20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fragile, funny men, November 28, 2008
This review is from: Stooges Among Us (Paperback)
We've been very fortunate to have seen several excellent books on the Stooges recently. But, for my money, one of the finest reads of late is "Stooges Among Us", compiled by Lon and Debra Davis.
Through essays by those who met the Stooges in their waning years, it paints an extraordinarily human portrait of elderly Stooges who are proud of their accomplishments, appreciative of their young fans, and perhaps just a little bitter about their stature in the realm of film comedy. How would they react knowing, today, they're better remembered than Laurel & Hardy or the Marx Brothers?
While people like Stan Laurel and Groucho Marx were feted by the young up-and-comers who grew up in their shadows (Dick Van Dyke, Dick Cavett), the Stooges - as befitting their everyman status - opened their doors to teenage boys who would ultimately become the film scholars keeping their legend alive today.
The most interesting part of "Stooges Among Us" is what it reveals about the relationship between Moe and Larry, who - after 50 tumultuous years together - may have formed a brotherly bond beyond what Moe shared with his actual brothers, Curly and Shemp. With their careers over and little in common beyond so many years of Stoogedom, flinty Moe (in robust health and living quite comfortably) and laidback Larry (wheelchair bound in a small apartment) become gentle caricatures of their onscreen personas, in a sort of "Sunshine Boys" scenario that's fragile, funny, and touching. I can't recommend this one enough.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A good book among us, July 9, 2008
This review is from: Stooges Among Us (Paperback)
There's something about seeing old Stooges in photos that's really intriguing. As years progressed in their career, The Three Stooges (especially in the 60s), became cartoonish in appearance anyway--sort of caricatures of themselves. I love the photos of old Moe with the full bangs of silver hair (sans shoe-polish black hair dye). It's nice to know these old guys loved their fans. That's what you ultimately take away from this book.
The book's concept is a fresh one and the editors have done a very fine job assembling some fun stories and anecdotes, straight from the fans who had the great fortune of meeting the Stooges decades ago. Fans will eat this book up. It's a neat perspective on the whole Stooges fascination and craze.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Would you personally like to meet Moe & Larry? You can here!, August 31, 2008
This review is from: Stooges Among Us (Paperback)
When I first heard there was another book about the Stooges coming out I had a luke-warm reaction. Like "What more can be said that hasn't been said in the many other books."
What is missing from most of the other books is the personal interaction of the Stooges. Moe's book (published two years after his death from his incomplete notes) is strangely cold, it never lets you understand how they felt & interacted with each other. Moe's book (not this one) makes you feel like Shemp just kind of came into the group, and then died. Nothing about what it was personally like to work with him.
Now enters the book "STOOGES AMONG US"! Here is a book written by the many people who have come in personal contact with the Stooges. They talk in detail of meeting them from the points of a family member, co-worker, friend, and fan. Their conversations with the Stooges have never been documented like this before.
When I first picked up this book & started reading in, I was suddenly transported into Larry's room at the Motion Picture Country House in Woodland Hills, California. Yes, this book made me feel like it was me there in Larry's presence, talking to him, learning his personal view of being a Stooge. 'Hearing' him talk of Curly's ill health in 1945, suspecting the strokes had started then. I wrote of this same incident in my DVD review of the Three Stooges Volume 4, but before I had read this book. To read Larry re-enforcing my observations was rewarding. To feel like I was actually meeting him was a pleasure. But there is a startling reference made by Larry hinting to some friction between him & Moe over his book "A STROKE OF LUCK". We fans like to think of Larry & Moe as long time friends, but it seems things got touchy near the end of their lives.
Through another writer we get to visit Moe & his wife Helen in their Hollywood Hills home, watching the Watergate Trials on television! Moe's interview (done years before his autobiography got published) reveals a few of his personal feelings of working with his brothers. Surprisingly, little was said about Larry here, Curly was Moe's focus.
The two Joes are also visited, Besser prefers to talk about his other work (his future book title "Not Just A Stooge" proves this), DeRita was a little harder to approach but did come around.
We even get to 'talk' to Emil Sitka!
Those that worked with the Stooges in the early days also reflect on their memories, brief as some are. But even these short chapters lend some new insight into what it was like working with the boys. Even child star "Baby Peggy" has fond memories of Ted Healy, because he was sober around her family. But then, Ted was not her boss.
There are also some brief histories of the Stooges which knowledgeable fans will just skim over, as I did. They are too brief to give any new information not in other books, just there to refresh our memories. Fortunately they are not the focus of the book.
The main asset of this book is that it allows those of us who never had the opportunity to visit with the Stooges, to do so. While I did see them on stage as a child in the 1960's, that is not the same. Before I got old enough to travel to California and visit them, they were gone from this world. Now, with this book, I feel like I have visited them!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No