bloody Mary, Liat's mother, and Alec Baldwin is Luther Billis. The entire cast is excellent, but this one-time performance would not have worked as well as it does without McEntire and Mitchell. They bring a natural command to their parts, they are believable as two people falling in love in the middle of a war. Most importantly, they sing superbly and in character.

South Pacific would not be the classic it is without the extraordinary Rodgers and Hammerstein score. Rodgers and Hammerstein were two hugely gifted pros at the top of their game when they wrote South Pacific. The score not only was carefully constructed to advance the story and, deliberately, to aim for hits, but to dig deeply into serious feelings about mature love, racial prejudice, uncertainty and plain joy. Consider a few examples:

--The score was written for Ezio Pinza, a basso profundo opera singer, and Mary Martin, a Broadway light coloratura. Martin insisted she not sing any duets with Pinza because she knew he could overpower her. The solution...a love story without joint duets. Instead, we have Twin Soliloquies in which each singer separately examines internally his and her new feelings. This is a clever and original solution to a professional problem.

--From Dites-moi to Some Enchanted Evening, in only four songs at the start of the show, Rodgers and Hammerstein are able to establish the characters of these two people, Forbush and de Becque, their backgrounds and their nature, and to establish bonds between each of them and us.

--Rodgers and Hammerstein keep us interested in the overall story by using songs to tell us things, but songs that have intrinsic charm and appeal. They deliberately juxtapose styles. Bloody Mary, for instance, is a bawdy song sung by the Navy guys, but it is followed almost immediately by Bali Ha'i, a dreamy song of longing.

--The score is fashioned for the strengths of the two leads. Nellie's songs tend to be upbeat explorations of her honest personality. De Becque's songs tend to be deeper and more serious. His were written specifically with Pinza's strengths and limitations in mind. They are written for a deep sound. This Nearly Was Mine, in fact, is almost an art song. Notice how so many of de Becque's sung lines end with the vowel "o." This gave Pinza the best sound to hit with his big voice, wide open and easy to sustain. Mitchell with his strong baritone makes skilled use of it.

--Rodgers invariably wrote the music after Hammerstein wrote the lyrics. Many would consider this limiting to a composer, and very few composers do it this way. With Rodgers, his talent was so great it didn't seem to make any difference. In South Pacific, his range moves from raucous songs for the sailors to one of the most delicate of love songs, Younger Than Springtime; from songs of optimism, A Cockeyed Optimist and A Wonderful Guy, to a song of great despair, This Nearly Was Mine. And Rodgers technique was extraordinary. Listen to what he does with Some Enchanted Evening, a big fat romantic song if there ever was one. Rodgers writes a flat-out romantic musical line with:
Some enchanted evening
You may see a stranger,
you may see a stranger
Across a crowded room
And somehow you know,
You know even then
That somewhere you'll see her
Again and again.
But Rodgers, out of the blue, flats the last note on the last "again." I can't explain why it works, but it gives the song an unusual power of longing and expectation. Every now and then he'd employ this device and it works every time.

--The score features You've Got To Be Carefully Taught, a song that places racial prejudice squarely in the bulls-eye. It wasn't unusual for politicians in the South to insist this song be cut before they'd approve of the touring show coming to town. Rodgers and Hammerstein routinely refused all such requests.

Rodgers and Hammerstein were consummate artists who knew exactly what they were doing. With this concert version, South Pacific receives one of the best presentations I've seen. The emphasis is on the score, with dialogue used to keep the story-line clear. Staging is cleverly handled, with the singers sitting in chairs in front of the orchestra and the chorus in the rear. Stage director Walter Bobbie keeps the movements fluid and interesting, especially when he moves the chorus up front.

The DVD presentation is excellent. Although it's a filmed record of a stage presentation, video director Steve Ruggi uses the cameras and editing to keep things moving. It's one of the best editing jobs for a staged show that I've come across. There are no extras.

I second the comments made about the 'blow-off' of a review with 1 star. What may appear to be an odd casting decision has to be experienced first before any kind of judgment can be made, and of all the reviews submitted prior to this, that is the only one that has such a pious air! Obviously the 'critic' did not remember that Reba is a Broadway veteran of 'Annie Get Your Gun' and that Nellie is after all, from Little Rock, Arkansas!

The entire performance is a delight (I have it also on CD) from beginning to end, and if I had any quibbles or issues, it would be two...first, it would have been wonderful if some additional background material could have been included (rehearsal sequences, interviews with cast and director)...second (and a truly minor point), as wonderful a singer as Brian Stokes Mitchell is, it would have been a smoother transition had the DVD menu opened with an instrumental version of 'Some Enchanted Evening'.

But the DVD is a wonderful reminder of what happens when you experience live theater. Seeing Reba McEntire as Nellie makes one realize what added depth and heart the part can have. Brian Stokes Mitchell has an 'ab fab' voice, and even Alec Baldwin shows how a momentary lapse on stage can result in something charming and wonderful that makes him seem not so much a casting frill but a necessary part to the cast chemistry. And for those accounting types who think 'canned' music is just as good as live, I defy anyone to listen to the Orchestra of St. Luke's and tell me that singing and interacting with a live orchestra doesn't bring a special flair and sparkle to this performance.

Avoid stereotyping...listen first...you may be pleasantly surprised and delighted, as I was and still am!

This was the most incredible live performance I have ever seen on PBS and knew instantly that I wanted to buy this DVD. Brian Stokes Mitchel's acting and majestic and powerful voice filled the theatre
that evening and he was truly into the character. Reba was the most believable Nellie Forbush I have ever seen. Alex Baldwin played a great Luther Billis and the Seabees and nurses sang and danced up a storm! The orchestra was absolutely fabulous.
At the end of the performance Reba was moved to tears watching the audience cheering and giving them a standing ovation.
Don't miss this one-- it's the best!

I loved it. I taped it when it ran on my local PBS station and have watched it over and over. I'm going to get it on DVD so I can have it forever. I've seen the original 1958 movie lots of times, and I like this version just as much. When Brian Stokes Mitchell sings "This Nearly Was Mine", I cry every time. I thought Reba McEntire would be too old to play Nellie, but this woman can do anything!! She was fabulous. I enjoyed Alec Baldwin in the comic numbers, even if he doesn't sing! What a Honeybun!! If you loved the movie and its songs, then you will also love this concert performance.

Reba is truly very talented! I never would have guessed. Her voice, really adds to the show. The cast enjoyed what they were doing and it transposed to the audience. I enjoyed this concert version more than any other rendition of South Pacific.

I would recommend this DVD to everybody!!

I've never been a Reba fan; I'm into classical, but not country. I was blown out of my seat by Reba; I couldn't have been more stunned by the perfect casting and the brilliant performances. Brian Mitchell Stokes moved me to tears every single time he walked to the front. When "Bloody Mary" started singing "Bali Hai" I stopped breathing. My daughter had to punch me at the end of the performance to get me to resume breathing. The fact that there was no set (no palm trees, no sand, nothing) only made the setting come more alive in the imagination. Buy this video now and find a comfortable chair when you watch it. You might not be able to move until the last applause has died down at Carnegie Hall.

I just received my DVD a few hours ago and already resampled the magic of that evening in May when the show aired on PBS. I like some other reviwers here tuned in expecting to tune out in short order.

No way, it really was an Enchanting Evening from start to finish. The music was revitalized in this concert performance and each of the performers were oustanding.

The ridiculous comments regarding Reba McEntire's performance by the previous reviewer makes me wonder whether he even saw or heard the performance. I was dubious of the casting as well but the woman was absolutly enchanting as Nellie. And she didn't fake one line. My major love is opera and she SANG the role. Buy this DVD it is wonderful.

CARNEGIE HALL, ROGERS AND HAMMERSTEIN, AND A UNIQUE CONJOINING OF BROADWAY STARS, BRING ABOUT AN EXCELLENT CONCERT VERSION OF "SOUTH PACIFIC". REBA MCINTIRE MAKES A GREAT
PERFORMANCE AS NELLIE FORBUSH THE PEPPY MIDWESTERN NURSE . BRIAN STOKES MITCHELL WAS BORN FOR THE ROLE OF DE BECQUE, HIS VOICE PERHAPS MORE SUITED TO THE PART THAN PINZA'S. JASON DANIELEY IS APTLY CAST AS JOE CABLE. WHO WOULD HAVE THOUGHT OF ALEC BALDWIN AS LUTHER, A ROLE HE PLAYS TO THE HILT. HOWEVER MY FAVORITE PERFORMANCE IS BY LILLIAS WHITE AS BLOODY MARY. YES I LIKE!

THANK-GOODNESS FOR PUBLIC TELEVISION'S "GREAT PERFORMANCES" RECORDING OF THIS WONDERFUL CONCERT. AT THE LAST MINUTE THEY COMMITED TO THIS PROJECT AND RECORDED IT FOR POSTERITY. WALTER BOBBIE NEEDS TO BE CHEERED FOR PUTTING THIS ONE NIGHT ONLY FETE WITH ONLY 4 REHEARSALS! I PRAISE CASEY NICHOLAW FOR HIS STAGING OF THIS CONCERT.

TO CUT IT SHORT , POINT AND CLICK THIS DVD INTO YOUR CART TODAY!

"Rodgers and Hammerstein's SOUTH PACIFIC in Concert from Carnegie Hall" features Reba McEntire's authenically accented voice bringing Nellie Forbush to vibrant life while Brian Stokes Mitchell melts your heart with 'This Nearly Was Mine' and Alec Baldwin provides comic relief.

The DVD includes dialogue to flesh out the entire story as well as all of the truly memorable songs that make this show a classic of musical theater not to be missed. Chorus members use the stage to bring the large production numbers alive with action so the overall becomes a hybrid between a pure concert and the full show. Kudos to PBS for making this unique concert performance available!