Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Flawed, but also smart and fun., July 26, 2008
This review is from: Spider Star (Hardcover)
If you can deal with the sometimes stiff writing and penciled in character relationships you'll find a book that has a lot to offer fans of hard science fiction.
One of the best aspects of the book is that it has a lot of heart, especially in the way that it handles the motivations of its main characters. For the most part these feel like real people making real mistakes and decisions in a very difficult situation. The relationships between these characters--in particular the romance sub-plots--aren't very well drawn though, which detracts from a number of the things that we are supposed to care about. There are also several questionable decisions made by characters in this book, but as I mentioned earlier I feel those decisions lend themselves to the reality of the characters. In fact decision making is one of the main themes running through the book (how do you make decisions when there is no rule book to follow? What is the right thing to do in an impossible situation).
Still there are some great themes of sacrifice and family that continued to pull me through the book.
Probably my other favorite aspect of the book was the science, which is very well laid out. Fans of physics will find a lot to enjoy in the setting of this book, which definitely pushes some boundaries. It's a pretty good mix of fiction theoretical physics that comes together to create a cohesive (if bizarre) setting. I was also impressed with the way the writer worked to incorporate other sciences. Often with hard sci-fi all you get is a lot of physics jargon, but this book mixed in archeology, medicine, military, linguistics, and computers.
The writing itself has some nice moments of humor, but can be occasionally too dry. There are some fantastic visuals in this book, but you'll have to use your imagination to conjure many of them as the descriptions tend to tell without showing very well.
All in all I actually quite enjoyed this book. I recommend you give it a try if you like hard sci-fi.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Hobbit is teased and promised and surpassed, September 1, 2008
This review is from: Spider Star (Hardcover)
I discovered this book in the new scifi section of my local library. I was slowly drawn in to care about the characters. The author mentions 'The Hobbit', 'There and back again', & 'You can't go home again' as if he is telling us what to expect. He is, and he surpasses my expectations. The science is exciting, the descriptions vivid, the imagery superb. The story moves along logically, in spite of a mind-boggling concept planet and alien aliens. The surprises are surprising, the reader is made aware of our humanity in a vast universe, and the resolutions are creative. The ultimate wrap-up of the story-arc made me weep. It is what I hoped for but did not expect. Bravo !
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
RAMA 2008, May 21, 2008
This review is from: Spider Star (Hardcover)
Humans have settled on a planet formerly occupied by an (apparently) extinct race. While exploring ruins, they accidentally trigger a doomsday device left behind by the aliens. A team of "Specialists" go racing accross the Galaxy to find the Spider Star mentioned in alien folklore, hoping to find a way to stop the doomsday device.
Take 5 parts of Clarke's "Rama" series, mix with 3 parts "Armegeddon" movie, add in one part of Niven's "Integral Trees", along with a dash of rishathra, then stir well.
While the main characters were romping about the Spider Star, one really couldn't miss the Rama connection, and Clarke did it better. Dropping heavy objects off your dirigible onto a populated area and expecting no reaction? Not rational.
The rationale behind the decision to travel to the Spider Star mode no sense as well. If it was within reach, and held such wonders, why had no one gone before? If the only evidence of its existence was a folk tale, why send your best and brightest on a 50-year goose chase when the world is in peril?
To sum up: un-original plot and setting with characters making decisions that made no sense.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|