10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Valuable book, November 24, 2005
This review is from: Spreadsheet Check and Control (Paperback)
Spreadsheet Check and Control addresses a woefully underrepresented aspect of information security, namely integrity. Whether in the hands of ordinary untrained computer users or professional software developers, spreadsheets are deceptively easy to program and all too easy to program incorrectly. The author provides a compelling and clearly-written set of tips and techniques for finding and resolving programming errors that, unchecked, could cause serious consequences. The `47 key practices' noted in the subtitle are collected under headings such as fundamentals (3 key practices), error identification (4 practices) and error correction (11 practices), all within chapter 3 on calculation. Previous chapters cover specification and inputs, the remainder cover outputs and review.
The reader is given just enough explanatory information to understand the issue at hand, followed by advice on how to avoid or fix the problem. There are numerous examples throughout the text, illustrated with Microsoft Excel screenshots (the reader can download the same example spreadsheets from the author's website to try out the techniques described). There are review questions at the end of each of the key practices with answers provided at the end of the book, and a good selection of annotated hyperlinks to further information sources.
Many of the practices are accompanied by relevant case studies - real world security incidents drawn from sources such as the RISKS list managed by Peter Neumann (http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks) and a number of public audit reports which identified spreadsheet errors. It focuses the mind to realize that a simple spreadsheet mistake can lead to errors amounting to millions of dollars.
This is definitely a practitioner's book, not a theoretical or academic tome. With minimal preamble, each section gets quickly down to the nitty-gritty tools and techniques of finding and eliminating errors. The writing style is clear and easy to read.
Save red faces all round by buying, absorbing and passing-on this book, especially if you personally develop spreadsheets or if your organization is subject to Sarbanes Oxley and related regulations. Avoiding even a trivial spreadsheet mistake may well pay for the book. Avoiding a large one may save your career.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Better spreadsheets through simple checks!, October 31, 2005
This review is from: Spreadsheet Check and Control (Paperback)
Although this book was written with the syllabus of The European Computer Driving Licence (ECDL) in mind, its quality and depth far surpass any expectations that may be implied by that fact. Patrick O'Beirne's wide experience of spreadsheet pitfalls and risk is apparent at every turn, resulting in a serious discussion of how best to avoid business disasters based on inaccurate and erroneous Excel models.
Microsoft Excel - and other spreadsheet programmes - allows the creation of models of infinite complexity. The main advantage of Excel - an easy-to-use, almost intuitive, "programming" interface - is potentially its main disadvantage. Spreadsheets get started quickly and may or may not be properly maintained. Complex calculations can be resolved in a cell-by-cell iterative manner, making error location difficult. Solutions tend to be extended over time - often by different people - which compounds the problem. A myriad of pre-packaged functions is available, but the choice of the appropriate - or inappropriate - function is entirely at the developer's discretion.
Spreadsheet Check and Control addresses all of these issues by providing succinct, down-to-earth tips on the basics of spreadsheet working:
* Specification - define what you're trying to do, record sources of information
* Security - avoid breaking a working version, making sure everyone is using the correct version, the use of passwords and their limitation
* Style - managing constants, units of measurement etc for consistency, handling unwieldy formulae
The discussion on Calculation addresses the fundamentals, such as the precedence of mathematical operators, circular references, and the particular quirks of arrays in Excel. Valuable hints on finding and identifying errors are provided followed by detailed descriptions of various error types and explicit tips for their correction. Obviously, if the developer understands the generic cause of an error type, then finding the offending formula or data for a specific instance is a much more efficient process. Given that the nature of the Excel beast results in error displays that are often "separated in time and space" from the original cause, the guidance provided here will significantly reduce error tracking effort.
The section on Output includes the mandatory hints on charting, but the pitfalls associated with cell formats provide answers to some fascinating questions: When is a number not a number? Are invisible cells seen by some? When is 100% not 100%? When did John Smith change his name? When is a database not a database?
Although it was common enough in the early days of programming, no one today would claim that a software programme was completed without some degree of formal testing. Yet spreadsheets are constantly being modified and altered - not just before that important meeting, but actually in the meeting! - without much awareness of the need to test the quality of the changed model. Patrick's work as Chairman of the European Spreadsheet Risk Interest Group (EuSpRIG) provides him with numerous examples and anecdotes of just how horribly wrong things can go as a result. The Review section of the book addresses the key areas of data integrity and functional correctness and is quite simply a "must read".
The Appendices provide useful information, but my favourite is the list of websites and software tools, which provide all the links the user needs to pursue the topic of Spreadsheet Check and Control further.
If you need useful, practical advice on building better spreadsheets, then this book is for you.
If you need to have confidence in the models that your colleagues and employees build, then this is the ideal present for them.
My only gripe has nothing to do with the book, but with the fact the Microsoft do a relatively good job of translating function names and arguments. As a result, it does require some additional brainpower to get the best of Patrick's tips if you're using a foreign language version of Excel.
Colm Toolan, Business Architect..
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beginning to End - Better Spreadsheets, November 21, 2005
This review is from: Spreadsheet Check and Control (Paperback)
Whether your a beginner or a seasoned pro, I would recommend this book. It is not collecting dust on my bookshelf. This is one of the first books I have read that took me from pre-design to maintaining the finished product. The book gave me proven design principles that will prevent many of the common pitfalls of my spreadsheet models.
One of the first things I noticed was how the book took me from the preparation before design - to getting the data in - to error checking, with an in-depth look at calculations and functions - to the finished presentation of the data. The book was an easy read, not filled with lengthy technical jargon.
Spreadsheet Check and Control will be a great addition to your collection, as it is to mine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
