Customer Reviews

StarMark Training Collar, Large, Blue

5 star:		(46)
4 star:		(28)
3 star:		(13)
2 star:		(9)
1 star:		(17)

 

 

UPDATE FEBRUARY 2011:

Just purchased another one, not because the current collar was broken or worn out, but the price dropped, and I know like all collars it will not last forever.

Also, my dog's neck has surprisingly gotten larger and I have now added 2 more links. Given the OVERPRICED nature of the extra links, I figured it's cheaper (per link) to buy a whole new collar and have enough extra links and/or replacements if one or two wear out.

ANYWAY - I have used this daily for years now, and it works great and the only rubbing/scratching on my dogs neck if from the second, nylon (standard) collar I always use (Just in case - on the off chance there is a problem with this collar and I need something to grab onto and hold. My dog is a true sweetheart who has thought he was a lap dog when I got him at 50 pounds and still thinks he is at some 50+ additional pounds more. For just the sheer weight and power, I keep a solid nylon dog collar on him ... and that ordinary one cause more irritation than this one).

FINALLY - I am updating this because I had forgotten just how great this collar is. But a neighbor got a Boxer puppy (one of the most beautiful .... and definitely the most high energy dog I've ever seen) and now that his dog is a year old and non-stop energy ... I lent him an extra one of these collars .... and he just stopped me all excited .... totally telling me "it's just like you said.... It like having power steering".

Hid Boxer has a very very long neck, and he says when the collar is properly positioned high up (where it should be) his dog Instantly Responded with understanding of the walk command (pulling straight up and start a brisk walk) and like power steering, the lightest directional command, and his dog just knew and responded.

I thourougly interrogated him on if there was any problem (pain, discomfort, dislike by the dog etc....) to make sure I had not bum-steered him .... and he was absolute and amazed how painless yet effective beyond belief this collar really is.

(it's NOT for ALL DOGS. Very short haired dogs (a Boxer, American Pit Bull Terrier etc...) it is great. Long hair could get tangled in the hinges - just guessing .... never tried) but use common sense and do be 'afraid' to at least try this collar if you are interested. At $10 ... it a steal compared to most dog collars, and if you can afford to risk the $10, give it a try.

It is truly a GREAT PRODUCT.

UPDATE MARCH 2010

==================

I still think this is one of the greatest dog collars. (The price, the ability to control a VERY STRONG 100 lb+ APBT ... and it has been personally and fully tested by myself when we were suddenly confronted with a 'KILLER LAWN MOWER' when we turned a corner on a daily walk.

I added an extra link so that it is just the right size to carefully slip on and off over his head without unbuckling the clasps.

PROBLEMS - I can see where there may be problems. If you don't line the grooves up correctly when snapping in place or you twist to much trying to twist it off the wrong way - it will either break or frustrate you to death trying to get 'a square peg into a round hole' ... so to speak. (NOTE: STUDY how the grooves line up carefully under a good light before you rush to put it on for the first time) the grooves (being plastic, will misshape or bend, and the most insignificant damage to a groove, will make THAT LINK useless)

I had one link get just slightly messed up from my own wrong twist and that link was permanently useless.

I do keep the collar looser that suggested since I have such a wonderful dog and I am not worried about his getting out of control ... Just worried he may go to sniff a tree without my paying close enough attention and end up having him ripping my last remaining shoulder blade out of it's socket ... Without ever realizing how strong he is when he went to innocently smell what he thought was 'doggie gold' of some sort .... unfortunately a few feet beyond the length of my leash.

=========================================

*** UPDATE *** 12/05/09

AFTER REGULAR USE - MY RECOMMENDATION IS EVEN HIGHER THAN MY INITIAL ECSTATIC REVIEW!

WONDERFUL! MY DOG HAS BECOME A TOTAL NON-PULLER AND MY SHOULDER IS ALREADY FEELING BETTER!

ABSOLUTELY NOT CRUEL - MY DOG HAS NEVER HAD ANY ADVERSE REACTION TO MY TAKING IT ON OR OFF, AND IS COMPLETELY COMFORTABLE WHEN I USE IT FOR ALL REGULAR DOG WALKS.

TIP: Some have commented on it being difficult to snap and unsnap. I fist thought they were crazy, because it was so simple, then all the sudden I couldn't do it at all. Then I realized when taking it off, IF! it does not quickly, smoothly and effortlessly unsnap, just STOP!, go to the other side of the metal ring/center and it will easily snap on and off.

There is obviously a 'front' and 'back' to the collar, which you can't tell which is which. It doesn't matter for use, but for taking off and on - it is the difference between easy vs IMPOSSIBLE (literally).

I can also carefully slip it on and off over my dog's head without any problem.

It is plastic, and will not last forever - but .... as long as you don't mess up the grooves for the latches trying to clasp and unclasp while getting unnecessarily frustrated, it remains fully functional, safe and will have to be replaced probably when the nylon connection eventually wears thin from normal use ... just like any non-metal dog collar wears out.

BTW - Also bought the metal kind, and much prefer this Starmark collar. It is much lighter, inconspicuous, and not even noticed by my dog when walking, whereas the metal kind gets twisted, chinked and have had some undesirable excessive pinching on my dog's neck. The metal collar also makes my dog 'appear' to have a serious aggression problem already, when in fact he is the most submissive, loving and non-aggressive dog ever. He just looks scary from his massive size and incorrect bad-rap the breed has, and the metal collar only makes people MORE frightened when we walk down the street.

**** end of update *****

WOW! THERE WAS AN INSTANTANEOUS AND DRAMATIC DIFFERENCE AS SOON AS I PUT THE COLLAR ON.

FIRST: My dog has not shown any sign of pain, discomfort, fear, dislike or any negative association when in use or when I put the collar on in the morning or when I take it off at the end of the day (or when I leave him alone). And I have really been watching to make sure he is not in any pain or discomfort when in use.

EFFECTS: It is like suddenly getting 'POWER STEERING' on a car for the fist time. My dog stays closer to my side in general and responds to the slightest leash commands long before there is even a 'pulling too hard issue'.

In addition to completely stopping all pulling, it only takes the very slightest of leash adjustment/movement for speed, direction or any other movement a dog walking properly on a leash makes. I mean you barely think and start to make what you would regularly do when walking any dog, and instantly my dog understands and responds to the proper movement before I can even make a full arm movement or gesture to guide him.

It is hard to explain, but it almost creates an unbroken link between my thoughts and the actions of my dog. He doesn't look at me or seem confused or even appear to notice or be self aware of the command given and executed automatically by my dog.

The point being, I think he is actually much happier without knowing why, simply because he is now so intuitively able to understand me when walking on-leash with the Sartmark Pinch Collar.

I am amazed and would highly recommend anyone to TRY this or the metal pinch collar. There may be problems with long haired dogs (tangling the hair with the collar) or different breeds skin sensitivity or body shape/structure which, I would even more strongly recommend you start slowly with the collar and pay really, really close attention for the first few days to make sure there is no pain, discomfort and/or potential problems foreseeable for one's own particular dog.

I like the plastic of the Starmark Collar, but if there seems to be any problem with wear-out, I would definitely consider the metal kind.

===>> CHECK OUT THE ON-LINE VIDEO DEMONSTRATIONS ON THE STARMARK DOG COLLAR WEBSITE (AND PROBABLY You-Tube) before you buy one. It could be very frustrating to attach and detach the links if you don't see the twisting method the video shows.

I have a pitbull-mix rescued from the streets of the Bronx who, I'm sure, has lived through hell. She is hyper-energetic and strong even at age 10+. I've always resisted using pronged collars but finally gave in after 8 years of exhausting walks and all kinds of training. The metal pronged collars takes the edge off and allows for a tolerable walk, but this collar is not effective because of the shorter "teeth" and her high pain threshold; however, it does work on my other larger dog who doesn't pull as aggressively, so whether this collar will work for you will depend on the age (younger the better), the nature of your dog, and--for obvious reasons--the thickness of the fur around its neck.

This collar was the best thing for our dogs as well for our arms and shoulders. The pinch collar does not cause any harm to our Husky/Chow or our Rottweiler. It provides a better experience for us during walks and when running with our beautiful dogs. These dogs are known for their powerful pulling capabilities and the collar helps them to control the urge to pull with all their might. I recommend this collar for senior citizens, kids, and handicapped dog walkers. Our dogs love their time out of the house and when they see us get the collars you can see the excitement in their eyes, they don't hide or growl at site of the collar. The steel prong collars need to be replaced by this non abusive dog collar!

This was a great purchase. Very cost effective way to control the dog that pulls too hard when you are walking. Now we can walk her without getting a sore arm in the end. She learned very quickly and walks gently and still gets to go on adventures

We recommend these collars at Dogproblems.com as they are a fair substitute for those who cannot buy a metal pinch collar. (For example: If you live in a country outside of the U.S. where customs might confiscate the metal pinch collar, for whatever reason?)

I do not feel that the correction with these collars is quite as motivational as with a true pinch collar-- however, it is a fair enough compromise.

This is an outstanding collar which was recommended to us by our dog trainer. It gives you so much control when training & walking your dog.

Our dog loves it & walks so proud, head held high, & no pulling. She is right at my side where she belongs. Its small teeth grip just like her mothers did. No pain, just all business & control. This is our third dog to have one. I wouldn't use anything else. Who wants to walk down the street with your dog walking (pulling) you? Not me, we both look & know what we're doing. It's a very comfortable, but exhillerating walk!!!

This is a very effective training collar, and it is the only one that works really well out of the four that I have tried. I personally slip the collar over my dog's head, which she tolerates with no problem. This avoids the problem of unsnapping the links that one user has reported. This may not work for some dogs. But honestly, it is not a big deal to unsnap these links. It takes the slightest amount of practice to the the hang of the motion that is required.

I have used this training collar for years. I have a keeshond (long-haired)dog. It's way easier to use and more humane than traditional metal prong collar or a choke collar. You just have to know how to use it properly and have the right size. I love this collar for training purposes.

I have a 2 1/2 year old labradoodle who still acts like a puppy on our walks. When I lost her last Starmark collar, she started pulling hard, disobeying commands, and stopping whenever she wanted to smell something. Now that she has a new collar, our walks are much more orderly, and a short tug reminds her to heel. The collar doesn't hurt at all - if you put it around your arm and tug you can feel the pull, but it doesn't cause pain. This collar is especially useful for my kids, who otherwise have a hard time walking the dog. The only downside is that it can be hard to put on and take off, especially when it's new, since the links are very tight. Once it's on, it doesn't come off though. Overall, I recommend it highly.

I mistakenly ordered a "large" for my Boston Terrier. Seller responded in timely manner and allowed me to return for smaller size. The collar is very effective in training my wild girl. When I put this collar on, she knows she is expected to behave! I don't like the electronic collars, but this one allows kind correction.