4.0 out of 5 stars
3.5 stars - Not his best, but not bad either, December 1, 2006
Spirit of Man is the fifth solo album from Magnum vocalist Bob Catley. To date, Catley's solo material has been heavier and more epic than what Magnum typically delivered, thanks in large part to the influence of the songwriters and producers Catley has chosen, including Ten alumni Gary Hughes and Paul Hodson. Spirit of Man is the first Catley solo album without anyone from Ten on board.
Spirit of Man finds Catley working closely with members of the UK band Lost Weekend, though little of that band's modern AOR sound comes across on this album. Between the songwriting and production, Spirit of Man is a much heavier and (for a melodic rock effort) grittier album than you expect from Catley and at times it just doesn't seem appropriate. Where Hughes and Hodson wrote material that fit Catley's voice like a glove, Thompson, Uttley, et al don't quite get what Catley is all about. Still, the album does have a few highlights. Songs like "Blinded By a Lie," "Last Snows of Winter," "Lost to the Night," and "End of the Story" are pretty terrific, and most of Spirit of Man is quite solid. Of course, after the previous four fantastic solo albums from Catley, "solid" doesn't quite satisfy. It would be interesting to hear the album reworked by someone like Gary Hughes or Dennis Ward.
Even though it grows on you each time you hear it, I have to say that Spirit of Man is Bob Catley's least impressive solo release. Of course "least impressive" for Bob Catley is still worlds better than most other artists' best efforts. If you're a Magnum fan, or just enjoy melodic rock, you definitely need to check out Catley's solo albums, but I'd start with either
The Tower or
Immortal (flip a coin) and save Spirit of Man for last.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No