From School Library Journal
Grade 7-10 Ms. Hart, a tenth-grade English teacher and recent transplant from New York City to Los Angeles, assigns her class of nine students a writing assignment, to be completed in two weeks: If you could get a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame for anything that you're good at, for anything good that you've done or plan to do, what would it be for? Then in brief, alternating chapters, each character's story unfolds. Marlon is a basketball star who has something to prove to his older brother. Shante is falling for a white boy and facing pressure from family and friends. Gus is small in stature and shy until he gets to know MJ, whose extra weight has been hiding her bright mind. Dorian, the class clown, doesn't want the life his Pops modeled for him. The themes will seem familiar to most teens, but the voices are somewhat uneven with some passages naive or clichéd and others filled with invective and searing emotion. The book ends with the students' essays and leaves an impression of hopefulness that is perhaps unrealistic. Short chapters and the high school setting may make this an attractive choice for reluctant readers, but the characters and story lines are unlikely to be remembered for long.
Karen Elliott, Grafton High School, WI Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
A young, idealistic, and motivated teacher assigns her nine creative-writing students an essay about how each one is a star—although not, of course, within the entertainment industry’s defining limits. Woods then weaves together the students’ and teacher’s personal stories, concentrating on events during the two-week period between the assignment and its due date. The students are poor, urban tenth-graders who attend public school in Los Angeles; their lives represent nearly every aspect of the contemporary socioeconomic spectrum, and their stories present various coping skills and frustrations attached to each set of circumstances. Interracial dating, stepparent abuse, shyness, the threat of cancer, the reality of parental HIV, poverty—each of these and more are given due plot attention. Throughout, Woods does a better job distinguishing her many characters’ personalities than she does their voices. Much is wrapped up in little time, but as catharsis goes, this brief book offers it in many flavors. Grades 7-9. --Francisca Goldsmith