6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wesley gets busted.... Again, March 9, 2001
This review is from: Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 119: The First Duty [VHS] (VHS Tape)
Wesley Crusher has gotten busted again and this time, it might cost him his Starfleet Career.
He and the people is his squadron have had a shuttle accident and a cadet died as a result. The others barely managed to survive. The squad leader, played by Robert Duncan MacNeil, (Tom Paris) tries to cover up the cause of the accident.
The accident was actually caused by them performing a banned manuver called a diamond-slot formation. This manuver was considered too dangerous to be performed by inexperienced pilots.
The investigation by the Enterprise crew gets closer and closer to the truth and Wesley is faced with making one of the most difficult decisions.
This episode has a special appearance by Ray Walston (My Favorite Martian) as Boothby, the groundskeeper at Starfleet Academy.
This is one of the best 50 episodes for the Next Generation series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Trouble at Starfleet Academy..., March 31, 2002
This review is from: Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 119: The First Duty [VHS] (VHS Tape)
The First Duty
The Wesley Crusher Academy Episode
Wes got himself in trouble with his classmates in this one. A fellow classmate dies in a tragic accident. a A flying maneuver with some small ships at what was sopposed to be a test run for an impressive display at the graduating class. Well, to make a long story short; Wes is asked to cover up the fact that their squad leader made a huge miscalculation. Their ships few too close together causing the tragic death of the unseen classmate. It's a good little episode where Wes learns not to go along with questionable charismatic leaders. Incidentally, the actor who protrayed this leader went on to play Tom Paris in Voyager; Robert Duncan McNeil.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Poor Wesley, poor Beverly, poor Josh..., September 19, 2008
This review is from: Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 119: The First Duty [VHS] (VHS Tape)
Very moving episode about the truth and how hard it is when so-called "friends" are pressuring you to lie for them.
As his mother is struggling through her rough time, including her recent problem with the unethical Toby Russell (see the episode
Star Trek - The Next Generation, Episode 116: Ethics ), Wesley Crusher is struggling with an ethical and moral issue of his own after an "accident" leaves one dead and the others wanting to lie and hush up the real cause of the so-called accident that killed Josh, their teammate.
It was lovely and touching to see Beverly's undying support for her son, even when Wes admits to his part in the banned scheme. It was also just good to see dear Wesley again; I could see that Bev really missed him.
Wesley, like Beverly was with Toby Russell, is also in a vise...either continue lying to the Starfleet inquiry board and contradict what Jean Luc Picard knows and pretend Josh's death was all an "accident"...or follow his conscience and tell the truth, even if it means Nick Locarno, who led the illegal maneuver and is now is using the "friendship loyalty" blackmail scheme to cover up his own lies, turns on him.
Nick so reminded me of Toby Russell, esp. when he tries to bully Wesley into going along with the lie; Toby also tried to bully Beverly into doing things her way also. Nick has the same lack of ethics and low morals that Toby Russell has.
The similarities of the situations that both Beverly and Wesley face are startlingly similar and it illustrates how much alike Beverly and Wesley are, even though Bev is much quieter than her son. I notice they even have similar mannerisms (slight lifting of brows when curious or questioning, for example).
It was a turning point in Wesley's life that forced him to mature in an unexpected way; he learned what true friendship was about and just how special the bond with his mom truly was.
And even though it broke Beverly's heart, she was still very proud of her son and it was so touching to see her unconditional love for him. Unlike many other parents, who would have berated their offspring in such a situation, Beverly (who was already going through a difficult time in her own life) wisely understood that Wes had already learned from this unfortunate experience and was already growing from it.
Although Jean Luc initially dresses down Wesley and tells him that he must tell the truth, and that Nick is not a true friend if Nick expects his "friends" to lie for him, Jean Luc knew deep down inside that Wes would do the right thing and it was neat and nice how Jean Luc comforted Bev as she cried.
The ending was good also...Jean Luc, after Wes has tearfully confessed the truth to the inquiry board (much to Nick's indignation), wishes Wesley good luck and without a trace of condemnation or criticism, bids Wesley well and adds, *Goodbye, Cadet*. It illustrated that Jean Luc would never, ever misuse his high ranking and leadership position, even if anyone under him does something "wrong" or violates regulations.
All three of them...Beverly, Wesley, and Jean Luc handled a potentially horrible situation with a beauty and dignity that took my breath away. Kudos to all three of them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
