| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Blunder Road,
By
This review is from: Springsteen: Point Blank (Paperback)
It's always good to read a Springsteen bio that counterbalances the worshipful works by Dave Marsh, whose objectivity is tainted by his family's long personal relationship with Bruce. On the up side, this is a warts and all portrait that offers information I haven't read elsewhere. It paints a fuller, more life-like picture than previous books. On the down side, the author is guilty of gross overwriting and sweeping generalizations. Where one word would do, he uses four or five. I suspect many readers will also have trouble decoding the "Britishisms" that litter every page. Another negative is the failure to grasp the culture of Asbury Park and Freehold in the 1950s and 1960s. I grew up in this area, a few years behind Bruce, knew this culture firsthand, and saw all his early bands (except the Castilles). The author alternates between being clueless and plain wrong. There were enough factual errors (e.g., Ocean County College is not on Hwy 9, the Stone Pony was not in existence during Bruce's scuffling club days) to make me question the accuracy of the balance of the book. In short, while this is an interesting addition to my rock-n-roll library, I'm still waiting for the definitive Springsteen biography.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Point Blank,
This review is from: Springsteen: Point Blank (Paperback)
This is a well-written, if over-analyzed, portrait of Springsteen. Sandford, who's clearly a fan, writes about Springsteen's childhood and his rise as a rock star that turns into rock icon -- but he tries to do so with the objective of portraying Springsteen in more human terms instead of just feeding the myth-making machine as so many other authors have done. This means that at times Springsteen does not come off as squeaky-clean or saintly as some of the more hard-core fanatics want so desperately to believe. Sandford balances the musical (reviewing and analyzing Springsteen's albums and songs, Springsteen's coping with the problems and pressures and eventually coming to terms with being a star, etc.) with the personal (his relationships with women, his marriage with Phillips, his sometimes contradictory nature, his selfless giving to various charities and so on). Sandford also shows how Springsteen evolved from somebody who never read a book and didn't know anything about politics to somebody who now reads the classics and is much more politically aware. Sandford is also not afraid to criticize, or at least point out certain contradictions concerning Springsteen's behavior -- one example being that early in his career, Sprinsteen vowed to never play stadiums and had imposed a ban on T-shirt or merchandising in his name. By the time of the Born in the U.S.A. tour, however, he was playing huge stadiums and selling plenty of merchandise, courtesy of Jon Landau. However, this book is no sordid tell-all, nor is it a hatchet job to try to bring Springsteen down -- Sandford usually goes on to defend Springsteen, or at least to explain the reasons for why Springsteen did what he did.One thing should be pointed out: Sandford is British, not American, and British sentence structure and grammar is a little different in style than American writing. He also has a dry sense of humor that is sprinkled throughout the book and he writes about Springsteen from an English perspective, not an American one. This book does have it's flaws though, with the major flaw being that he uses too many anonymous sources for his quotes, causing a dip in the credibility department. He also tends to be a bit long-winded, which causes him to repeat himself quite a bit. In the end, though this book shows Springsteen as more than a one-dimensional "Rambo with a guitar". Sandford succeeds in portraying Springsteen as a human being, with human flaws, and not as some guitar-toting cartoon character. If you're looking for a more objective look at Springsteen, then this is the book.
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Pass This One By,
By A Customer
This review is from: Springsteen: Point Blank (Paperback)
Having read just about every Springsteen book I've come across in the last 10 years or so, I've got to say that Sanford's Point Blank is hands down the least redeeming of the bunch. Rather than ramble on endlessly (as Sanford tends to do) let me just sum it up this way: first, this book offers no information that even the most fair-weather Springsteen fan wouldn't already know. Second, Sanford's prose is, at best, ill-developed, sloppy and over-written, as if he's trying to squeeze every fancy adjective he's ever heard into the very same sentence. At worst, it bounces around and runs on and on to the point of being unreadable. (And given that Bruce has made a career out of writing for "every man", as it were, with both economy and accessibility, Sanford's style seems in direct contradiction to the man he's writing about and the fans who will likely buy this book.) In short, even if Bruce were a raving ego-maniac (which I sincerely doubt he is) HE would find it nearly impossible to make his way through this book. On that note, the Dave Marsh volumes "Glory Days" and "Thunder Road" manage to reveal more of Springsteen's myth, legend, and reality in the first couple pages than Sanford does in an entire book. Spend your money on those, if you want, but take a pass on Point Blank.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|