17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Shoddy Journalism, February 1, 2008
This review is from: Spaceships of the Pleiades (Hardcover)
It does not matter whether the Billy Meier Case is legitimate or not when writing a review on Kal's book. The fact of the matter is, as another reviewer has already put it, Kal's investigative approach is seriously lacking.
The Billy Meier case has over 100 independent witnesses who have witnessed some form of "evidence" of alien activity connected to Billy Meier over the years to this present day. Kal makes no attempt to try to let any of them speak in his book. Without any good basis for doing so, he basically accuses all 100+ witnesses of being liars and/or of being in on this "grand hoax" without offering any good motive or explanation for why there would be so many witnesses in the first place and why all of the witnesses, even the many who are in no way affiliated with Meier, would be caught up in such a scheme.
There are over 360 photographs still in existence to this day that can be examined, some which still have the original slides in existence despite what Korff has falsely stated. Korff makes every attempt in his book only to analyze the least impressive of the photographs still in existence and expects the reader to assume that all of the arguments against the weakest ones will also hold up against the more impressive ones that baffled those who can definitely be considered experts in the field of photography and such, as opposed to Korf. As was stated by another, he makes no attempt to analyze any of the videos but tries to let the reader believe that his explanations for the least impressive of the photos can also be used to explain all of the videos and all of the other photos. He has no "smoking guns" as he states. He only says how Meier COULD have created even the least impressive photos but no definitive proof even of these that would hold up in a court of law.
I have read better research papers from 6th graders than this book by Kal Korff. For most of the book, Kal sounds like he is an angry teenager talking on the phone to one of his friends. As other analyses of this book have shown, Korff takes no care to make correct references to other Meier literature, he seems to deliberately falsify other documentation (likely with the hope that his reader won't have access to the other documents that he is referencing so that they won't be able to verify what he writes). He makes no attempt to try to look into the story itself (despite the title of the book being the Billy Meier STORY) and all of the various events that surrounded the case while the photos and other evidences were being produced, such as the people who were actually living in the Meier home for weeks at a time, searching for models, photo labs, science journals, etc. and who were unable to find anything. It is basically a work of name-calling, baseless accusations, deliberate falsifications, and to say the best: shoddy journalism.
If the Meier case is a hoax, Kal's book is not the definitive expose of revealing the hoax. All areas of the case, especially the evidences that have already been documented and analyzed by experts, need careful attention to be given to them, with good explanations for each of them in order for it to be properly debunked. How easy is it to complain about all of the weak evidence of the case while completely ignoring all of the strong evidence and try to form one's conclusions based on one's ignorance? Many, like Kal, do this on a regular basis.
The reason I gave this book a two-star rating is because the case DID need some effort on the con- side. All other books (not articles) that have been published in English on the case are on the pro- side. Kal did certainly spend a lot of time and effort on the con- side to give the whole controversy some balance so I'll give him a star for that. However, if this is the only definitive con- book ever published on the case, it seems only to add more credibility to the case rather than disproving it if one looks into all of the available material that has been published on the case. "Smoking guns" must come in other forms than what Kal has given to us.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
small piece of info, June 23, 2009
This review is from: Spaceships of the Pleiades (Hardcover)
Kal K. Korff -- Untruth and Dubious Intentions
Many people have asked about FIGU's opinion of Kal K. Korff and his book Spaceships of the Pleiades (1995, Prometheus Books). Well, frankly, we do not like it when someone publishes a shoddy book full of untruth as it is the case with Korff's (WV). Moreover, we assume that the content of a book gives one a hint about the way of thinking, if not the character of the author (WV).
By using extra big types, Kal K. Korff was able to 'stretch' his book up to 439 pages. Acknowledgements alone cover more than 10 pages. It seems that a thick book shall generate an impression of importance and respectability.
Essentially, Korff's book is about his trip to Switzerland. Under the assumed name of STEVE THOMAS, and in disguise, he visited the Semjase Silver Star Center, Schmidrueti, in Summer 1991. He was accompanied by Tina Layton. Korff had opportunity to speak to FIGU members on two days for some hours. He didn't speak a word with Billy Meier.
Since nearly all pages of Korff's book contains information that is untrue and exaggerated (WV) it is impossible to list them all. It would need the space of another book.
A few excerpts from Korff's book shall demonstrate his dubious (WV) intentions to manipulate and misuse the readers for his bad aims. Some of Korff's claims and distortions are so absurd that a reasonable person can but laugh.
Korff's claim (page 38):
"... During one of these alleged time-travel adventures in the past, he [Billy Meier] met with Jesus Christ! ... but he is Jesus Christ reincarnated!"
The truth:
Never, not verbally or in writing, did Billy Meier ever claim having met Jesus Christ, or to be his reincarnation. Billy Meier vehemently dissociates himself from such impertinent claims and rumors by Korff and others.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff's claim (page 64):
"Although we had made it only a few hundred feet onto the property, it was already obvious that Meier was anything but "poor," contrary to what his proponents would have everyone believe. ... After walking about ten minutes, Tina and I came across a large brown wooden building with an angled roof off to our left. As we would later discover, this was a "guest house" ..."
The truth:
The Semjase Silver Star Center isn't owned by Billy Meier. All FIGU members are joint owners! Besides, it is only a 3-minute walk from the Restaurant Freihof to the Center's first house. And: we don't have any "guest house".
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff's claim (pages 67-69):
"... From where I stood, at the railing which prevented me from straying off the main gravel roadway, I could see down at the bottom of the hillside what were the faint remnants of three "UFO landing rings" that had been there since at least June 1980. ... Even though the landing tracks were eleven years old by the time of my visit and were barely visible to the naked eye, ... Even though my video camera has a 10x zoom lens, the landing-tracks proved to be too far away to observe any meaningful details from the location where I was standing. ... incredibly Gary Kinder [author of LIGHT YEARS] says he never saw any landing-tracks during the entire five weeks he spent living at Meier's place! Instead, Kinder claims he only "talked to several people who had seen them and who had photographed them while still fresh. It is doubtful that Gary Kinder's claim is true, since the three UFO landing-tracks on Billy Meier's property are directly behind his house and down the hill in his own back yard! Not only are they easily visible from numerous locations throughout the property, but are in fact impossible to miss most of the time when walking back and forth between the guest house and Billy Meier's residence. ..."
The truth:
Fig. 7 on page 65 'clearly' shows
1) that the meadow where Menara landed her beamship on June 15, 1980, lies hidden behind bushes and trees;
2) the exact landing place lies hidden behind a knoll on the hillside and would even be invisible to the naked eye, if there were no trees to obstruct the view from the house;
3) The landing tracks - circles of grass pressed counterclockwise to the ground - "vanished" as soon as the meadow was cut and the cows were grazing.
Conclusion: Either Korff had hallucinations, or he is a ... (WV)!
Concerning Korff's 'drawing' of the "Meier's compound" (Fig. 10 on page 70): All distances and proportions are incorrect (the landing tracks are much farther away from the house than may be seen on Korff's drawing!). Is Korff really not capable of producing a correct drawing? Or does he deliberately create a false picture in order to lead the readers onto a wrong path?!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff, the "meticulous" investigator (page 73):
"... Elisabeth Gruber, the wife of Guido Moosbrugger, ..."
The truth:
Elisabeth Gruber is married to a Mr. Gruber. Elisabeth Moosbrugger is Guido Mossbrugger's wife.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff's fantastic ideas (page 77):
"... such as the "fact" that Billy Meier's full, true name is purportedly "Eduard Albert Meier-Zafiriou." However, a subsequent check of the local Canton Police for Meier's region in the town of Hinwil revealed that there is no record of Billy Meier's "true" name containing the word "Zafiriou" in it. ..."
In a footnote Korff writes: "The name "Zafiriou" has been added by Meier in recent years as his "mission" has taken on more religious overtones. Zafiriou is supposed to be Meier's name as a prophet, reincarnated from a past life."
The truth:
In Switzerland it is custom that a husband adds the name of his wife to his own. The maiden name of Billy Meier's wife was - in Greece - (Miss) Zafiriou. - Simple, isn't it?!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff (pages 78 ff):
Falsifications and distortions concerning the Talmud Jmmanuel
The truth:
Prof. James W. Deardorff answers: A refutation of false claims and distortions by Korff
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff's claim (page 95):
"... for among the Meier faithful we encountered (as well as in the pro-Meier literature), we are told repeatedly that Billy Meier is a simple farmer who is illiterate and has only sixth-grad education. ..."
The truth:
Billy Meier went to school for 8 years, just like most of the other children in Switzerland at that time. Yes, he lives now on a farm, but he is no farmer. His chief occupation is writing books: He preserves the vast spiritual knowledge that he himself gathered or has received to the benefit of the present and future generations.
To call Billy Meier an "illiterate" person (read: he has a limited intelligence) was the work/invention of Lee and Brit Elders. For anyone who understands German and wishes to test Billy's illiteracy it is advisable to read one of Billy's fairy tales, e.g. "Die Frühlingsprinzessin".
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korff's claims (pages 98/99):
Korff planned to take soil samples from "UFO landing tracks" on the Center's ground and writes in his book:
"... The perimeter of the Meier compound turned out to be fairly fortified; weaving my way through its defenses would prove to be a challenge. There was a high risk of being seen, due to the location of the tracks. For this reason, I decided to return to the compound at night, dressed in U.S. Army camouflage clothing so that I would minimize my visibility. As Tina and I drove back up the mountain past the Meier property, we parked our car just on the other side of the hill and walked very carefully back down toward the upper parts of the compound. For safety reasons, I made sure that Tina stayed behind, close enough to our car so that she could drive away in the event I did not return or was caught. When I approached one of the electric fences, I calmly slid underneath it, making sure that I did not touch any of its wires. After clearing the fence, I slipped on down the hill and around to where I saw the remains of one of the landing-tracks. Removing some plastic bottles from my pouch, I obtained both control and specimen soil samples. Now that I had my evidence, it was time to get out of there quickly before I got caught. With the existence of dogs at Meier's place, a weapons depot for use by his people when the end of civilization nears, security personnel, and the fact that Meier himself often carries a pistol, I am lucky I was not detected. ... I then ran to our car and Tina and I drove back to the ..."
The truth:
Everyone who is familiar with the Center grounds will surely laugh if he or she reads Korff's fantastic story.
1. The only electric and removable fence (with only one wire) was installed around the pasture area where the cows were grazing. There is no road or path in the Center that is barred by a door or a gate, and there is even a public path (a "Wanderweg") that leads through our land and near the house.
2...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No