Customer Reviews

Stoic

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

"Stoic" is entirely set in a prison cell shared by four prisoners. An argument during a card game soon spiral into bullying, violence and death. "Stoic "i s quite different from most of Uwe Boll's other movies. The movie is not light entertainment. It's a 90 minute study in human cruelty and violence. It's brutal and disturbing and certainly not for all tastes but it's fascinating in a way and the actors all do a good job.

I love a good horror film, and I don't often see good ones these days. So many horror films have jumped on the "torture porn" bandwagon, and have replaced suspense, tension, and an exploration of the darkest parts of human nature with outrageous gory stunts being performed on half-baked characters (Yes, makers of the "Saw" franchise, I'm talking to you!)

"Stoic" is a horror film in the truest sense of the word, because it is a truly horrifying depiction of the darkest, sickest, most cruel and cowardly aspects of human nature. Four petty criminals (not murderers or rapists, but in jail for minor drug offenses, robbery, etc) sit alone in a cell, going about their normal routine of shooting the breeze and playing cards. When one of the foursome places a bet that involves the cost of an unpleasant act (the eating of some toothpaste) and then refuses to follow through, it sets in motion a series of acts which begin as unpleasant, and quickly escalate into abuse, beatings, torture, rape, and murder.

The film does a good job of making the series of events seem believable. The young men are all caged, angry, scared, and, most of all, determined to maintain their reputations as tough and a part of the group. Whenever any of the characters display a slight sense of apprehension or conscience, the other characters are quick to instill in them the fear of the consequences of going against the pack. The film cuts from the showing of the events that led up to the death of the victim with interviews with the three perpetrators following the crime. Ultimately, each of the characters is processing the events in a different way, which vary from cold detachment, complete denial, and sniveling regret.

Director Uwe Boll is about to release a film about Auschwitz. "Stoic" was probably good exercise for that film, since it depicts a microcosm of the kind of group psychosis which led to the events in Nazi Germany.

I must say that I don't care about Uwe Boll's reputation, even though he has made some bad movies. Now, Stoic is set entirely in a prison cell with sequences of fighting, rape and sodomy, and abuse. If you can't handle those things, turn away from this movie. Each set of abuse is divided by interviews with three of the cell mates that do a great job at acting. Good news, the shaky camera isn't as annoying as it was in Rampage and Darfur.
The ending is what really brings it down a star for me because I just didn't agree with it factually. This was a great movie with minimal plot, which Uwe is actually good at doing because I personally don't think that he writes well. I could watch it again, but I would probably watch it with the commentary or just the special features. Once you watch it once, you don't feel the urge to really watch it again. Rent it and see for yourself.

A film by Uwe Boll in documentary style. The story centers around four prisoners in a cell and the events that unfold therein. The film cuts between the events in the cell and the prisoners being interviewed and giving their take on those events.

WARNING! This film depicts extremely violent events unfolding as well as very strong language and various obscene acts. It is definitely not for anyone under 18 and may be highly distasteful to some viewers. Enter at your own risk, so to say.

Plot (SPOILERS): Four prisoners shoot the breeze and decide to play a card game and gamble. One prisoner loses a bet and refuses to pay up, resulting in his being bullied, brutally beaten, forced to perform obscene acts, and brutally raped. I won't give away the end.

I gave it 5 stars because I felt that the style Boll was going for was done well and came off as realistic as any documentary you would see on TV. The actors all did an excellent job in making this feel as real life as possible. They made you feel that you were seeing actual people who were real prisoners.

I'm not sure if this is correct information, but I have read that this film was based on actual events that occurred in a German prison.

Back in the 70's a film called "Short Eyes" was released. It had the same type of plot, and I found that movie to be more convincing than this one. The actors were drab, the cutaway scenes of them telling their stories of what happened was a bore. They sure don't make prison movies like they used to. Short Eyes was much much better.