1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very articulate account of the US army and combat in the Pacific, October 4, 2011
This review is from: Steel Helmet and Mortarboard: An Academic in Uncle Sam's Army (Hardcover)
Francis Heller was a young Austrian who was forced to flee the Nazi takeover of his country. He went to America and studied law but when the war came to the United States he stepped forward to fight for his adopted land. He did this with the 24th Infantry Division in New Guinea and the Philippines.
Apart from being a very strong student, Heller had served as an Officer cadet in the Austrian artillery and appropriately, it was this arm that he ended up in the American army. Commendably he refused placement in non-combat units (based on his astonishing IQ level), insisting that he serve in a front line capacity. Even so, his assignment to divisional artillery HQ didn't promise much in the way of a rollicking combat story. It was a major surprise then to see him go from using trigonometry at his HQ desk to a bayonet duel to the death on a narrow New Guinea track! There followed a dramatic landing under fire on Leyte and intense artillery observation duties later in that campaign. So while the combat phase concludes about page 85, Heller fits in some incredible stories. Another of these is the posting of an insane commanding officer (a favourite of MacArthur) to his unit. It just boggles the mind that such a thing could happen! Following the war he continues in the Reserve and again, there are some great stories about preparing a unit for war (Korea) and re-invigorating another that was failing.
After a slightly stolid beginning (lots of commas and brackets, many names) this story blossomed into a truly remarkable read. Heller shows the benefit of an extensive education. He has a lot to say and he says it in a very fluent manner. Aside from WW2 he has a lot of insightful things to say about the Japanese, during the Occupation, and the US army across several decades. The connections that can come from army service are amazing. There is also very interesting material on Pre-war Austria and frankly, much else. His perspective as a new American and an academic make this memoir stand out in many ways. Yes, it is a touch indulgent but Heller is entitled to that. I am just grateful that he has published his amazing story.
PS : Note on rating - This is a 5 star book in every way, however on the more narrow basis of my focus on combat, I give it 4. While Heller's revelations are incredible, they are of a different level to those of Eugene Sledge and others on my list and I want to rank it accordingly.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No