Customer Reviews

Spiral Staircase [VHS]

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

An earlier reviewer mentioned Hunnicutt and a shower scene. It is NOT functionally nudity as the camera does not go below the shoulders and it is just a few seconds long. Not remotely worth comment except to warn.

This film is not the best or the worst I have ever watched. Not having seen the earlier film of the same title, I can't make a comparison, but it does sometimes fail to convince. But any film starring Christopher Plummer gets my vote.

A lot of people are sayig that this one isnt as good as the original, but I actually liked this version. I also liked John Ronane as the doctor. Some are picking on his performance, but I thought he was absolutley adorable. I wish this version would come out on DVD.

I think this movie stands on its own merit! I didn't see the original version, but I don't feel I need to compare. The story is suspenseful, the acting is convincing and John Phillip Law is absolutely gorgeous!! If you are a JPL fan, don't miss this movie. He's acting is in top form in this thriller. Don't miss it.

This is a pretty sad attempt to update a classic favorite.

First off, do not expect any real class here. The sets are pretty good, and the veteran actors try their best, but you never get the sense that this is anything but bad TV.

As far as the differences between this and the classic film, none really get in the way of the 1975 effort. First, and most obvious, the setting is the then-present day instead of the turn-of-the-century period depicted in the classic 1946 film. Second, Helen is not a young servant girl, but a full grown widow, who third, sees her husband and daughter die in a fire, rather than witnessing her parents die as a little girl. Love interest Dr. Rawley is no longer just a simple country doctor, but instead a phychiatrist trying to treat Helen's disorder (I won't go into the ethics of a doctor getting romantic with a patient, but there it is). Lastly, many of the character names have been changed, though for what reason I can't say (perhaps going back to the originals in the book?).

Jacqueline Bisset is suitable as the mute Helen, and Christopher Plummer and John Phillip Law both deliver as the two brothers. Elaine Stritch is pretty good as the crabby nurse, while Mildred Dunnock is equally good as the bedridden matriarch of the Sherman clan. If there is an improvent over the original, it would probably have to be Gayle Hunnicutt as Blanche, Plummer's assistant (couldn't resist that one, but she's actually pretty good).

Director Peter Collinson does okay with set-ups and design, but fails miserably when it comes to bringing out the best in the actors. Most laughable is the pathetic and extra-hammy performance by John Ronane as love interest Dr. Rawley. At times, I thought I was watching a old kung fu movie, what with his over-expressive "acting" and "emoting". Sam Wanamaker is okay as the police detective, but was clearly directed to go over-the-top, just like Ronane. Collinson is probably best remembered for a Michael Caine film, "The Italian Job". In addition to this remake, he also did an overseas remake of "And Then There Were None".

Although released theatrically, it sure feels like a made-for-TV movie, and it may be interesting for comparison with the original film. I think you should see this version if you're a fan of the original, or mid-70's dreck.

Fans of the 70's will get a real hoot out of the dated style of phone Helen tries to use, too (I know I did).

This is a remake of a classic movie and I believe it equals the original. Jacqueline Bissett plays Helen, a mute women traumatized after seeing her husband die in a house fire.She is staying at her psychiatrist's house along with his assistant, the equally beautiful Gayle Hunnicutt. Ms. Hunnicutt proves she is very good at crushing a man's testicles (figuratively speaking of course) because she knows the Geek Shrink is in love with her but she has sex with his brother in the Geek's shower which is pretty cruel but she does look good in that state of undress!!!Then the brother tells the Geek Doctor that him and her are going away for some wild , uninhibited sex!!!That's pretty cruel too I think.Gee. Am I ever going to gow up and stop getting a kick out of seeing beautiful actresses in various stages of undress?I hope not. 5 stars for this movie.