A very good special edition reissue, while I don't consider this album essential for Bowie fans, it is a historically important snapshot of David Bowie at the tail end of the 60s. The reality is, while Bowie kept at the singles market throughout the 60s, he was probably too out of sync with the sensibilities of the 60s to belong to that era. He began to find his voice with this album, but he would also have a ways to go before he truly arrived. First off, the title track is a truly great piece, not only a great song, but a great record as well. The team of Producer Gus Dudgeon, and arranger Paul Buckmaster delivered such an impeccable record, that Elton John and Taupin would soon snatch them up for John's series of classic albums. Rick Wakeman's eerie Mellotron blends almost perfectly with Buckmaster's arrangement. Producer Tony Visconti takes over for the rest of the proceedings, "Unwashed and Somewhat Slightly Dazed" evolves into a good up-tempo rocker, with some hot harmonica soloing and an horn ensemble. The fun little filler known as "Don't Sit Down" is tagged on the end of "Unwashed" as all one track, and this differs from the Ryko reissue from the early 90s.
"Letter To Hermione" is a plaintive ballad about the breakup of his girlfriend. "The Cygnet Committee" is one of the more interesting tracks, as it's theme would be explored again with "Savoir Machine" off of the next album TMWSTW, as well as some thematic aspects of Ziggy Stardust, A messianic figure exploiting his followers, while his followers exploit him in kind. The song also seems to also be a scathing lament of the fallen ideals of utopian hippies, i.e. the outcome of Altamont, the career opportunism of Woodstock, etc... The electric Harpsichord work of Rick Wakemen is outstanding on this track and tends to get overlooked. "Janine" is probably the most accessible track, and for my tastes, the least interesting, and the track I tend to feel seems like filler. While not essential, I like "An Occasional Dream", while it seems a little dated, the Flute and recorder ensemble works well, and harkens to Bowie's Anthony Newley influence. The Newley influence creeps through on "The Wild Eyed Boy From Freecloud", I initially assumed that Paul Buckmaster was involved in the arrangement, being that it was the B side to "Space Oddity", and Buckmaster could be heard on Bowie's Demo, but to my surprise Tony Visconti was responsible for this epic, over the top orchestral arrangement.
"God Knows I'm Good" is a narrative about a shoplifting incident that manages to comment on rationalist thinking. "Memory of a Free Festival" is an odd closer, with Bowie's plaintive vocal and pump organ, that again seems to be a sympathetic lament on the idealism of the late 60s. The closing "Sun Machine" segment seems to reference "Hey Jude", as there's a horn ensemble buried in the mix to reinforce that impression. While there's a certain degree of studio polish on the album, there's also a kind of looseness present we would never see again from Bowie.
Peter Mew's work on the digital remaster is outstanding, with some added presence, and clarity when needed. The second disc is generous with it's selections, while a number of these tracks appeared on the Ryko issues, or the Sound and Vision box set. These versions of "Space Oddity" and "Occasional Dream" are demos featuring his brief partnership with John Hutchinson, This version of "Freecloud" had already been heard on the 'Sound and Vision' collection. "Let Me Sleep Beside You, Unwashed", and "Janine" are recordings from the BBC Radio D.T.L show, and rather good. Two mixes of "London, Bye, Ta, Ta" are included, although the track had already appeared on the 'Sound and Vision' set. A Stereo mix of 1970's "The Prettiest Star" with Marc Bolan is included.
A Stereo mix of "Conversation Piece" is featured, whereas the Ryko addition featured a Mono mix, this track is interesting from the standpoint of showing a confessional self reflective side to Bowie's writing that normally isn't seen. The electric re-take of "Memory of a Free Festival" is included, featuring the first time Mick Ronson appears, as well as a layer of moog synths, this was the other bonus featured on the Ryko 1990s issue, this version of "Memory" hints at the hard rock glam direction Bowie would soon take. A longer version of "Memory", from the original album, with a longer fade out is also included. Also included is an alternative mix of "Freecloud" where the vocal is brought more forward, and the orchestration less emphasized. The Italian mix of "Space Oddity (Ragazzo Solo, Ragazza Sola)", features an interesting mix of the backing tracks for Gus Dudgeon's production and brings this collection full circle.
The packaging, while missing lyrics, includes a great set of liner notes from Kevin Cann, as well as a timeline of Bowie's career during this period. As well as unreleased photos, sketches, and art work. The packaging certainly offers value for your dollar, but seems geared towards completists, or the very curious. Hopefully this will lead the way towards generous reissues of "The Man Who Sold The World" and "Hunky Dory". Recommended.