Customer Reviews

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace: Read Along (Audiobook)

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

First of all, this CD is clearly for kids. Especially the 2 - 7 year olds will enjoy the read along - style of the hughly coloured book accompanying the cd. Those who expect a high tech soundeffect - adventure will be greatly dissapointed - not only that the use of soundeffects and original dialog is very limited, unfortunately the old music from the elder movies was used...although the new score was already availabe. Nevertheless the quite complex story is vivdly told and any scary, for children unsuitable elements like violence and too dark descriptions of evil characters are left out. A little more atmosphere would have done alot to improve the overall experience! Good for kids, teenies and eager star wars fans - hands off! Get the audio book from EPISODE I - UNABRIDGED instead!

As a big fan of Star Wars I would have expected that this CD contained an audio version of the movie, but instead this is a poor pretext for another licensed product.

Having grown up listening to a 60 minute audio tape of Star Wars over and over, I expected the CD of Episode 1 purchased for my son's 6th birthday to be of similar quality. I was sorely disappointed with length, quality and lack of significant movie dialog. The story is severly edited, probably less than one-half hour, and almost all narration with little in the way of sounds and dialog from the movie. Hopefully, someone will come out with a better audio version because this one leaves a lot to be desired.

This is the worst! 99% narration and all of that bad. I used to listen to my Star Wars story LP over and over (which is why, unfortunately, I can still tell you that Luke and the crew were trapped in trash compactor 3263827) and it was great. A narrator was used sparringly to make transitions and all the dialog and music was straight from the movie, this is completely opposite. Now I know the Lucas marketing strategy is to drip out products like frozen molassas over the next hundred and fifty years, but this, like JAR JAR, was just bad thinking. If you're looking for a read along book, okay here's a really bad one, go nuts. But if you want the MOVIE on a CD that your children can listen to without nodding off thanks to a voice-over guy getting paid scale (at least that's what he's worth -- the editors and writers of the book too) pass on this.

You get a nice read along book with cool pictures, but this is definately aimed at kids ("when you hear the WHOOSH sound, turn the page...") It does feature sound bites from the movie ("Kill them immediately," Sidious said...) but the music is recycled from 1983's RETURN OF THE JEDI. It uses some STAR WARS sound effects (mostly light sabres) but not having seen the movie, I am uncertain if the rest of the effects are actually from PHANTOM MENACE. In general, as an adult, I am a bit disappointed with this CD. But then, of course, I'm not 10 years old.....

The CD consists of one track that lasts twenty minutes long - it could have been broken down into multiple tracks, but since it is so short, why bother?

The music is recycled from the previous Star Wars triology and contains none of John Williams newer music. The same appears to be true of the sound effects.

The dialogue taken from the movie is far too sparse, containing less than forty lines of short snipets that last but a few seconds (though this appears to be the only audio actually taken from the movie).

Pictures in the book are also sparse, but capture a few good shots from the light saber conflicts.

The style of the book is intended purely for children, but even my young nephew didn't care for it - and he's a huge fan.

In short, this read-along-book should only be bought by the most-desparate and least-discerning Star Wars fan. Otherwise, you will be disappointed.

p.s.- I did like the movie!

This soundtrack will not only make the hard core Star Wars fan drool, but the punk rock, anti-symphonic drool as well. John Williams gives us his best with the age old classic Star Wars tunes, plus some new ones to dazzle us with. This soundtrack is a must have, and I recommend it to everyone!

I just got a copy of the Star Wars: Episode 1 novelization (I won't say who I got it from- I don't want anyone to lose their jobs)and I was amazed. Trust me- YOU NEED THIS BOOK. Audiobook or otherwise- you need it.