5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Eyeing This Storm, November 11, 2009
This review is from: The Storm in the Barn (Hardcover)
If you're looking for a page-turning graphic novel that is both educational and kid-friendly, look no further than The Storm in the Barn by Matt Phelan. This riveting story of one family's struggle during The Dust Bowl is not to be missed.
Kansas circa 1937 is shown through the eyes of an eleven year old boy named Jack Clark. While a bunch of bullies swings at him with their fists and their harsh words, a dust storm blows through town, and Jack runs off. Soon, we meet his family: Pa is gruff, Ma is sad, his sister Dorothy is sick, and his littlest sister, Mabel, has never seen rain. Jack overhears the doctor telling his father that Dorothy's condition is called "dust pneumonia," and that a new trend, "dust dementia," has started to spread. After seeing an odd face in the abandoned Talbot farm, Jack begins to worry that he too has been made ill by the storm.
Using pencil, ink, and watercolor, Phelan has created stark, dusty images of distinct, proud characters that will certainly stay with the reader. As Jack's level of courage goes up and down, so does his posture: sometimes he is slouched, and he often hides his eyes under the brim of his hat, but when push comes to shove, he stares, he shouts, and he stands straight up. There are wordless panels which express a great deal, such as the two panels on one of my favorite pages (199, which comes towards the very end, so don't you dare skip ahead!)
With her songs and and her smile, little sister Mabel steals every single scene - rather, panel - that she's in. Whenever she was shown skipping around with her umbrella, I thought of the Morton Salt Girl. Her natural curiosity and happiness nicely countered the sadness expressed by other, older characters.
Phelan also weaves in the power of storytelling: While bed-ridden Dorothy reads Ozma of Oz by L. Frank Baum, Ernie down at the General Supply tells young Jack tall tales which always star a courageous boy named Jack.
Highly recommended for young readers and their families.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dynamic and taut, September 26, 2009
This review is from: The Storm in the Barn (Hardcover)
I've enjoyed his illustrations in the books written by others. With this, the first both written and illustrated by Matt Phelan, he delivers a well paced graphic story. Set in and during the dust-bowl, the young protagonist is looking for his place in the world, and his family. Tall tales help, and adventures await.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A wonderful addition to not only graphic-novel collections, but to children's fiction in general, November 2, 2009
This review is from: The Storm in the Barn (Hardcover)
Eleven-year-old Jack's life is as bleak as the dust fields that used to be his family's farm. In Kansas in 1937, nobody grows much more than dust and farmers are packing up and moving away every day. Trapped as a boy when he should be learning to be a farmer, Jack's life is made worse by town bullies and by his sister Dorothy's serious illness. The only bright spot is when Dorothy reads to him from L. Frank Baum's Oz books, popular fantasies of the time. Jack soon finds himself in a different fantasy, though, when he starts seeing mysterious lights in an abandoned barn. But is Jack really seeing a strange figure with a face like rain or is the dust getting to him, causing a sort of "dust dementia"?
Quiet and pale, Phelan's tale is as deceptively simple as dust itself. There is not a lot of dialogue; the characters' words have dried up even as their town has. But the few words that are spoken have the power to either strip a soul bare like a dust storm on the rampage or to quench the thirst of a soul in need. Both types of words are offered to Jack, but it is the soothing relief of the later type that gives him the strength to survive the adventure awaiting him. The owner of the local general store tells him of the exploits of the Jack of legends to bolster him after he is bullied by local kids and his delicate sister reads to him about the experiences of the literary Dorothy. Baum's words in particular hit Jack hard as it is clear that Baum knows Kansas and knows of the hardship and wonder of life on the plains.
Even if Phelan doesn't have his characters talk much, they still communicate plenty. Jack's pained face is echoed by his long-suffering mother and father. The harshness of life has obviously scarred the townspeople and their struggles are evident in their body language. Phelan makes good use of the comic medium, allowing his tale to slowly unfold over the course of as many panels as are needed. He often utilizes closeups to make a point or to clarify a detail. Color is judiciously dealt out. Much of the story is in muted browns, tans, and greys, but the colors become more vibrant when Jack's mother speaks of her childhood in a green and fertile Kansas or when the shopkeeper tells stories of the folkloric Jack. One scene--a brutal jackrabbit "drive," where jackrabbits are herded together and slaughtered--is especially powerful. A single bright red panel is used to show the results of the hunt, and later a bright red haze of anger slowly fades from the hunters as their bloodlust cools.
There are some harsh topics in this story, but nothing that is beyond the grasp of an older elementary-school student, fifth grade and up. Phelan's historical fiction title is a wonderful addition to not only graphic-novel collections, but to children's fiction in general. It does not talk down to readers, but presents the hardships of the Dust Bowl in a clear, accessible format. This should be picked up by schools and added to reading lists. It is a wonderful work by a talented creator.
-- Snow Wildsmith
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
