8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Doom of Public Under High-Pressure Business Rhetoric, June 5, 2001
This review is from: The Spirit of Public Administration (Jossey-Bass Public Administration) (Hardcover)
Management is management everywhere, in public or private organization, but the principles you must be loyal to, the context you are faced with, and certainly means to be used depend on the setting, where you are in. So far, much was written about creating high-performance government organizations by making public organizations much more like business, that is, it was thought to apply business- oriented models to government organizations. This process gained the moment with the splendid study, reinventing government, of Osborne and Gaebler,. Following this book, lots of book took the turn to advance the reinventing voice and as time passed, incredible propositions were presented in order to transform public sector into a new structure similar to that of profit sector.
This book is an investigation on the spirit of public administration. Professor Frederickson tries to persuade readers about why public administration should be thought of and approached to differently. The relationship of public administration with democratic principles is told in the book. In classic public administration theory, much emphasis was given to efficiency, economy and effectiveness and these performance guides were accepted as surrogates to evaluate how much public organizations are successful. Given this, public administrators were assigned the role to implement policy decisions, imposed by elected officials, with the maximum efficiency and economy. Author tells that these are important, but not sufficient, and another third surrogate -EQUALITY- must be added. Not only equality between people of today generation, but also between future and today generation is considered important.
Recent years witnessed an increasing accentuation in literature on governmental ethics partly due to ethical breaches increment in last years. Author explains these ethical transgressions with the increasing privatization, contracting out (outsourcing), third-party government. To prove this, author presents research findings and literature sources. According to the author, increasing privatization substitutes “idealism” with “careerism”. Resulting from this radical shift, private benefits and values dwarf ideals of public administration based mostly “patriotism of benevolence”.
Author strongly advocates that public organization is efficient and effective at least as is business organization. Bureaucrat-bashing reformist rhetoric created some prejudices about public organizations in the minds of citizens and caused people think that public organizations are unnecessary burdens on whole society although people are glad from their close relationships with public organizations in their neighborhood. This is explained in the book with the term “distance of paradox”. People do not make a distinction between public officials and elected officials and both are gathered in one category, which is “public”. Failure of political officials is connected to whole public sector, elected or appointed. It is not seen as surprise that officials who are involved in corruption are generally officials appointed by elected officials (politicians), according to the author. Second, bureaucrat-bashing propaganda of politicians and attitude of media shape the approach of citizens about public organizations and officials remote from their neighborhoods.
Author discusses the meaning of “neutrality” of public officials in the context of democratic society. According to the author, neutrality does not mean that public officials must follow government policy with eyes shut. Neutrality means non-partisan policy implementation by placing democratic values to the center of public service as essential guide and inalienable factor for efficiency or economy....
I would like to contribute to what author thinks about corruption in government. In the book, it is accepted that increasing corruption in public sector is related to erosion in values. But I think that ominous economic status of public officials should be taken into consideration to logically comment on corruption in public sector, especially in third-world countries.
That I reviewed above included only most important considerations that I needed to relate. You will find much more such as governance, high citizenship, intergenerational equality, the role of courts in democratic government and so on in the book. I believe that this book is an invaluable study and instigates readers to think on “PUBLIC” more deeply. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
One month past and still don't have it!!!!, September 18, 2009
This review is from: The Spirit of Public Administration (Jossey-Bass Public Administration) (Hardcover)
The book actually is pretty good and I know this because I had to purchase it somewhere else. I ordered the book on 8/18/09 and I still don't have it. The response I received when looking for the book was "it was being sent media mail and was within its delivery date". I order online alot and have never heard of this type of shipping, especially a book. I am assuming it is in someone's backpack and they are walking it across the country to deliver it to me personally. I ordered two other books at the same time and received them within the week. I will not order from this source again. I will be sending the book back as soon as it hits my doorstep and not via media mail.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
