4.0 out of 5 stars
Nothing seems right and even Data seems wrong, April 2, 2009
This review is from: Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 88: Clues [VHS] (VHS Tape)
While on a routine mission, the Enterprise apparently passes through a wormhole and is immediately transported an enormous distance. All of the crew except for Data is rendered unconscious and he is able to revive the crew in approximately 30 seconds. Captain Picard then decides to proceed on mission, but suddenly anomalies appear. The first is that one of Dr. Crusher's botany experiments has achieved 24 hours of growth. Further investigation indicates that approximately 24 hours have passed and that the crew was conscious for at least part of that time.
When Picard and others confront Data, he is evasive and unclear in his responses and there are strong indications that he has falsified the data entries in the Enterprise computer. This continues for some time until Captain Picard orders the Enterprise back to the location of the supposed wormhole.
They arrive, only to discover that there is no wormhole but a planet inhabited by a powerful species that is extremely xenophobic. Their policy when a ship encounters their planet is to simulate a wormhole, render the crew unconscious and then move the ship a significant distance from their planet. Since their methods are ineffective against Data, Picard had ordered the crew to alter the Enterprise so that there was the simulation of the 30 seconds of unconsciousness and all the humans would have their memory of the events erased. Captain Picard then ordered Data to never reveal to anyone the existence of the planet. The xenophobes prepare to destroy the Enterprise, but Captain Picard convinces them to give the Enterprise another chance to make it work, and this time the crew succeeds.
Considered as a possible event, human explorers encountering a xenophobic species that wants no contact, is very possible. In many ways some human societies, for example Japan before the voyage of Commodore Perry, took that route. The only thing that forced open Japan to the outside world was the clear military might of the Western navies. If Japan had had the military superiority, there would have been no opening of the country. Therefore, this episode satisfies one of the most important criteria of believable science fiction, a plausible and even likely premise. The acting is well done and the dialog is presented as a puzzle to be solved. Brent Spiner plays his role as the conflicted but properly behaving Data very well. The opening scene where Guinan is in a detective holdrama with Picard is amusing and sets the stage for what is a mystery with baffling clues. Her puzzled flashing of the garters is very funny.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Warning: Wormholes ahead....., September 9, 2006
This review is from: Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 88: Clues [VHS] (VHS Tape)
Plot: While Picard was originally planning to have a "Dixon Hill" mystery with Guinin (Gloria from Cleveland), he is contacted by Data, who says that they may have discovered something really unusual. Suddenly, they jump through a wormhole, which stuns everyone except Data. When everyone wakes up, he says that they were out for 30 seconds. However, things are not what they appear to be. Little clues seem to indicate that Data is hiding the truth. As investigation goes deeper and deeper, everyone begins to their lose trust in Data. Picard finally decides to head back the "scene of the crime", where the wormhole was first encountered...
Overall, a pretty intriguing episode, with plenty of drama. While I didn't really like the whole solution to "Whodunit", I have to say that it was a pretty good episode on the whole, earning 4 out of 5 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
