Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Full Paper Jacket, November 6, 2000
This review is from: Stanley Kubrick, Director: A Visual Analysis (Paperback)
This may be, as the notes above claim, the "most comprehensive" book yet written on Kubrick. And it's clear the author's personal relationship with him enhances understanding of his films. But it's also obvious that the book was rushed onto the shelves to capitalize on the publicity surrounding Kubrick's last film and the director's death -- unless, of course, the typos and printer errors are an artistic statement about mankind's pointless quest for perfection... The strongest part of the book is in finding subtle similarities among the films, both in style and content, and in tracing the evolution of the director's ability to put his ideas onscreen. But the writing is occasionally overblown, presenting obvious points as if they were major revelations. The section on 'Kubrick's Use of Color' is almost laughable, looking like a four-color decoy for the rest of the book's cheaply done b/w. its analysis pretty much boils down to 'He used a lot of red.' An editorial description above refers to 'frame-by-frame' analysis, but that's pretty misleading. There is some detailed technical insight, but not for every film. And in sections that discuss particular sequences, the accompanying photos are often on different pages. The section on EWS is pretty splapdash. But there is also some really interesting stuff here. It's just too bad they didn't spend a little more time sealing the cracks.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Exceptional Visual Analysis, November 6, 1999
A very good book, really. Although I was rather unimpressed with its treatment of Eyes Wide Shut. I think the book owes a lot more to that film than what it had say. The book has a very interesting chapter entitled " Kubrick's Use of Color" which I found very intriguing. But still, again, the author leaves it a good deal short. Especially when an experienced viewer can think of so much more to say for it..... But nonetheless, the book offers invaluable analysis of Paths of Glory, 2001, A Clockwork Orange, to some degree the Shining, and Certainly Full Metal Jacket. Probably the best analysis of Full Metal Jacket that you'll read anywhere.... Overall, what impressed me the most was its utilisation of authentic stills to provide a clear, visual study of Kubrick's films. Something that should be done more often when studying Kubrick's work. So for that, I say it is rather impressive book. A must-read for any serious or aspiring Kubrick fan. At the very least, it's a complete, thouroughly-researched and commendable analysis....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not definitive but still intriguing, August 30, 2001
This is an interesting book, with a huge number of photographs detailing most of Kubrick's films. (The only ones not examined in depth are 'Fear and Desire,' 'Killer's Kiss,' 'The Killing,' 'Spartacus,' and 'Lolita.') The book is organized chronologically, with a small section in the middle of the book about Kubrick's use of color and an epilogue detailing Walker's personal encounters with Kubrick at the end. It is fun to read about Walker's stories about Kubrick, which shed some all-too-needed light on the personal life and motivations of the reclusive filmmaker. On the whole, Walker's analyses of Kubrick's films are good, not great: I think he is really off-base in praising Tom Cruise's acting in 'Eyes Wide Shut' and in denigrating Kubrick's use of the occult in 'The Shining.' However, his analyses of 'Barry Lyndon' and 'Full Metal Jacket' were astute, and he successfully links certain themes and motifs throughout all of Kubrick's films. Finally, although normally I don't like a huge amount of pictures in a book because of how they always jack up the price, here the pictures are well-chosen and either help jog your memory about the films or help you understand them if you haven't seen them. I will say that some of the pictures were much larger than they needed to be - I didn't need a full two-page spread of the atomic bomb exploding in 'Dr. Strangelove' - but that's a minor criticism. All in all, a generally fun book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|