Customer Reviews

Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 143: Birthright, Part II [VHS]

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Following the superbly-scripted first part of "Birthright", the second part is a tremendous let-down. Pursuing rumors of his father's possible whereabouts, Worf discovers a Romulan prison camp for Klingon survivors of the Khitomer Massacre. Although Mogh died honorably in battle, his comrades opted to live in dishonor as POWs, and have even conceived offspring during their years of captivity. These Klingon youngsters have been raised with their Romulan guards, and know nothing of their warrior birthright. Enter Worf, whose undying hatred toward Romulans cannot tolerate this peaceful coexistence with an enemy race. As he begins to foment bigotry in the youngsters, and surreptitiously teach them their heritage, he falls in love with a hybrid girl. Now the benevelent Romulan commandant has a dilemma: the disgraced Klingon POWs will never be accepted on either homeworld, Worf can not be permitted to leave and reveal their existence, yet he cannot stay and destroy the harmony of the camp. Reluctantly, the Romulan orders Worf's execution. This episode appears hastily-written, poorly-developed. Worf's "romance" with Ba'el in particular, seems superfluous. Why would he fall in love with the irritating, simpering, whiny child in the first place; and how could such a legendary bigot so quickly overcome his revulsion of her interspecies conception? The writers missed several opportunities to develop this relationship. Perhaps if Worf had taken Ba'el on the hunt instead of the boy Tok, taught her of her Klingon birthright, then his growing feelings for her might have seemed more realistic. If Ba'el had been the first to stand in Worf's defense, instead of the last, their romance might have had more purpose in the episode. As it is, the only explanation for her inclusion was to provide a titillating scene of Worf spying on her bathing. And although Worf succeeds in "liberating" the Klingon youths, including Ba'el, from their captivity, his "love" for the hybrid maiden ends with this episode. As a Klingon fan, I was eagerly awaiting this sequel to the excellent first half of "Birthright", but the episode failed to deliver. Worf, raised by Humans, a discommended exile of the Klingon Empire, the sole member of his species in Starfleet, continues to vacilate in character development. How is it that he rejects his heritage, and yet is its staunch advocate? And how can he be qualified to teach it to others?