Customer Reviews

Starlight 3 (Starlight (Tor Paperback))

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The newest edition of Patrick Nielsen Hayden's original anthology series _Starlight_ is a pretty solid book, certainly not hurting the reputation of this series as one to rival _Orbit_ or _New Dimensions_ or _Universe_ in quality and consistency, but it's vaguely disappointing: I guess because while there are a whole lot of really good stories, there are no superb stories, nothing like say "Story of Your Life" from the second issue.

I'll mention some highlights. Ted Chiang is back, with "Hell is the Absence of God", a rather intriguing and deadpan look at a world much like our own in which the existence of Heaven and Hell are objectively proven: indeed, the souls in Hell can be seen, and in which angels occasionally come to Earth, typically causing a mixture of miraculous events and capricious disasters. The story focuses on an unpious man whose beloved wife is killed and ascends to Heaven in one such angelic visitation, and who tries to find a way to love God and thus reach Heaven to rejoin her, against all his instincts. My favorite piece might have been Maureen McHugh's "Interview: On Any Given Day", about a teenaged girl who becomes infected with a potentially cancerous agent after an odd affair with a rejuvenated older man -- the story not only describes a near future teenage milieu quite well, but it's particularly good at what it's really about, in kind of a sideways fashion: the affect of this rejuvenation technology on people, particularly the sad older man who has the affair with the main character. This was a very real-seeming story -- McHugh at close to her best. Susan Palwick's "Gestella" takes a very simple (even silly) gimmick: what if werewolves share the 7/1 lifespan ratio with humans that real canids are said to have, and extrapolates it to a very scary conclusion in telling of the relationship of the title werewolf with a shallow professor. And it's a great example of effective, and, it seems to me, narratively essential, use of the second person. I'm a great fan of Susanna Clarke's stories, few as they have been. "Tom Brightwind, or, How the Fairy Bridge was Built at Thoresby" is a witty piece about Tom Brightwind, a fairy, and his human friend, the Jewish doctor David Montefiore, and said bridge, and the means and results of its building. Light-hearted, clever, fun stuff. Madeleine E. Robins' "La Vie en Ronde" is one of the more original stories I've read recently -- I can't say much more about it, but I found it intriguing if a bit hard to figure out. Alex Irvine's "The Sea Wind Offers Little Relief" is also intriguing, and hints at being a really special story, but didn't quite come together for me. Still, it was different: about a future in which the Assimilation has occurred: electronic communications and direct mind-computer uplinks have become so common that any communication that can be concealed, such as reading plain text, is illegal. After nearly 150 years of imprisonment for forbidden reading, a man is released in order to read and explain a poem. The poem encapsulates another mystery. I've had similar feelings about a couple of Irvine's stories: that there are really neat ideas behind them, and that I'm just barely missing some great point -- so they seem not successful, really, but very promising. (In a different way, this story reminded me of a story from _Starlight 1_: John Ford's "Erase/Record/Play".) The last story in the book is Terry Bisson in his most openly satirical mode, and pretty effective at it: a rapist and murderer becomes converted to Christianity, and some unsavory sorts decide to stage a crucifixion by convincing him that his conversion experience means that his death penalty must mimic Christ's. Bisson aims at a lot of targets in the story, which makes it seem a bit scattershot at times, but it's still pretty solid satire.

Patrick Nielsen Hayden turns out another outstanding Starlight anthology. If only they could come out on a more regular basis. The Starlight series is the only significant original fiction anthology series on the market.

Starlight 3 follows up the first two Starlights admirably. The quality of fiction in the book is consistently high, occasionally achieving excellence.

The high point of the anthology for me was 'Senator Bilbo' by Andy Duncan. Duncan stumbled across a reference to an old Southern senator named Bilbo and turned it into a story about an old right-wing hobbit senator who wants to maintain the 'purity' of the Shire. Duncan does a great job of portraying a changing Middle Earth without comprising Tolkien's vision.

Other highlights include 'Wolves till the World Goes Down' by Greg van Eekhout, 'Hell Is the Absence of God' by Ted Chiang, 'Gestella' by Susan Palwick, and 'Power Punctuation!' by Cory Doctorow. This is not to say that the other stories in the collection are not fine stories as well. Every story in this collection is well-written and worth reading.

Many of the stories have a deeper goal beyond entertainment. Chiang's story ponders spirituality and ethics. Palwick's 'Gestella' is a sad love story between a human and a werewolf who ages at a rapid pace. Colin Greenland's 'Wings' is set in a world where angels are commonplace and humanity must reconcile itself to new truths.

Truly an excellent anthology. I look forward to a Starlight 4 and hope it's published in a timely manner!

Original anthologies of SF stories have become a rare thing these days. The Startlight series of anthologies is, therefore, more important than it would have been otherwise.

The 3rd volume in this series features an introduction, 16 stories and authors' bios. Most of the 16 stories are by famous names: Ted Chiang, Stephen Baxter, Terry Bisson, Geoffrey Landis, Jane Yolen, Cory Doctorow, D.G. Comptom, Colin Greenland.

Onward to the stories: The book starts off with Ted Chiang's "Hell is the Absence of God". Ted Chiang recently burst on the SF horizon. He has written only a handful of stories and novellas but almost every one of them has either won an award or has been nominated for one. His "Story of Your Life" is one of my favorites. The present story has an intriguing name and an intriguing premise. It depicts a world where the natural and supernatural go hand in hand. Heavenly visitations and miracles are taken for granted. The story is interesting up to the very end where it falls flat on its face leaving a bad taste in the mouth. Sorry, this is not a Chiang story that I like.

Out of the other stories, I liked (not exactly in the same order) "Sun Cloud" (Stephen Baxter), "Wolves Till the World Goes Down" (Greg van Eekhout), "La Vie en Ronde" (Madeleine E. Robins), "Power Punctuation" (Cory Doctorow), and "The Sea Wind Offers Little Relief" (Alex Irvine). Terry Bisson's story is good but it is neither SF nor fantasy. But the best among the lot is also the shortest: "The Secret Egg of the Clouds" by Geoffrey A. Landis. In less than 2000 words, Landis has delivered a tale full of the proverbial "sensawunda" as well as social significance. It is poetic and meaningful. It is beautiful. If I had the power to do so, I would have definitely nominated this gem for Hugo, Nebula and all other SF awards around.

It is a good anthology, much better than some of the "Year's Best" anthologies around. It has a good mixture of SF and fantasy. What it lacked was humor - and some new blood.

Ahmed A. Khan
http://ahmedakhan.journalspace.com

The first story (Hell...) completely soured my enjoyment of the book. It was preachy and not at all science fiction. From then on I was looking for the religious underpinnings/sermon in the rest of the stories and finding quite a bit of it. Wings might as well have been Touched by an Angel's attempt at a Roswell episode.

I guess I'm old fashioned or maybe just addicted to "hard" SF but when I see a title like "Starlight 3" I'm expecting some space stories or at least some interesting short hard science fiction - NOT!

This stuff leans much more toward fantasy than SF. I guess the lines have been blurred. Oh well, I got it at the library so I'm not out any cash. If you're looking for some fantasy style short fiction then this may be for you. If you're looking for some hard SF, stay away.

Once again editor Hayden has given SF fans a reason to cheer; another superb and solid read from a solid line up of the best SF authors around today! Gary S. Potter Author/Poet