|
| |||||||||||||||
|
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Nice comeback,
By
This review is from: Stone Temple Pilots (Audio CD)
Okay, honestly, this is more of a three-and-a-half star review. As a fan of STP over the years, I love that they've stayed on course..... ironically meaning that they've released another album that sounds like none of their other albums.
That being said, there are some tracks that sound like what you'd call "vintage STP." "Take A Load Off," for example, has the soaring chorus (with Scott once again employing the use of the word "Yeah" in place of something with meaning....... I'm so glad he's out of Velvet Revolver......), with a grungy verse. As soon as you move on to "Huckleberry Crumble," it becomes more obvious that the DeLeo's have been thinking 60's and 70's rock. While some people lament the fact that some of the tracks on here sound like old Aerosmith and Bowie ("First Kiss On Mars"), I ask "why lament?" Bowie and Aerosmith haven't done music as good as their seventies stuff since.... well... the seventies, so why not get some great music in that style done by somebody else? "Hickory Dichotomy" has a great funky groove and is definitely among the best tracks on the album. Not surprisingly, they released the best tracks for streaming about three weeks before the album was available, so it's when you move on to the other tracks, the disappointment sets in. "Dare If You Dare" has a great, very DeLeo guitar riff and verse melody ripped from what could be an unreleased "Sgt. Pepper" song, but the chorus is so insipid both in lyrics and vocal delivery, that it's almost worth skipping altogether. "Cinnamon" is a gem, though. Does it sound like good Oasis? It does. But note the word "good." (But Scott's back to his "I can use the word 'Yeah' for a full chorus!' thing....) "Hazy Daze" has a similar problem to "Dare If You Dare" - it's got an amazing riff, good verse and bridge, but the chorus doesn't fit the music. (Am I being nitpicky? Yes. But I've had these opinions about all of Weiland's material...... back to when he ruined some great music on Contraband with bad melodies.) "Bagman." Straightforward rocker. Another early streaming track and concert teaser that's great as a shout-along. "Peacoat." The first truly forgettable song on here. I liken it to the songs on "Shangri-La-Di-Da" that I can hum along to but don't know lyrics or title, as they weren't impressive enough to learn. I will never know that this song is called "Peacoat." "Fast As I Can" is not, as I'd thought, a recording of a song of the same name done by STP's former moniker "Mighty Joe Young." It's fun, but fits in the exact place as other songs of this type.... for some reason, his is the place in the album (third or so from the end) where all rock bands drop a track that's a forgettable rocker. It's not bad, and it's got a great beat, but it's placed on the album in a way that it disappears. "First Kiss On Mars" is a Beatles tune sung by David Bowie. And it's awesome. I haven't listened to the lyrics enough to be sure that they mean absolutely nothing in relation to the title, but this one has it all - good 60's riff, good verses and a flowing chorus (which could very easily have been "Yeah, it's over," but maybe Scott's expanding his vocabulary). "Maver" - the usual mellow finale to the album. Glam rock neuvo-country. Decent. Forgettable. As I said, three and a half out of five. When it's good, it's great, but there's the usual amount of dead wood. Worth a listen, though. And if you're open to something that isn't exactly like what you remember STP to be, it's pretty solid.
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Blend Of Purple & No. 4,
By
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Stone Temple Pilots (Audio CD)
As a starting point, I have been a STP fan since Core. To give you a reference point of my taste over their career, I thought Core was outstanding, same for Purple even though it was a much softer sound. Tiny Music was mostly just a boring album, but No. 4 was a hard return to form. Shangri-La Dee Da wasn't bad, but it never hooked me and lives in the same space as Tiny Music for my ears.
Anyone who has followed the band through the years has had many ups and downs as Weiland has struggled to stay above his addictions, but news of a new album has always been welcome. Now that's it finally hear, how does this self-titles stack up? Let's go through it song by song: 1. Between The Lines - A good mix of Purple and No. 4 to me, and great to hear that no matter his personal troubles Weiland still have a commanding voice. Easy to hear why this is the song they performed on their first time back to Letterman in a decade. 2. Take A Load Off - Very Purple. The main riff is a solid backing to lyrics that seem to wander about in contemplation. I'd imagine the trademark 'Weiland dance' will accompany this in concert. 3. Huckleberry Crumble - So far, my favorite track on the album. Seems very '70s to me for some reason, but the main chorus is a freight train of listenability and makes the whole song work. 4. Hickory Dichotomy - Again, a very 70s feel. Trippy and light, very radio friendly if not particularly memorable. 5. Dare If You Dare - This seems straight out of No. 4, almost a spiritual companion to Sour Girl. A good mid-album tune. I dig the slight edge Weiland puts on his voice here. 6. Cinnamon - Man, this is a strange one for me. It's not bad, but it's not the type of song I ever expected from STP. This sounds more like Kaiser Chiefs to me. Again, not bad, just different. 7. Hazy Daze - This sounds like what I'd imagine Rage Against The Machine would have sounded like with Jimi Hendrix on guitar. Heavy and catchy, another standout track. 8. Bagman - Ah, back to Purple. I can see this is a single, and no doubt this is the type of song that will get the multiple Beatles sound comparisons. Substitute the word 'Batman', takes on a while new meaning! 9. Peacoat - The Bowie influence can be heard clearly in the vocals on this track, which is slower but still a good listen. Some cool guitar work going on in this one. 10. Fast As I Can - Just like that, the tempo picks up. This sounds like a lost track off of No. 4. A bit harder, a bit faster, a lot arena rock. Nifty guitar solo towards the end. 11. First Kiss On Mars - Back to Bowieville, and I would guess based on the title that it was no accident. Spacey and poppy. 12. Maver - This one reminds me of Tiny Music for some reason. Not bad, but forgettable. 13. Samba Nova - Again, a fusion of Purple and No. 4 as we get a trippy 60s tune to finish out the new material. Likeable, and a good way to close the album. 14. Vasoline (Live) - Being that I liked Purple, this is a nice extra track. Good performance of a well-known tune. 15. Hickory Dichotomy (Live) - Always good when a live performance of a song is so close to the recorded version that the review of the album version still applies. 16. Between The Lines (Live) - Weiland sounds a lot like Kurt Cobain in this recording, but that could just be me. A good performance of a great song.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
These guys can't catch a break,
By Da Peace Dogg (Hollywood) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Stone Temple Pilots (Audio CD)
It's 2010. The Stone Temple Pilots have released six brilliant and diverse studio albums, and all critics seem to want to do is prattle on about how Scott Weiland once mimicked Eddie Vedder in a video from 1993. Or talk about his drug use.
So here's the real scoop on STP's latest CD: It's quite possibly the best one of their storied career (which is saying a lot) and one of the best rock and roll albums I've heard so far this year. While Nickelback and Daughtry sell records by the boatload, the more talented STP is getting drowned under by ridiculous hack reviewers who write for meaningless publications and select fans who want nothing more than a recreation of "Purple." Give these guys a Grammy and quit comparing them to other bands whose sound is every bit as derivative of works from the past.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Passionate about music?
Learn more at SoundUnwound, the personal music encyclopedia, or challenge your friends with our music quizzes.