From Publishers Weekly
In a lively and original tale of the Old West, Brooks takes potshots at the conventional understanding of what really happened to Billy the Kid in that fateful ambush in 1881. Brooks has penned a dozen conventional westerns (Return to No Man's Land, etc.), but here he attempts a bit of whimsical revisionist history. Two narrators tell the story. One is Billy; the other is Manuella, Billy's lover of many years. In a casual vernacular, Billy maintains that he was not killed by sheriff Pat Garrett that night at Pete Maxwell's ranch. Now, 27 years later, in 1908, he claims he wasn't even there, and that Garrett shot the wrong man and lied to cover it up. Too ashamed to admit his mistake, Garrett gets everyone to go along with his version of the story, and the public heaves a sigh of relief, pleased the Kid is dead. The real Billy spends years hiding out, planning to get even with Garrett some day. Meanwhile, he and Manuella travel, gamble and work at odd jobs to survive, their feelings for each other growing cooler each day as they realize that expedience is all that keeps them together. Manuella pines for a dead outlaw husband and blames Billy for her loss. He dreams of the good old days when the infamous Lincoln County War thinned out the ranks of feuding cowboys, and Billy was a popular hero or a vicious killer depending on who you talked to. Pat Garrett was actually murdered in an ambush in New Mexico in 1908, and the killer was never identified. Did Billy finally get his revenge, or is he just a fat old man wishing he had? Only he and Manuella know for sure. This well-crafted tale is a graceful song, alive with drama, biting wit and just enough well-substantiated doubt to make you wonder.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
*Starred Review* Here's a marvelous what-if novel that explores the possibility--believed by many to be true--that Sheriff Pat Garrett didn't kill Billy the Kid. Nearing 90, living under his given name of Henry McCarty, the man once known as Billy the Kid reflects on a life defined by blood, death, lost love, and regret. Through his journal--with an occasional entry by Manuella, his lover and partner for many years--he carefully reexamines his life, looking for value but finding little that satisfies him. His two best friends--Tom O'Folliard and Charlie Bowdre--were ambushed and killed by Garrett. Charlie was married to Manuella. The subsequent union between Billy and Manuella was cemented less by love than by the ghost of Charlie. Billy, in Brooks' version, only killed those who tried to kill him but, nevertheless, finds himself haunted through the years by the faces of those he has dispatched to the "Stone Garden." Brooks' novel deserves to be mentioned with such western classics as
Shane,
Hombre, and
The Virginian. He captures the everyday humanity behind the legends while simultaneously adding to the myth of the great golden West. This is one of the most inventive, moving, and memorable western novels in many years.
Wes LukowskyCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
