From School Library Journal
PreSchool-A collection of standard nursery rhymes with embroidered illustrations. Each selection is simply there; no natural groupings seem to occur. One or two rhymes and accompanying pictures are displayed within a patchwork border. The art lacks the fine detail of well-embroidered pieces; the fabric is more prominent than the stitchwork. The size of each person, animal, or thing is too constant throughout, giving the book a monotonous look. The strength of the artwork is the subtle use of characters of different ethnic backgrounds. The playfulness of the rhymes will catch children's attention; however, the illustrations are not attractive or varied enough to sustain that interest. For a comprehensive collection in which the rhymes and illustrations flow naturally from one to the next, try Michael Foreman's Mother Goose (Harcourt, 1991). For a beautiful, timeless collection of the standards, take a look at Elizabeth Harbour's A First Picture Book of Nursery Rhymes (Viking, 1996).
Dawn Ibey, Vancouver Public Library, CanadaCopyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Ages 3^-5. Downes' method of illustration is embroidery, and she puts her stitchery to good use in this collection of nursery rhymes. All the favorites are here: "Old King Cole," "Jack and Jill," Mary and her lambs, but here they are executed in snippets of material highlighted with tiny stitches. The collage artwork is most noteworthy on the cover; inside, not all the pieces are sharply reproduced. The book has the advantage of going beyond the Mother Goose canon into other familiar rhymes such as "Monday's Child." Little ones will enjoy the pictures, and so will the mothers who read it to them.
Ilene Cooper
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.