18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sensitivity, Emotions and Anomalous Phenomena, September 14, 2009
This review is from: The Spiritual Anatomy of Emotion: How Feelings Link the Brain, the Body, and the Sixth Sense (Paperback)
Anatomy reads like a scientific detective story, weaving clues and insights from neurology, biology, psychology and parapsychology, in an attempt to answer questions about some of the most puzzling aspects of human behavior. These include sensitivities, allergies, autism, dissociation, somatization and `anomalous phenomena.'
Michael Jawer began his journey as a consultant on `sick building syndrome' in Washington, D.C. While interviewing environmentally sick people, he wondered whether how much of their illnesses were due to their physical environment, and how much to their `felt environment'. He began to suspect that their issues were neither entirely `in their mind' nor entirely external. Many of these people were `sensitive', and could apparently see and feel (and react to) stimuli imperceptible to `normal' folks. Among the stimuli that these sensitives sometimes experienced were apparitions and `anomalous phenomena' (e.g. ghosts, poltergeists, `presences'). And so began his long investigation into the neurobiology of sensitivity.
Jawer theorizes that different forms of subjective experience share a common neurobiological basis. In a fascinating chapter titled "Sensitivity, Personality Traits and Anomalous Perception," he points out that anomalous talents may be associated with specific personality traits. In this regard he cites the pioneering work of such researchers as Jean Ayres with sensory defensiveness, Elaine Aron's concept of `highly sensitive people,' Michael Thalheim's concept of `transliminality,' and Ernest Hartmann's ideas re: `thick and thin boundaries.'
Jawer presents a long and impassioned argument for the central role of sentience, feeling and emotion in human experience. Building on the work of Damasio, J. Allan Hobson and Joseph LeDoux, he marshals evidence for the contention that feelings are intimately connected with the body --- and constitute the basis for cognitive thought processes. "From the physical, feeling foundation of the mind stems not only the core human experiences of laughing and crying, but all of our capacities on up to thought, insight, and advanced reasoning." He further argues that the ego itself (which he terms the `self') develops out of the sensory foundations of feeling. To paraphrase Descartes: "Sentio, ergo sum."
Extending this line of reasoning, he points to emotional arousal underlying many hitherto unexplained phenomena. Jawer suggests that the dissociation of repressed energies, combined with mental preoccupations, may set the stage for apparitions, ghosts, `presences', phantom limbs, etc. There follows a long discussion of the connections between anomalous experience and emotional energy, dissociation, sensitivity, electromagnetic phenomena, and atmospheric influences.
Anatomy is thoroughly researched, and meticulously documented and footnoted. My other concern is that the author dances fluidly from citing solid neurological research, to psychological case studies, to anecdotes, without distinguishing the relative validity of different kinds of evidence. While observations can be insightful, not all evidence is created equal.
Anomalous phenomena need to be acknowledged, and included in any truly comprehensive theory of both human behavior and consciousness. Jawer points to feelings, emotions and sentience as a Rosetta stone to understand various illnesses, psychological sensitivities and the paranormal. While I can not agree with all his conjectures and conclusions ---- much of the evidence is not in, yet ----- I admire his courage in broaching and exploring a very controversial subject.
Obviously, much more research, study, and discussion are needed. This powerful and provocative book opens the doors to that discussion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Understanding Emotions and The Sixth Sense, October 8, 2009
This review is from: The Spiritual Anatomy of Emotion: How Feelings Link the Brain, the Body, and the Sixth Sense (Paperback)
Stomach -- the organ where food is digested. Heart -- the hollow, muscular organ that circulates the blood. Intestine -- the lower part of the alimentary canal. Brain - nervous tissue contained in the skull of vertebrates that controls the nervous system. We know a lot about the organs which make us digest food, breathe, and think. But what do we know about the origin and creation of our feelings and emotions? What do we know about the birth of emotional demons, like obsessive-compulsive disorder, schizophrenia, and depression? If we understood what causes feelings and mental illness, we could probably ensure the happiness and mental stability of everyone. Perhaps there would be fewer suicides, addictions, and psychiatric institutions.
Modern scientists believe all our feelings and perceptions begin in the brain. In this book, the authors present a compelling case that it is the opposite ... that it is our feelings which determine what we think and how we live, and that they "are the product of interaction between raw sensation on the one hand and mental activity on the other."
Recently, prior to helping my company defend an unemployment claim, a business acquaintance shared her "crazy" morning with me. She was in the basement when suddenly all the buttons on her washer and dryer began turning on and off. Not knowing what to do, she yelled "Cut it out." Suddenly everything stopped. Then she smelled her recently deceased mother's perfume (which she didn't particularly like while her mother was living). Is this down-to-earth arbitrator crazy? Nope ... she is one of the "sensitive" people discussed at length in this book ... people who have perceptions and visions which cannot be explained.
Know anybody with fibromyalgia? Chronic fatigue? Migraines? Ever experience premonitions or see apparitions? Do you or one of your friends have chronic skin problems? Mr. Jawer and Dr. Micozzi share their theory of the connection between feelings, the brain, the body, and the sixth sense, a connection which can cause each of these afflictions and mysterious visions.
Beyond these topics, the book also discusses other unexplainable phenomena, such as the apparent past-life memories of gifted children, near-death experiences, out-of-body experiences, and even the extreme abilities of some animals. Take Oscar, the cat who lives in the advanced dementia unit of a nursing home in Rhode Island. Oscar, not a particularly cuddly cat, correctly curled up beside 25 people in their final hours, lying next to them for hours at a time before they finally died. Lest you think this is a fabricated story made up by some nut, his case has been written about in the prestigious "New England Journal of Medicine".
Recommended by Dr. Andrew Weil, this book should be on every scholar's library shelf. If you're interested in holistic medicine and the mind-body connection, this is a book you simply must read, fascinating page to fascinating page, story to story, and cover to cover. Events and experiences you have heard about or experienced may actually begin to make sense.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent job of gathering an enormous collection of research evidence confirming links between the brain, the body and emoti, February 6, 2010
This review is from: The Spiritual Anatomy of Emotion: How Feelings Link the Brain, the Body, and the Sixth Sense (Paperback)
Michael Jawer has done an excellent job of gathering an enormous collection of research evidence confirming links between the brain, the body and emotions. Students and academics who are starting out to explore these links may find many gems of interest in this book. For instance, Jawer's list of 36 emotions exceeds most of the lists of emotions I have seen. To some extent this is due to his looser definition of emotions than is used by many researchers in this field. Jawer includes cognitive constructs to which many apply the term 'feelings,' even though they are more in the realm of thoughts (e.g. desperation, longing and resignation). Nevertheless, this is a useful addition to our awareness. His discussions on how stress can be traumatizing to mind and body also have much to offer the reader.
I was pleased to pick up a few gems of awareness myself, such as:
...the term "biophilia," coined by Harvard University biologist Edward O. Wilson... alludes...to "the connections that human beings subconsciously seek with the rest of life. Examples of biophilia include:
...The appeal of house pets and companion animals
...Our interest in gardening and keeping plants in our homes and offices
...The value of taking a stroll in the woods or getting more vigorous exercise outside...
Accumulating evidence suggests that, when we indulge our biophilia, we derive tangible benefit. (p. 445-6)
And I love the term I'd never encountered before, 'empathosphere,' coined by Michael Fox "to describe 'a universal realm of feeling that can transcend both space and time.' " (p. 414)
However, while Jawer has researched emotions through this literature, his understandings appear to be based on intellectual sortings of the dry masses of research evidence, missing the leavening that comes from life experience acquired from dealing with live challenges in a clinical practice - which provides a more solid basis for evaluating and interpreting the evidence.
For instance, Jawer writes,
...I do not consider depression - a subject much talked about these days - to be an emotion. Depression is a condition, the result of emotions unexpressed. In that sense, it is an anti-emotion, an example of what can befall someone when powerful feelings are disowned, bottled up, or dissociated. In many cases - perhaps all - there is also a genetic component, a latent disposition. But none of that alters my assessment that depression does not - indeed cannot - qualify as an emotion. (p. 24)
While these observations may be true for some people who experience depression, my impression from clinical experience and extensive readings on depression is that these sorts of cases which are the focus of Jawer are a small minority by far. Depression, in my personal and professional experience, is a distinct emotion that earns it a firm place on my list of emotions. Anyone who has gone through grief or other losses or suffers from bipolar depression could likewise testify to the reality of depression as an emotion in and of itself.
I also differ with Jawer/s discussions of intuition, a major focus of his book. For example, Jawer stops at the point of feelings in his discussion of an empathosphere that represents a resonation between living beings. My experiences and understandings of empathosphere include a collective consciousness that is facilitated by telepathy, clairsentience, and knowledge that transcends space and time.
Jawer has invested much of this book in support of his theory of 'thick boundary' vs 'thin-boundary' people. Thick boundary types of people are more likely to be insensitive to subtle perceptions and thin boundary people more sensitive to them. This might prove to be a helpful distinction in some situations. Interestingly, research in parapsychology has acknowledged the differences between believers and non-believers in psychic and transpersonal phenomena with the differences in their response to the question, "Do you believe in psychic phenomena or not?" Substantial research has strongly suggested that non-believers (affectionately labeled 'goats') possess these sensitivities as much as believers (labeled 'sheep') do, but the goats appear to use them in alignment with their belief systems. On tests of psychic abilities, the skeptics perform so consistently below chance levels that their results are highly significant. Meta-analyses of studies in which the sheep/goat effect were examined (Lawrence, 1993) demonstrated significance with odds against chance greater than 1 trillion to 1 (p < 10 x 10-8).
Jawer cites some of the research evidence from parapsychology journals and books, and reviews research on phenomena such as the out of body experience (OBE) and near death experience (NDE), but limits his theorizing to physiological, neurological and psychological explanations for these, and does his best to explain away any theories involving transcendent realities - which theories Jawer does not consider directly in any detail. Here, too, there is well-substantiated research confirming the existence of telepathy, clairsentience, and knowledge that transcends space and time (Benor, internet reference). Jawer proposes a variety of theories based on emotions and brain dysfunctions, suggesting such phenomena need not be explained as real extensions of our consciousness beyond our physical and emotional selves.
For instance, when it comes to apparitions (ghosts), he suggests that the electrical "vortex of energy in the body, when combined with issues of preoccupations held in the brain, can generate the phenomena we know of as ghosts, poltergeists, and similar haunts" (p. 131); or that infrasound may generate fears that are translated into imaginary sightings of apparitions (p. 404-5).
Jawer does not cite evidence contradicting his theories about these transpersonal realms of experience, such as that of Luis Vargas and colleagues, published in the American Journal of Psychiatry in 1989, showing that two out of three people who lose someone close to them experience bereavement apparitions. They either see, hear or 'sense the presence' of these people who are no longer in the physical world - in very real and palpable ways. The communications in both directions appear to be deeply meaningful and healing in many cases. Nor does Jawer mention research such as that of Gary Schwartz and colleagues (2002) confirming the validity of psychic and channeled information. Jawer dismisses reincarnation as a theory, suggesting that emotional energy created by psychological trauma might persist in the world (types of energy and how they might persist are not explained), subsequently influencing a fetus during its development in utero. My own review of the apparition, mediumistic (channeled) and reincarnation research includes a spectrum of evidence suggesting survival of the spirit as a real phenomenon and not just the product of physiological processes in the brain or of emotional projections and hallucinations (Benor, 2006).
For Jawer,
Such superstitions...are not far from the truth - but the truth lies in the biochemistry of the brain and the body and in the emotional energy retained in our being. I will state my concept again: the frozen energy of the stress reaction, combined with issues or preoccupations held in the brain, can generate the phenomena we know as ghosts, poltergeists, and similar haunts. (p. 155)
Jawer is impressed with a minor reference from spiritual healing research that lends support to his theory, but overlooks the much more substantial body of spiritual healing research (Benor 2001; 2007) that cannot be explained by his theories that are limited to body, emotions and brain. Jawer makes an observation on the work of Bernard Grad, one of the pioneers of healing research, performed studies showing that healers could hasten wound healing in mice and could enhance the growth of plants. However, Grad's evidence and the hundreds of other studies on spiritual healing - including healing from a distance - are all ignored by Jawer in his discussions. For Jawer, the evidence worth citing is:
...this intriguing observation by researcher Bernard Grad, who has studied people who seem to possess healing ability: "I have conducted experiments in which I obtained extraordinary results with people who made no claim to be healers but who were in states of emotional arousal." [Emphasis mine]. (p. 155-156)
So I would say in summary that the strongest audience for this book will be those who prefer to limit their consciousness of their existence to conventional, Newtonian medical and psychological understandings of the world.
On a personal note, I have to add that this was a difficult review for me to write. My views differ substantially from those of Jawer (and I presume those of Micozzi as well, though his voice is nowhere explicitly evident in the book). I experience the world very clearly as inseparably imbued with the presence of something transcendent that is beyond words. I can only begin to touch on the fringes of its essence when I start to put it into words, and hopelessly distort it when doing so. I feel I am a part of that vast essence, which includes everything beyond my physical self. I am a part of IT and IT is a part of me. This is not the place to expand upon my views much further, but I feel I must share at least a hint, a pointer for anyone with open mind and heart and inner gnowing - to at least explore this consciousness of what Larry Dossey calls 'non-local reality.' Jawer fails to go there.
I strongly believe that not going there is a major part of the reason the world is in the mess it is in, and headed for suicidal self-destruction. By separating ourselves from our...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
