Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
thought provoking civil war novel for young people, January 14, 2011
This review is from: The Storm Before Atlanta (Hardcover)
There's no shortage of historical fiction novels for children about the Civil War, but with the 150th anniversary of the outbreak of the conflict this year, this thought-provoking new novel by Karen Schwabach is a worthy addition to any school or public library's collection. The novel tells the story of ten year old Jeremy, who wants nothing more than to enlist in one of the New York regiments of the Union Army as a drummer boy and gloriously die for his country. Continually told he's too young to enlist, he goes off to find the war himself--to follow the army until they take him. Soon he joins up with the 107th New York Regiment from Elmira, takes his oath, and gets a uniform, a pair of shoes, the promise of $13 a month, and best of all, a glorious drum. Traveling to Georgia, Jeremy and the 107th become part of a new corp led by General Hooker, on the march. "They were not told where they were going or why. It wasn't a soldier's business to know that." But Jeremy can't wait to "see the elephant," as the soldiers called those who had seen action, but all they seem to do is march and wait.
We're also introduced to to two other key characters, whose lives will become intertwined with Jeremy's: Dulcie, a spunky and very bright slave girl who runs away from her cruel mistress to find the Union Army, and eventually becomes a medic for a Union field doctor, and a friendly young Confederate soldier, Charlie Jackson, just a bit older than Jeremy, who's looking to trade for coffee or anything else.
War isn't as black and white as Jeremy had imagined back home. Jeremy knows that Charlie shouldn't really be his friend, but he's hungry for company his own age. And Charlie, on the Confederate side, wonders why he's fighting a war started by a bunch of rich men who "Told us we had to stand by the South. Then they went home to their families, to watch their slaves makin' money for 'em." And both sides learn that war is more about rain and mud and staying alive than glory and being a hero.
Schwabach creates sympathetic characters in her three young protagonists, as well as a very convincing sense of place. The reader feels right there in the middle of the action, as 98,000 Union soldiers march into Georgia complete with hundreds of wagons, cattle to be butchered, ambulances, servants, contraband slaves, and even some dogs and a pet pig. We experience along with Jeremy and Dulcie the chaos, blood, and horrors of the battlefield and its aftermath. There's plenty of action, drama, and even a surprise ending (no spoilers here!) as Jeremy and his comrades in the First Division march closer to Atlanta.
The author includes a brief historical note with additional background information about the characters, many of whom were real people, and a bibliography of selected sources.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Searching for the elephant, January 3, 2011
This review is from: The Storm Before Atlanta (Hardcover)
Eleven-year-old Jeremy dreams of leaving Upstate New York to die nobly in battle like the famed Drummer Boy of Shiloh. He cannot remember his mother, and his father is currently a long-term guest of Auburn State Prison. He has run away from the man whose bond he was put into after his father's arrest, and ended up in Syracuse as a paper boy.
But every time he tries to join the army to be a drummer boy so that he can achieve his dream of heroic death, he is told eleven is too young. Finally, he decides to leave New York, head south and try again. This time, he succeeds in joining New York's 107th. When he finally achieves his dream, he learns that battle was not what he dreamed it to be.
He befriends a young runaway slave who has also joined New York's 107th as a medic. Dulcie's outlook on the war is very different from Jeremy's. Also eleven, she has "seen the elephant," a thing which Jeremy longs for. Highly intelligent, Dulcie understands the horrors of war, as well as the horrors of slavery, and longs to see the end of both.
Jeremy also makes friends with a young Confederate, Charlie. Charlie is two or three years older, but is always friendly to Jeremy. Jeremy learns a lot about slavery and the South from him, but Charlie as a larger secret...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
War is hell, January 3, 2011
This review is from: The Storm Before Atlanta (Hardcover)
The Civil War as seen through the eyes of an 11 year-old drummer boy - he went in search of Glory, and learned to hope that he and his messmates would just survive somehow -
This is a fascinating book, providing meticulous details of the later Civil War as well as an eerie penetration into the mindset of the two opposing forces. One can't help but feel that some universal truths emerge about the means by which soldiers are recruited so that wars can be prosecuted. None of this is forced on the reader, though. What appears is just a good action story, some captivating anecdotes about small southern political groups fighting for peace and union (or re-union,) and a cast of characters - mostly children - whose involvement in the war is at once horrifying and inevitable.
All three of the children who are the principle characters in the book - Jeremy, the 11 year-old newsboy; Dulcie, the self-liberated former slave of roughly the same age; Charley, a few years older but decades wiser than the other two - have run away from terrible circumstances in search of a war that has been sold to them by an older generation.
A wonderful and thought-provoking book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|