Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Forensic Mystery, August 4, 2008
This review is from: The Stones Cry Out: A Novel (Paperback)
Prefacing this review, I usually don't read CSI type mysteries. I didn't enjoy geology in all of my schooling, so I come at this book with prejudices. I desire to be fair and allow those who do enjoy these sciences to know this is a very nice debut for author, Sibella Giorello.
The novel, set in Virginia, is well conceived. The writing was quite nicely composed. The protagonist, FBI agent Raleigh Harmon, is an engaging, slightly cynical, somewhat dissolusioned female FBI agent asked to investigate the plunge of two men off a warehouse. One, an African American advocate, and the other a white police officer. Accident? Tied to a civil rights rally taking place below them? Conspiracy? Soil samples, training, and geological finds help Raleigh determine this case even when the FBI commands, "Drop the investigation."
Adding some levity to this offering are a cast of eccentric characters and the fact that Raleigh remains hopeful. She has a deep seeded Faith, which is gently sprinkled among the pages, but never in a "bible thumping" way.
Enjoyable. Mystery and forensic fans you will really click with this tale. It just wasn't my cuppa.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
God is in the details, February 1, 2007
This review is from: The Stones Cry Out: A Novel (Paperback)
In the middle of a winter spent slogging through "Collapse" and Cormac McCarthy's "The Road," it was time for something, shall we say, easier on the psyche. "Elmore Leonard," I thought while wandering around Amazon. "The Stones Cry Out" caught my attention instead. Lucky me. And I was lucky for the same reasons you will be when you order this debut novel from Pulitzer-nominated journalist Sibella Giorello: A tight, tidy mystery supporting the travails of a smartly human heroine impelled by a burly but nuanced prose that simply won't let you go, even after the last sentence. - maybe because of the last sentence.
In TSCO We are introduced to Raleigh Harmon, an FBI agent in the Richmond, VA field office, brought in to investigate two deaths during a civil rights rally. Ms. Harmon is tasked to ask perfunctory questions and quickly wrap up her investigation. But luckily for all - especially readers - she is an individual whose faith and sense of duty won't simply let her walk away from the many tough questions left unanswered. The novel becomes, then, both the compelling mystery of its billing as well as the delicate examination of a woman affirming that while the world is in fact a hard place, it is also the only place in which one can attain their own redemption - and it is, finally, our own actions that allow one to attain it.
Ms. Giorello knows her stuff, and her storytelling demonstrates it. This novel is very well researched, coursing along over a bed of historical and scientific accuracy compelling in its fascinating detail and overall relevance, providing a savvy momentum to the plot. But these are only undercurrents. The novel's real heft is found in characters that you can look in the eye, secure in your belief in who they are. No one in this novel is a caricature - though you'll recognize people in it. Instead, through spare constructions of action and dialogue, Ms. Giorello allows the reader just those perfect little glimpses that ultimately result in the fully fleshed. I was startlingly aware of this late in the book in a scene in which a perpatrator has been chased into a high walled cemetary. Raleigh realizes she is standing at just the angle she needs to see him clearly, while he has no idea he is seen. And this is what the author has built throughout - a vantage from which you know you are seeing clearly the details you need to put it all together. But you have to work to get there - this is no simple yarn, and Ms. Giorello has authored a work that requires you to participate is using information, inference and instinct to deduce. Its a killer book.
Finally, I want to alert readers that you may find this novel marketed through mostly christian book lists, and there is a strong reference to Raleigh Harmon's faith throughout the book. But this is like saying Flannery O'Connor wrote for a Catholic audience. Raleigh's devout christianity is elemental to her character - she's not Raleigh without it. This novel though is deserving of a far wider audience and I hope the audience finds it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Understated and Confident, January 29, 2007
This review is from: The Stones Cry Out: A Novel (Paperback)
A few months back, I heard that a Pulitzer-nominated author was putting out a debut novel, "The Stones Cry Out." Being a big fan of Rick Bragg (another nominee), I found my interest heightened by the shared Southern background of Sibella Giorello and Mr. Bragg. The title and cover of this new book added to the intrigue. What was the book about? Did it even matter? Good stuff coming down the pike. I was sure of it.
And then I got my copy. I started reading. I kept turning the pages. Within a few days, I'd devoured this richly drawn mystery. Not only does Giorello draw memorable characters, she creates evocative settings and rapid-paced dialogue. Her main character is Raleigh Harmon, an FBI agent caught up in a criminal investigation that's become a civil rights powderkeg in modern-day Richmond. A white police officer and a young black man are both deceased, after falling simultaneously from an abandoned building. Which one was the victim? Was this a racially motivated incident?
Like Sigmund Brouwer's Nick Barrett mysteries ("Out of the Shadows"), and my own Aramis Black novels ("The Best of Evil"), Giorello writes contemporary fiction with a spiritual edge and Southern ambiance. She gives us a great lead in Raleigh, a woman facing pressure from corrupt officials, hard-nosed superiors, and her own mother who is clinging by a thread to mental stability. Raleigh also deals with old romantic interests, while enduring some heart-stopping threats. Her emotional detachment after one particular scene is a case-study in understated, yet fully-developed, inner struggle. This is the work of a gifted and confident author.
I look forward to the continued intrigues of Raleigh and her Richmond setting. I hope this book finds the wide audience it deserves. It remains to be seen whether a modern mystery, told with great style and skill, belongs with a title and cover that indicate a more traditional literary novel, especially when coupled with Giorello's writing resume. Either way, "The Stones Cry Out" is a clear statement from Revell Books that great fiction will not be overlooked in this market.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Mystery, a Ministry, a Blessing
Sibella Giorello, disguised as FBI Special Agent Raleigh Harmon, has created a truly amazing, intriguing, gripping, exciting, suspenseful, absolutely beautiful, poetic, flowing,...
Read more
Published 10 months ago by just Frank
|