Amazon.com
Star Trek fans were decidedly mixed in their reactions to this, the ninth big-screen feature in Paramount's lucrative
Trek franchise, but die-hard loyalists will appreciate the way this
Next Generation adventure rekindles the spirit of the original
Trek TV series while combining a tolerable dose of New-Agey philosophy with a lighthearted plot for the
TNG cast. This time out, Picard (Patrick Stewart) and his executive crew must transport to a Shangri-la-like planet to see why their android crewmate Data (Brent Spiner) has run amuck in a village full of peaceful Ba'ku artisans who--thanks to their planet's "metaphasic radiation"--haven't aged in 309 years.
It turns out there's a conspiracy afoot, masterminded by the devious, gruesomely aged Ru'afo (F. Murray Abraham, hamming it up under makeup resembling a cosmetic surgeon's worst nightmare), who's in cahoots with a renegade Starfleet admiral (Anthony Zerbe, in one of his final screen roles). They covet the fountain-of-youth power of the Ba'ku planet, but because their takeover plan violates Starfleet's Prime Directive of noninterference, it's up to Picard and crew to stop the scheme. Along the way, they all benefit from the metaphasic effect, which manifests itself as Worf's puberty (visible as a conspicuous case of Klingon acne), Picard's youthful romance with a Ba'ku woman (the lovely Donna Murphy), the touching though temporary return of Geordi's natural eyesight, and a moment when Troi asks Dr. Crusher if she's noticed that her "boobs are firming up."
Some fans scoffed at these humorous asides, but they're what make this Trek film as entertaining as it is slightly disappointing. Without the laughs (including Data's rousing excerpt from Gilbert & Sullivan's HMS Pinafore), this is a pretty routine entry in the franchise, with no real surprises, a number of plot holes, and the overall appearance of a big-budget TV episode. As costar and director, Jonathan Frakes proves a capable carrier of the Star Trek flame--and it's nice to see women in their 40s portrayed as smart and sexy--but while this is surely an adequate Trek adventure, it doesn't quite rank with the best in the series. --Jeff Shannon
From The New Yorker
Paramount's most lucrative long-running franchise (nine films in nineteen years) shows little wear and tear in this installment, perhaps the most colorful and relaxed of the series. In this story, the stalwart Captain Picard (Patrick Stewart) leads his multicultural starship crew in a rebellion to save a planet from the very Federation they serve so proudly. Director Jonathan Frakes (he plays Commander Riker) films much of the movie in the beautiful High Sierras, and the dramatic landscape grounds the action-it's a welcome relief from photon torpedoes detonating in space. "Insurrection" is a decidedly less bombastic entry in the series, and it works as a prelude to the likely fireworks of the next installment-the first "Star Trek" feature of the new millennium. -Bruce Diones
Copyright © 2006 The New Yorker