Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My Least Favorite in the Series, but Still Worth Reading, July 14, 1998
By A Customer
When I first read *Spiderweb For Two* I was deeply disappointed. Mona, Rush, and Mark are hardly even seen. Then, as an adult, I read the entire series to a much younger friend. I realized I'd underrated this book because it wasn't what I expected. I reread it again a few months ago and I loved it. The clues left for Randy and Oliver are clever. I like where they lead. I like what we learn about Mr. Melendy from one of them. I'm glad dear Mrs. Oliphant wasn't left out. I'm only sorry there aren't any more Melendy books. That young friend I read them to loved them because his own home wasn't very happy. He told me the Melendys showed him what a family could be like. I'm sorry, but I'm a little choked up thinking how much pleasure this series has given me for most of my life. This is a good family. The children are nice without being implausible angels. Mr. Melendy, Cuffy, Willie -- these are good adults for raising children. I heartily recommend the serie! ! s, not just for children, but for adults who aren't afraid of being caught reading "kids' books." Ann E. Nichols
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The end (alas) of my favorite childhood books, September 1, 2002
"Spiderweb for Two" is the last book in the series about the Melendy family and it's my least favorite of the four, simply because there are not enough Melendys in it. When the book opens, one year after the end of the third book, the three oldest children are off to boarding school and Randy and Oliver are facing a lonely, boring winter by themselves, until a mysterious letter written on blue paper arrives in the mail, containing the first clue to what will be a year-long treasure hunt. The clues are funny and entertaining, and the adventures Randy and Oliver get into, going from one clue to the next, are enjoyable. But we miss the presence of Mona, Rush and Mark except during the brief period they are home from school for the Christmas holidays, and the adults in the family, Father, Cuffy and Willie, aren't quite enough to take up the slack.
One thing about "Spiderweb" that sets it apart from the first three books is the lack of a time frame. Enright wrote the first three during World War II and the war is at the center of the family's lives and is present in each book; the children are busy presenting a show and working after school to buy war bonds and going on scrap metal drives during the summer holiday. The first three books take place from the later winter and early spring of 1942, through the end of the summer of 1943. But although "Spiderweb" runs from October of 1944 to June of 1945, the war is never even referred to in the book. Even V-E Day in May of 1945 which would have been celebrated all over town, isn't mentioned. Perhaps this is because Enright wrote "Spiderweb" ten years after she wrote the third book and many of her readers hadn't been born during the war; but still, some mention of the events would have given the book a dimension that is present in the first three but lacking in this one.
Another problem with "Spiderweb" is that Enright seems reluctant to let some of her characters grow up. She doesn't even mention Randy's age in the book, although we know Randy is four and half years older than Oliver, which means she's already a teenager. But Randy shows no interest in boys, movie stars, popular music, or any of the things thirteen year old girls normally obsess about. Mona comes home for vacation talking about "When I grow up I want to be..." No young lady going on seventeen talks about "when I grow up", in their minds they're already grown up. Enright's young characters seem caught in a time warp, frozen in time as children.
When I turned the last page of "Spiderweb" after reading it as a child, I was devastated to realize that there would be no more Melendy books. But Enright had the right idea; the next year would have seen Randy herself going off to boarding school and Mona off to college, leaving Oliver rattling around the Four Story Mistake by his lonesome. A depressing prospect indeed. Enright knew where to end it.
Judy Lind
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A GREAT FAMILY READ-ALOUD CHOICE, January 27, 2004
One day I saw my daughter curled up with a book. "What are you reading?" I inquired. She flashed the well-loved cover of my childhood copy of Spiderweb for Two. "I was feeling Melendyish today," she explained. "Melendyish" is the perfect word to describe that sensation experienced by die-hard fans of Elizabeth Enright's four Melendy stories when nothing else will do but to curl up with one of her books and visit the beloved Melendy family once again. When I was a child the four Melendy children sometimes seemed more like real, three-dimensional people than some actual living, breathing kids I knew. Spiderweb for Two was the first Melendy book I read and it inspired me to create many mind-boggling clue hunts for my brother and my friends. The treasure hunts that figure prominently in the way my children and I celebrate holidays today can probably be traced back to those Melendyish moments of my childhood when I read this book over and over and over. (I can still recite some of the story's mysterious clues from memory!) I would suggest that you read the Melendy books in order: The Saturdays, The Four Story Mistake, Then There Were Five, Tatsinda (a fairy tale that is mentioned but not told in Then There Were Five) and finally Spiderweb For Two. Just be sure you don't stop before you get to Spiderweb for Two! Your whole family will enjoy it! If you want more funny, creative, warm and cozy family stories like these, try The Treasure Seekers, The Wouldbegoods, and New Treasure Seekers by E. Nesbit.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|