31 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
UNSYSTEMATIC, January 15, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Behind The Wheel Spanish For Your Car / 8 One Hour Audiocassette Tapes / Complete Learning Guide and Tape Script (Cassette) (Spanish Edition) (Audio Cassette)
I am convinced that I received a different product than the one that has received the glowing reviews. I hope this review appears objective in order to help possible purchasers. The criticisms:
1. The CD program does not follow any apparent sequence/order, nor does the instructor provide any headings for each new section (I am generous with the word section here). I think this is important since one is relying completely on the instructor without the benefit of the book (compare Penton's Learn in Your Car series - short lessons, in a logical sequence, which are always introduced by the speakers - a far better organized course) With the Behind the Wheel program you will have no idea where you are (or why), or where you are going;
2. A great deal of the program is repetitive, although Frobose advises that repetition and review are important to the foreign language acquisition process. Admittedly, repetition and review are important - but why waste valuable time repeating "It's 5:30" 50 times when more time could be devoted to providing additional material? (I think numbers were repeated approx. 10 times - perhaps more) Repetition, it seems, is something better accomplished on subsequent listens;
3. Although more of a personal matter, I found Frobose to sound somewhat condescending. The "native" speaker is almost comical in the way he over-pronounces each word. Certainly, the words are expressed clearly, but if you pronounce the words in the same way as the native speaker, I am sure you will get some raised eyebrows; and,
4. Some reviewers suggest the interesting phrases/idioms are helpful for sounding "native." Honestly, the isolated phrases presented throughout the course have no context - they just come "out of the blue." Further, the phrases are not broken down for an understanding of the words/phrase (for a true "building block" system see Michel Thomas' Spanish with Michel Thomas. With MT you will build from an understanding of one word, then two, then three, etc. until you can formulate a sentence)
I would not suggest any one purchase this course. If you are looking for a solid foundation, start with Michel Thomas to gain an understanding of the structure of the language. I would follow MT with Learn in Your Car (3 volume) for additional structure and vocabulary (which MT lacks).
Hope this helps in the foreign language quest.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very Fast, Simple, and Effective, November 10, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Behind The Wheel Spanish For Your Car / 8 One Hour Audiocassette Tapes / Complete Learning Guide and Tape Script (Cassette) (Spanish Edition) (Audio Cassette)
I am delighted with the excellent results I am getting from Behind the Wheel Spanish. As a commuter, both by train and car, I can say that nothing is more important to me than clear, effective, and enjoyable Spanish instruction. The results speak for themselves, and the process was so easy and fast!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
38 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Poor quality and poor methodology, April 13, 2000
This review is from: Behind The Wheel Spanish For Your Car / 8 One Hour Audiocassette Tapes / Complete Learning Guide and Tape Script (Cassette) (Spanish Edition) (Audio Cassette)
I am actually returning the tapes. I thought the sound quality was poor and the methodology was equally poor. There is little repetition and though the speaker requests that the listener repeat phrases, little time is given to repeat the phrases. The tapes spend alot of time on sentences and not on the actual words that make up the sentence. These tapes might be more appropriate for advanced speakers wanting to polish their skills but I would not recommend them for beginners.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No